Wednesday, September 5, 2012

What Bush Inherited from Clinton


Having proclaimed the transcendent greatness of Michelle Obama the media is readying itself to shower Bill Clinton with encomia.

Those of us who have the misfortune to watch the Democratic National Convention through the lens of the mainstream media will be regaled about stories about the greatness of Clinton and the failure of Bush.

Not only is the media biased, but it has a very short memory.

While it is agonizing over the mess that George Bush left for Barack Obama, media flacks are conveniently forgetting the mess that Bill Clinton left George Bush.

Happily, Charles Gasparino takes a look back at the Clinton record today. His is the article that everyone should be reading today.

Gasparino reminds us, for example, that Bill Clinton lay the groundwork for the housing crisis by implementing a policy of increased homeownership. The Clinton administration began the practice of forcing banks to hand out subprime loans.

In his words:

Clinton charged his Housing secretaries, Henry Cisneros and Andrew Cuomo, with driving homeownership rates up to about 70 percent of households from around 64 percent in the early ’90s.

How did they do this? Through rigorous enforcement of housing mandates such as theCommunity Reinvestment Act, and by prodding mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to make loans to people with lower credit scores (and to buy loans that had been made by banks and, later, “innovators” like Countrywide).

The Housing Department was Fannie and Freddie’s top regulator — and under Cuomo the mortgage giants were forced to start ramping up programs to issue more subprime loans to the riskiest of borrowers.

We know how that turned out: Fannie and Freddie help stoke a housing bubble that actually made homeownership less affordable unless borrowers took out ever-more-risky loans. Eventually, both agencies imploded (along with the housing market); bailing them out since 2008 has already cost taxpayers more than $100 billion.

(And, yes, Bush continued Clinton’s policies — but did try to rein in Fannie and Freddie in his later years, before the meltdown. But Democratic barons in Congress like Rep. Barney Frank balked at stopping the train before the wreck.)

Gasparino also reminds us that the Clinton administration led the charge for banking deregulation by pushing the repeal of Glass-Steagall.

Republicans were on board with removing the barriers between commercial and investment banking, but the brains behind deregulation belonged to Robert Rubin, who then profited from the new law as chairman of the executive committee at Citigroup.

When Citigroup teetered on the edge of insolvency, this same Robert Rubin, uber-banker, claimed that he did not know what was going on at the bank.

Gasparino does not mention it, but if we are now judging an administration by what happens in the months after it leaves office, how about giving some thought to the feckless Clinton counterterrorism policy, the one that might have contributed to what happened on September 11, 2001.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Totalitarian Parenting


New York parents are a special breed. They are even more special, and apparently more extreme, if they have been indoctrinated in political correctness.

Yesterday, blogging on a website called The Stir, Kiri Blakeley posted a vignette about a special New York custom: “extreme parenting.”

It isn’t just that parents have become health fanatics, shielding their children from the least morsel of inorganic chicken, but they also want to shield their children from ideologically incorrect language.

You may not agree with me when I characterize such people as the thought police, but these extreme parents are trying to ensure it that their children never think a counterrevolutionary thought.

I would call it totalitarian parenting, because this level of mind control, when practiced on the young, was endemic to the great totalitarian dictatorships of the twentieth century.

Recently Blakeley attended a dinner party with, among others, a couple that had brought along their two-year-old daughter.

To Blakeley’s mild surprise, the child was thoroughly absorbed in her activities and sat quietly and calmly through a four-hour dinner party with perfect aplomb.

She was, Blakeley notes, thoroughly “well-behaved and social.”

Allow Blakeley to describe what happened next:

Towards the end of the gathering, the little girl ended up sitting next to me. So we're sitting there, chillin', and she was doing something cute with her large red bib, when I cooed, "Aren’t you a good girl?" Her mother -- a very nice woman, by the way, don’t get me wrong -- leaned over and said, calmly but firmly, “We don’t use the term 'good girl.' "

In New York City, the land of extreme-parenting, there's about a million different ways one could go wrong around a child in the eyes of the hyper-vigilant parent, and I had just bumped smack dab into one of them. In using the term "good girl," I had unwittingly crashed some parental ordinance of which I had no knowledge, but had been scolded for nonetheless. It wasn't one of those things that you could classify as obvious not to say around a child. Such as, say, "muhthaf**king crackwho*re."

This very nice mother, a woman who would surely call you out for the least hint of judgmentalism is, let’s be clear, a bully.

