Saturday, December 5, 2009

Giving Thanks in Troubled Times

Thanksgiving has come and gone, but gratitude should never be a one-night stand.

Marshall Goldsmith has collected a number of statements from people who, while working their way through troubled times, find time to practice the virtue of gratitude.

Overcoming Troubled Times

A few weeks ago I wrote a post about how life coaching could help people to deal with troubled times. Link here.

Yesterday John Baldoni wrote about how Winston Churchill overcame troubled times. It is well worth a read. Link here.


Friday, December 4, 2009

Coaching Lessons: How to Contribute to the Greater Good

Coaching as self-management. Following Peter Drucker's lead I have been writing a series of posts about how to manage yourself. Here is a link to the last post, which contains links to the previous posts.

Once you know your superskills and the circumstances under which you perform best, and once you know your values and your value, Drucker advises you to take the next step: figuring out where you belong.

Do you belong in a large company or a boutique firm? Would you do best in a department story or a boutique? Would you be happier as a solo practitioner or as a team member?

If you have no organizational skills you should not join a business that requires them. If you work best alone you should be working in a profession that allows for solo practitioners; if you have strong leadership skills you need to find a place where you can exercise those skills.

I would add that you should also choose to live in a community where you feel like you belong. And, if you are going to get married, you should understand that you are going to be part of a new family. If the marriage is to work you will have to feel that you belong in the new family.

Drucker's next question is: What should you contribute?

He does not ask about what you can contribute, but what you should contribute. Once you become part of a company or community your duty is to contribute. You are obliged to work at tasks that will advance the interests of the group you have just joined.

When you work for a company, your personal stamp will involve contributing to the work of the enterprise in an identifiable way.

I mention these points because I want to emphasize the extent to which Drucker sees human beings as social beings not as self-fulfilling monads.

Drucker is not talking about charitable contributions, but he is trying to show how individuals can make a difference, can give something of themselves, and can establish and achieve goals. And yet, when you contribute to a company you are also exercising the virtue of generosity-- giving yourself selflessly.

Interestingly, Drucker sees individual satisfaction linked inextricably to the value of one's contribution to the group's success.

Whether your contribution involves reorganizing the mail room or leading a new marketing campaign or holding morning staff meetings or setting up a suggestion box... you need to have a way to contribute to the company.

Why don't we think more often about contributing? Drucker believes that we have been infected by the values of the 1960s counterculture.

In the post World War II decades most of the workforce had forged its character in the crucible of military service. Men were used to taking orders; they believed in the values associated with military culture; they had seen it work and had seen it achieve victory. They looked for the same strict social organization and uniformity in their work lives.

Then, in the 1060s, as the culture repudiated the Vietnam War and the values involved in being a good soldier, it made people more self-centered, more self-involved, more at odds with group values.

In Drucker's words: "Then in the late 1960s no one wanted to be told what to do any more. Young men and women began to ask: What do I want to do? And what they heard was that the way to contribute was to 'do your own thing.' But this solution was as wrong as the organization man's was. Very few of the people who believed that doing one's own thing would lead to contribution, self-fulfillment, and success achieved any of the three."

This should almost be self evident. If you do your own thing, you are, almost by definition, refusing to do anyone else's thing. Your personal good becomes irrevocably at odds with the good of the group. If this feels like an invitation to an extended adolescent rebellion, that's because it is.

I would add that asking yourself what you really, really want to do forms the basis for the therapy culture. Fulfilling your heart's desire is not the same as discovering your skills, and contributing to a group.

Besides, if you are doing your own thing you are being induced into acting as though you have been cast out, even rejected by the larger group. Since no human being can ever survive for a long time on his or her own, the chances that you will go from doing your own thing to becoming a cult follower are very high indeed.

Drucker's advice is to see your own personal fulfillment as identical with your ability to contribute meaningfully to the well-being of others.




Thursday, December 3, 2009

Does Your Marriage Need Therapy?

Strictly speaking, Elizabeth Weil and Daniel Duane had a good marriage. It was not in any danger; it was not ripe for therapy. It was normal.

To Weil, however, it was not good enough. One evening she had an epiphany that told her that she had been coasting, or drifting, in her marriage, that she was not putting enough work into it, and that she ought to try to make it better.

