Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Living Optimistically


Optimism, it’s more than a feeling.

Or better, optimism is as optimism does.

It feels a bit self-evident, but in the world of therapy it counts as a major discovery.

You do better when you approach life with an optimistic attitude. Having an optimistic attitude involves the way you act, not how you feel.

So, therapy has abandoned the notion that life is about satisfying needs or desires and embraced the notion that life is about success and achievement.

Yet, this has led to some inevitable misunderstandings. Some people believe that optimism is a state of mind.

Psychologist Elaine Fox responds that optimism lies in how you behave, how you act, not how you feel.

She explained it to Jane Brody:

What really makes the difference is action…. If you sit back passively, you won’t get the job you want.

In her book, Rainy Brain, Sunny Brain, Fox wrote:

Optimism is not so much about feeling happy, nor necessarily a belief that everything will be fine, but about how we respond when times get tough. Optimists tend to keep going, even when it seems as if the whole world is against them.

Optimism is less an attitude and more a character trait. It’s less about positive feeling and more about how you conduct your life.

Optimistic people are convinced that they can do it. They take defeat in stride, making it a reason to work harder.

This implies that if you are pessimistic you can become more optimistic by acting as an optimistic person would under the circumstances.

If your gut tells you to give up and you know that an optimistic person would persevere, then you need to force yourself to persevere.

It might not feel right. It might even feel wrong. It’s easier said than done. 

And yet, you only gain optimism by acting as though you are optimistic.

It’s hard work, but then again, significant personal improvement must be earned. It does not descend on you like a gift of prevenient grace.

When therapists talk about optimism they are referring to confidence in your own abilities, not a blind faith in the future. As Fox wrote, optimism is how we react to adversity.

If you do not believe in adversity then clearly you will not know how to deal with it.

Optimism does not make you believe that everything is always going to turn out for the best.

Those who do are making an excuse for being sloppy and slothful.

Optimists do not believe that everything is for the best in the best of all possible worlds. Candide was not an optimist. He was naïve. The two are not the same.

If you refuse to recognize the possibility of calamity you are saying that you have no confidence in your ability to take charge of one.

Optimists are so confident in their abilities that they make plans for the future. And then, they follow the plans.

A plan gives you a sense of control. It factors in the possibility of setbacks. Dr. Fox said: “When you have a setback, you feel you can do something about it.”

If you cannot envision yourself dealing with a setback you will be blindsided. When that happens you will more likely give up.

Giving up because you feel overwhelmed is the definition of depression.

When the LIghts Go Out, Where's Barack?


The president is a Democrat. The mayor of Washington, D.C. is a Democrat. The governor of Maryland is a Democrat.

Ergo, the storm-produced power outage in the mid-Atlantic region is not such a big deal.

If George Bush were in charge, the press would have fanned out over the afflicted area, reporting breathlessly about the people who are suffering and dying from the heat.

After all, 22 people have died. 4.3 million are without power.

Since Barack Obama is in charge, you hear nothing about responsibility.

This morning on Instapundit Glenn Reynolds explained it all in a few short sentences.

If you want to ensure that the power does not go out in a storm, you need to bury the power lines.

If you want to bury the power lines, you need to make some infrastructure investment.

If you want to invest in the power grid, you should not be funneling massive sums of money to alternative energy projects run by your political supporters.

Now, who bears responsibility for this environmental catastrophe?

Of course, if you read the press you would think that the fault lay with global warming. God is punishing us for our profligate use of fossil fuels.

Those who believe in global warming will use this “black swan” event to promote the same bad policies that created the mess in the first place.


Monday, July 2, 2012

Harry Frankfurt, Ann Althouse, and Ludwig Wittgenstein


Happily, Ann Althouse has provided us with an opportunity to ponder the thought of a man who was arguably the greatest philosopher of the twentieth century, Ludwig Wittgenstein.

Yesterday, Althouse offered a meditation on an incident involving involved Wittgenstein and his friend Fania Pascal. The incident was reported in philosopher Harry Frankfurt’s book: On Bullshit. See also Timothy Noah's account here.

One day, in the 1930s, while Fania Pascal was recovering in a hospital after a tonsillectomy Wittgenstein phoned. When he asked how she was, she “croaked: ‘I feel just like a dog that has been run over.’”

Her statement disgusted Wittgenstein, who replied: “You don’t know what a dog that has been run over feels like.”

Reasonably enough, Harry Frankfort fails to understand how anyone could find Pascal’s phrase disgusting. He seems to believe that Wittgenstein was being rude and insensitive.

Maybe she misunderstood him:

Perhaps Wittgenstein was trying to make a small joke, and it misfired. He was only pretending to bawl Pascal out, just for the fun of a little hyperbole; and she got the tone and the intention wrong. She thought he was disgusted by her remark, when in fact he was only trying to cheer her up with some playfully exaggerated mock criticism or joshing. In that case the incident is not incredible or bizarre after all. 

After considering the possibility, Frankfurt rejects it. He is unwilling to believe that Wittgenstein was trying to cheer up his friend. He concludes that she is simply showing us how preposterous Wittgenstein was, as though, Althouse explains, she were making a joke.

Althouse objects to Frankfurt’s reading, first by suggesting, strangely, that Wittgenstein might have been offended by his friend’s insensitivity to the way dogs feel.

But, that too, requires us to take her words literally. If we take them figuratively, Pascal would have been saying that she felt the way we feel when we see a dog that has been run over.

Then, Althouse suggests a new way of helping Wittgenstein to save face:

Pascal wasn't being callous toward an actual suffering being. The suffering being was Pascal, and the callousness, if any, was Wittgenstein's. On this theory, which hurt Pascal's feelings, he was saying, essentially, let's not talk about your mundane little tonsil surgery and its predictable after-effects. Let's talk about something philosophical, and the first thing that springs to mind is that dog you just mentioned. And he introduces the new topic. Ironically, the distraction into the random issue of animal feelings was much more likely to alleviate Pascal's pain that going on about the details of the surgery.

As clever as this is, it misses the point. It assumes a level of social skills that Wittgenstein did not have. Both Frankfurt and Althouse are interpreting the dialogue as though it involved someone who was as socially adroit as they are.

Surely, the exchange demonstrates that Wittgenstein was very likely suffering from Asperger’s syndrome, high-functioning autism that often afflicts people of superior, genius-level intelligence.

Cambridge philosopher Andy Martin explained the reasons for the diagnosis:

Wittgenstein, not unlike someone with Asperger’s, admits to having difficulty working out what people are really going on about. In “Culture and Value” (1914) he writes: “We tend to take the speech of a Chinese for inarticulate gurgling. Someone who understands Chinese will recognize language in what he hears. Similarly I often cannot recognize the humanity of another human being.” 

If Fania Pascal really knew Wittgenstein and understood that he had Asperger’s—less likely— she would have recognized that he was making a philosophical point because he was incapable of recognizing her humanity and did not know how to express sympathy over her condition.

Wittgenstein read her figure of speech within the context of his philosophical reflections, because that was his only context.

Why not extend some generosity to Fania Pascal here too. Perhaps her figure of speech was infelicitous, but, we should not hold her to a very high standard while recovering from for throat surgery.

As for Wittgenstein’s larger point, a point that is of considerable philosophical importance, he was suggesting that words never truly express human feelings.

Since human language is, by definition, a public medium, it cannot accurately communicate something private, like feeling and emotion.

For an extensive treatment of this issue, see Saul Kripke’s: Wittgenstein on Rules and PrivateLanguage.

A private language might be able to do it, but a private language is a contradiction in terms.

The best we can do is to try to evoke an experience that produced a similar feeling. 

So, you have an individual suffering from Asperger's trying to communicate with another person who is recovering from surgery. What you get is miscommunication. 

Enter the Tiger Immigrants


When Americans debate immigration they are usually referring to the influx of illegal immigrants from Mexico and Central America.

We have ignored the fact that, since 2008 America has received more immigrants from Asian nations than from Hispanic nations.

Walter Russell Mead reports the striking statistics:

A report released this month by the Pew Research Center shows just how much the face of immigration has changed in the past few years. Since 2008, more newcomers to the U.S. have been Asian than Hispanic (in 2010, it was 36% of the total, versus 31%). Today's typical immigrant is not only more likely to speak English and have a college education, but also to have come to the U.S. legally, with a job already in place.

What's responsible for the change? The reasons include a rapidly falling birthrate in Mexico, dramatic economic growth there and the collapse of the U.S. residential construction industry—a traditional market for low-skilled, non-English speaking immigrants whose documentation was often subject to question.

Of course, Asian immigrants are less likely to cause trouble, so, we can safely ignore them.

Most often, Asian immigrants enter the country legal, with job offers in hand, bringing with them the good values and work ethic that more and more Americans have lost.

Since American parents and schools are more interested in puffing up children’s self-esteem than inculcating a work ethic and teaching science, math, technology, and engineering… Americans are not qualified for many new jobs.

Mead explains that Asian immigrants have a good work ethic and strong family values:

There also seems to be some truth in the "Tiger Mom" syndrome described by author Amy Chua. While 39% of Asian-Americans say their group puts "too much" pressure on kids to succeed in school, 60% of Asian-Americans think that other Americans don't push their kids hard enough.

Other family values are strong as well, according to Pew. Only 16% of Asian-American babies are born out of wedlock, in contrast to 41% for the general population. In the U.S., 63% of all children grow up in a household with two parents; the figure for Asian-Americans is 80%. Some 66% of Asian-Americans believe parents should have some input into what careers their children select and 61% think that parents have something useful to say about their children's choice of a spouse. The hard work and strong family values appear to pay off: Asian-Americans' median household income is $66,000 (national median: $49,800) and their median household wealth is $83,500 (national median: $68,529).

Mexicans took jobs that Americans did not want to do. Asians take jobs that Americans don’t know how to do.

No one knows how much time it will take, but eventually the wave of Asian immigrants will change the face of America. If Mead is right it will be a change for the better.

Hollowing Out New York's Middle Class


No one knows how long it will take but the decline of New York City seems inevitable.