Being a creature of the therapy culture, and being far too willing to grant credence to various psycho-gurus, Weil and Duane decided to enlist the services of professional marriage counselors, therapists, and psychoanalysts. The culture accredits these people with superior knowledge into the nature of marriage and of how to make it better.

She chronicles her journey-- which feels a bit like Dante's descent into the Inferno-- in a long and fascinating article in the upcoming Sunday Times Magazine. Since the article is available online, I am linking it here.

If you do not dance to the tunes that the therapy culture is playing, you might find it somewhat strange that marital improvement should be the province of mental health professionals.

Before examining Weil's experience I should note that both she and her husband are professional writers. Dan Duane, for example, has written a memoir detailing his sexual history.

The couple in question manifests less than the average quota of modesty. Perhaps they are harbingers of a new age when the intimate details of everyone's marriage is on public display, but, for now, we should recognize that this couple understands what it means to live your life as though it were material for a piece of writing.

Yet, were it not for people like Weil and Duane we would have no way to evaluate the effectiveness of different kinds of therapy. At a time when people are increasingly doubting the value of psychotherapy, it is nearly impossible to know what really goes on in the sanctum sanctorum of the therapist's office.

As Weil notes, people who do therapy are in the business of curing what ails you. If you go to consult one you are induced, by the culture, to discover, even to create, problems that would be of interest to a therapist. You do not want to be rejected by a therapist; you do not want to think that you are wasting your time and money; you must find something that is wrong about your marriage.

Once you create difficulties where there were none, therapy will teach you that they were really always there, like precancerous lesions, and that if you did not expose them they would have come back to haunt you in the future.

Of course, there is no way of proving or disproving the statement in the last paragraph. It is a counterfactual, a possible outcome, and thus cannot be proved or disproved by referring to facts.

For their first exercise Weil and Duane try out one of the exercises proposed by "Oprah-sanctioned self-help guru" Harville Hendrix.

Hendrix recommends that you make a list of all the qualities: "you wish your partner would praise your for but never does and then [you would sit] in a chair as your partner walks circles around you, reading that list in an increasingly loud and emphatic voice."

This is called: "positive flooding." It feels more like dramatized abuse. Your partner walks around you; into your line of sight and out of it; he makes you feel besieged and trapped while he barks out the loving messages you wish he had been whispering in your ear.

This feels to me like a theatrical parody. Your husband reads from a script that you prepared and resents having to read words he did not write. The more he does it the more he becomes loud and emphatic, thus hostile toward you.

Words of affection are transformed into weapons. It is not surprising that Weil: "... began seeing Dan as my adversary." She had managed to negotiate her way to a harmonious family life. Now, however, she reports that: "...the competitive mindset came roaring back, as I reasoned, unconsciously anyway, that any changes we made would either be toward Dan's vision of the marriage and away from mine or the other way around."

Now, her marriage has been reduced to a competitive struggle in a zero-sum game. Like any abuse victim you will first start thinking that there is something wrong with you. Therapy can then induce you to start questioning your marriage: "What if my good marriage was teetering of a precipice and any change would mean a toppling, a crashing down?"

Among the issues they had negotiated was an equitable division of household labor. He cooked; she dealt with the finances.

But Weil was not entirely happy with the arrangement because she did not like it that her husband spent too much time and money cooking restaurant-quality meals.

Encouraged by a workshop to express all of her feelings, the better to allow her husband to respond with scripted empathy, Weil began confessing her discomfort with their cooking arrangement. From there she moved on to confessions of childhood and adult indiscretions.

She could do it because she knew that her husband was going to respond, as scripted, with proper empathy.

Of course, there might have been a real problem with the division of household labor. And empathy was surely not going to put anyone on the road to solving it.

What if Weil was unhappy about the fact that she, a mother, had nothing to say about feeding her children. That would have required us to refer to more traditional roles, and such thoughts seem never to have crossed anyone's mind.

And while we all admire Dan Duane for preparing three gourmet meals a day, might it not also be the case that he was simply a frustrated chef? Could he have missed his true calling? Should he consider working as a chef?

Again, that would have been too practical-minded. The emotional haze that had enveloped their marriage was making it impossible for them to look at any practical issues, no less to solve them.

For a time these open-air confessions worked. The couple was having better sex. But then Weil "recoiled" because she seemed to recognize that the empathy was forced; it was being spoken on cue, as though from a script. She starting thinking, as I would put it, that she and her husband were acting roles in someone else's play.

Next, Weil and Duane went to consult with a psychoanalytic couples counselor. Weil was aware of the pitfalls of this approach: "...the therapy carries not only the threat of learning things about yourself that you might prefer not to know but also the hazard of saying things to your spouse that are better left unsaid, as well as hearing things from your spouse that you might prefer not to hear."

She describes her experience of psychoanalytic counseling thus: "So, instead of speaking our harshest truths, for six weeks running Dan and I pursued the lesser offense of making the other sound crazy. Holly [the analyst] cooperated, too, offering feedback that we used to confirm our sense that the other was neurotic."

Now, armed with psychoanalytic insights Weil started to question everything her husband said to her. If she said she was beautiful, she would ask herself why he was saying it.

After a few weeks of this counseling, the couple had the worse fight of their marriage.

Psychoanalysis teaches that the human family is a cauldron of incestuous longings, homicidal impulses, and rank jealousy. If you are not feeling these things you are not normal; you are certainly not enlightened.

And since psychoanalysis sees the relationship with one's mother as central to all of human experience, it should not be too surprising that Weil and Duane got into a furious fight about her relationship with her mother.

I will not detail all of the drama that these and other therapists produced in this good marriage, but I believe you will be surprised, as I was, to read that at the end of this therapeutically-sanctioned descent into Hell, Weil felt: "more committed than ever." She had, by her lights, gained: "the courage and patience to grow."

Faint praise, indeed. As modest a result as could be expected. But one that is far more positive than the one I would draw. Perhaps the reason is that she was responsible for jeopardizing her marriage, unnecessarily, and now she can hardly say that it was all just a waste of time, a punishing exercise that we should all avoid.

Anyway, she seems to have gotten a book out of it.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

What Is the Difference Between Psychotherapy And Life Coaching?

It may not be the most burning issue of the day, but some people are asking for a better definition of the difference between psychotherapy and life coaching.

Today, I am going to try for clear and succinct, not for theoretical complexity. If "high concept" is a good thing, we should be happy to apply it here.

One caveat: for the purposes of this argument I am only referring to psychotherapy that tries to cure through insight. I exclude cognitive and behavioral exercises because they fall within the realm of retraining, and thus, are closer to coaching than therapy.

Here are some principles, as I have been developing them on the blog.

Psychotherapy is about getting into your mind; life coaching is about getting into your life.

Psychotherapy offers self-knowledge; life coaching aims at self-management.

Psychotherapy is about how you understand yourself; life coaching is about how you conduct yourself with others.

Psychotherapy is an aesthetic; life coaching involves an ethic.

Psychotherapy gives you a front row seat at your life's dramas; life coaching engages you in the work of building your character.

Psychotherapy offers self-knowledge to no particular end; life coaching gives lessons in self-management to help you to get into the game and to play it well.

Psychotherapy wants to discover why you keep getting it wrong; life coaching wants to show you how to get it right.

Psychotherapy wants to know why you can't perform; life coaching wants to help you to perform better.

Psychotherapy claims to offer care and cure for what ails you; life coaching offers guidance to help you improve on your strengths.

Psychotherapy wants you to get in touch with your feelings; life coaching wants you to keep in touch with your friends.

Psychotherapy wants you to accept the worst about yourself; life coaching wants you to see the best in everyone.

Psychotherapy wants you to fulfill your creative potential; life coaching wants you to work hard at what you are best at.

Psychotherapy wants you to blossom; life coaching wants you to excel.

Psychotherapy tries to analyze everything; life coaching is happy to leave well enough alone.

Psychotherapy wants everything to be spoken; life coaching is happy to leave things unsaid.

Psychotherapy looks for problems; life coaching looks for solutions.


What Not to Do When You're Out of Work

The one thing you don't want to do when you are out of work is to act like you're out of work.