A city that perfectly embodies the blue state principle, “from each according to his ability [to pay], to each according to his need” depends largely on the ability of the financial services industry to pay the taxes that support big city government and social welfare programs.

The result: in important segments of the labor market New York is no longer competitive.

This morning The New York Times reports on an important trend: mid-level Wall Street jobs are being sent out of New York in what is now being called near-sourcing.

The banks are hiring again, but they are hiring fewer people in New York. Because it costs too much… first, for the banks, and second, for the employees.

It’s an important trend. More and more it is making New York a city that is divided between the rich and the rest.

For the very rich high taxes and a high cost of living do not make much of a difference. The poor do not pay taxes anyway; they are increasingly wards of the government.

For a banker it makes sense? Given the wonders of the internet, why pay more to keep your staff in New York City when you can send it to North Carolina or Utah or Florida and spend less for office space, less in taxes, less for supplies, less for everything.

Since the cost of living in other states is significantly lower than in New York you can pay less and your employees can have as good, if not better quality of life.

The result: New York’s middle class has become an endangered species.

Sunday, July 1, 2012

What Is the Muslim Brotherhood?


It is reported that our Secretary of State-- and media darling-- Hillary Clinton will be the first foreign dignitary to visit the new Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi.

Since Morsi represents the Muslim Brotherhood, the timing of Clinton's visit says that the Obama administration is giving America’s blessing to its rule.

A few days ago French philosophe Bernard-Henri Levy took a few minutes to remind us of the origins of the Muslim Brotherhood. As he puts it, the Brotherhood is “a totalitarian sect inspired by Nazism.”

In his words:

Worse, we can never be reminded enough that the organization whose pale apparatchik is in the process of acceding to the leadership of the largest Arab nation was born in the late '20s as a totalitarian sect, inspired by Naziism, one whose founder, Hassan Al-Banna, never neglected an occasion to inscribe Adolf Hitler after Saladin, Abu Bakr or Abdelaziz al-Saoud in the lineage of "reformers" whose "patience, firmness, wisdom and obstination" had guided humanity.

And this "error of youth," far from being washed away with time, has been constantly reiterated, confirmed, the theorized about -- didn't Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the current guide of the Brotherhood and master, by the by, of a certain Tariq Ramadan, describe Adolf Hitler as the latest-born of these "representatives of Allah" who have appeared regularly to "punish the Jews" for their extreme "corruption," in a January 2009 statement on Al Jazeera, picked up and disseminated by the excellent Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI)?

Being a philosopher BHL remains cautiously optimistic about the possible outcomes, but it is worth our time and effort to recognize the nature of the organization on which Hillary Clinton is rushing to confer legitimacy.

The Last Days of Mary Richardson Kennedy


When the media last looked at the case, it concluded that Mary Richardson Kennedy hanged herself because she was suffering from a borderline personality disorder. That is, because she was mentally deranged.

In the dominant narrative her estranged husband, Robert Kennedy, Jr. fought valiantly to save her from her mental illness. Sadly, her mental illness won out. There was nothing he, or anyone else, could do.

Until now the story of Mary Kennedy’s suicide has been carefully orchestrated by the Kennedy family to protect the Kennedy name. The voice of Mary Richardson Kennedy has effectively been silenced.

See, however, my previous posts.

We all know that there are always two sides to every story, especially stories involving bitterly contested divorces. So, we should never rush to judgment.

This morning, new information reported by the New York Post paints a radically different picture. The information is contained in a petition filed by Mary Kennedy’s former attorneys, who claim that Robert Kennedy, Jr. has not paid them their legal fees of $278,000.

The lawyers’ petition also claims that Kennedy was employing a “scorched earth litigation approach" against his wife.

It’s a form of psychological warfare. The Post reports that Kennedy had cut his wife off:”… from a $20,000-a-month, court-approved credit card, leaving her unable to buy groceries, gas or even medical care for their son.”

The paper continues:

“Unfortunately, the last months of Ms. Richardson Kennedy’s life were full of daily financial challenges, directly attributable to Mr. Kennedy’s litigation tactics executed through his family office,” according to a petition.

 Already struggling with alcoholism and depression, she was subjected to the humiliation of having her card declined at the local drug store and supermarket. At one point her plastic was denied at her son’s doctor, the source said.


This tactic violated the agreement that Kennedy and his wife had made:

Each warring spouse was supposed to have a $20,000-a-month limit on a joint credit card, with the bills to be paid by the Kennedy clan’s money manager, the Park Agency.

According to the Post:

Cutting her off was a tactic “to squeeze her and make her panic” as important issues — the custody of the couple’s four children, and division of assets — were being hammered out, the source said. Bobby Kennedy also falsely claimed millions in joint assets as his own, according to the court filing.

This report leaves us with one, and only one question.

If you are in the middle of a contentious divorce with a woman who is having a nervous breakdown and you are concerned about her mental health and well-being, would you employ such tactics? Would you try to starve her out and to make it impossible for her to buy food to feed your children?

This tactic does not show a man who is consumed by concern for the well-being of his estranged. It shows a man who will stop at nothing to destroy someone who has gotten in the way.