This means that you do not want to eat too much, drink too much, shoplift too much, smoke too much, and sleep too little. You do not want to indulge all of your tendencies toward insouciance and terminal coolness.

As more and more of the out-of-work develop some very bad habits, the phenomenon is beginning to attract attention. Link here.

I said as much in other posts (sample here), but apparently people have not been getting the message. Given that this is the most dire employment situation in memory, the worst thing you can do is to let yourself go.

Difficult situations require moral toughness. People feel demoralized and dispirited; they feel unappreciated and unfairly judged. Many have worked very hard, only to find themselves lining up for unemployment and food stamps.

It is all too tempting, under the circumstances, to give up. It is better to see your job search as a new job, to be approached with the same seriousness, the same concentration that you would put into a job that you had.

Yet, once you develop bad habits you cannot just discard them like an old suit.

Some of those who are lounging around the house all day in their pajamas sipping Chardonnay are telling themselves that once a job prospect appears on the horizon they will rouse themselves, clean up, don that nice suit, and march forth to meet the challenge.

Sad to say, it rarely works that way. If you spend all your time indulging your bad habits you will not feel comfortable, you will not feel like yourself, when you dress up for the job interview.

As I like to put it, you will not be wearing your suit; your suit will be wearing you.

A good interviewer, one who has many candidates to choose among, will sense it very quickly and send you back to your bad habits.

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Exit, Pursued By an Angry Wife

I do not know whether public relations is an art or a science, but managing your public image is a vital human undertaking.

It is even more important when you are a world-famous athlete and a major brand.

All told, most of us want to ignore Tiger Woods' recent automobile accident. No schadenfreude there.

Such is the respect we accord to a man who is arguably the greatest athlete of the past decade that we have no interest in seeing him embarrassed. We might gain some satisfaction by watching an arrogant narcissist brought down by his hubris, but Tiger Woods was never that man.

These days Tiger Woods is as close as we get to a great American hero.

Now a coterie of lawyers and PR professions are explaining how Tiger should handle the situation. Mostly they are advising him to hold a press conference and explain what happened. Come clean, they say. Open up, they say. Be honest with the public, they say.

Yet, Tiger Woods did not cheat at golf. He did not enhance his game with controlled substances. He did not commit a felony that might take him off the tour by putting him in jail. Apparently, he was involved in some kind of quarrel with his wife. One fails to see the relevance of a public apology.

One lawyer suggested that what was good for David Letterman should be good for Tiger Woods. As though all celebrities are created equal.

True enough, both Tiger Woods and David Letterman are celebrities. But athletes are not like other celebrities. No one is trying to emulate David Letterman. No executive is trying to apply the secrets of David Letterman's success to corporate leadership.

People emulate Tiger Woods. He is a fierce and successful competitor; he has the demeanor, the focus, and the concentration that befit someone who is the best in the world. And his competitive stance involves excellent character.

Other celebrities, whether stand-up comics, actors, or clowns perform behind masks. They perform a script whose outcome is given in advance. They are not playing in a game; they are playing roles on a stage.

If I had to invent a concept, I would say that athletes, unlike other celebrities, have face in the game. Most true celebrities live lives filled with drama. Whether on the stage or off, they do not compete; they entertain.

Tiger Woods on the golf course is Tiger Woods. He is not playing Tiger Woods. He does not make a living pretending to be someone he is not. He is not acting a role in a movie.

Tiger Woods does not putt from behind a mask. He shows his face. And he uses his face to achieve the focus and concentration, the unflappable demeanor that has inspired people around the world. See my post, "The Eye of the Tiger." Link here.

All of this to say that it is not a simple matter for a Tiger Woods to show off facial injuries in public. It would not be entirely unfair to say that, both literally and figuratively, he seems to have lost some face in his accident.

Think what you will, a man who bears scratches and contusions he suffered at the hand of his wife does not look like a fierce competitor.

Were Woods to go out in public in his current condition, his face would travel around the world in light speed. This would compromise his brand and his self-confidence.

People would be forced to juxtapose the image of the man whose wife beat him with the image of the man who is the ultimate competitor. Worse than that, once everyone is making the comparison, Woods would have that much more difficulty recovering his true face.