In the name of her maternal instinct, she is telling other people that their vocabulary must fit her political bias… in this cases, she seems to have something against “good girls.”

She has arrogated to herself the right to police how other people talk to her daughter.

Blakeley understands, as we all do, that it would be inappropriate to issue forth with a torrent of obscenities in front of a toddler. Not because the toddler would understand what the words meant, but because most parents do not want to expose their children to such crass vulgarity and its attendant aggressiveness.

We all know that you do not say just anything to a child. In truth, you do not say just anything to anyone.

Conversational decorum requires a measure of self-control, coupled with tact and consideration.

As it happens, “good girl” does not cross into the realm of the tactless, the rude, the crude, the lewd or the inconsiderate. Or, at least, it doesn’t for any normal human being.

Only an individual who is saturated with radical political ideas would correct the phrase “good girl” in order to protect a two-year old from indignity.

The mother is imposing her political beliefs on Blakely, even to the point of making her think that she might have done something wrong.

Normal language usage develops over time through a myriad of verbal exchanges. Deciding that you want to change it because it offends your ideology or because you believe that changing it will change reality reveals a totalitarian mindset.

The mother might think she is principled. She is behaving like a fanatic.

If she believes that this expression is so completely injurious how does she expect to protect her daughter from the ambient culture? Will she send a note to her daughter’s schoolteachers telling them not to call anyone a “good girl?” Will she launch boycotts of television stations that use the expression “good girl?” Will she want to have the term excised from books, newspapers and magazines?

If she really refuses to allow her daughter to be exposed to such “vile” language, she will have to mount a campaign to change the way everyone speaks.

This sounds impossible, but it has happened before. In fact, it is happening now, as we speak.

No one has yet proscribed the term “good girl” but nowadays everyone calls both men and women “persons” for fear of offending the gender neutralists, and everyone uses the generic “she” in place of the generic “he” or even the more neutral “he or she” as a sign of obeisance to the Great Mother Goddess.

Unfortunately, the mother in question is also abusing Blakeley’s good manners. If a mother tells you not to address her daughter as a good girl, you will normally respect her wishes, however totalitarian they may seem.

Dare we even speculate about why “good girl” is such a bad term? Which is more offensive, the “good” or the “girl” or the combination of the two.

But why does this mother believe that “good girl” so offensive? Is she revealing her own latent misogyny? Does this woman believe that anything is better than being a girl? Or, is she at war against goodness, as in good character?

After all, Blakeley was giving a little girl a nudge toward good character. The girl had been very good at dinner; she had behaved in exemplary fashion. She deserved a compliment, so Blakeley quite properly offered it.

For her efforts, she was slapped down.

It takes a special warp of mind to guilt-trip a friend for having said something nice to your child.


The War on Egyptian Women


As expected, women are now being routinely sexually harassed in the new democratic Egypt. You might have thought that Egypt’s new Islamist rulers favored respecting women.

You would have been wrong.

Apparently, the new cultural climate has made it open season on women. In today's Islamist Egypt women no longer feel free to come and go as they wish. They are certainly not free to dress as they wish.

The "religion of peace" is systematically terrorizing Egyptian women.

The BBC reports:

Campaigners in Egypt say the problem of sexual harassment is reaching epidemic proportions, with a rise in such incidents over the past three months. For many Egyptian women, sexual harassment - which sometimes turns into violent mob-style attacks - is a daily fact of life….

How is the Obama administration reacting to something that really deserves to be called a war on women?

It is funneling money to Egypt’s Islamist government, in the name of “democracy.”

The New York Times reported this morning:

Nearly 16 months after first pledging to help Egypt’s failing economy, the Obama administration is nearing an agreement with the country’s new government to relieve $1 billion of its debt as part of an American and international assistance package intended to bolster its transition to democracy, administration officials said.

You won’t hear a word of this from the Democratic National Convention. You won’t hear a word of this from Sandra Fluke and other feminist activists.

After all, how can Barack Obama’s Democratic party denounce a war on women that it is helping to fund.

Monday, September 3, 2012

Mistress Betty and the Feminist Thought Police


I don’t know whether Katie Roiphe believes in God, but she certainly believes in the Great Godmother in the Sky, Betty Friedan.

You see, if you are a feminist you bear a primary moral responsibility to satisfy the ideological zeal of Mistress Betty, even now that she has passed over into the beyond.

If a woman does not define herself as Mistress Betty would have wished, junior members of the thought police, like Katie Roiphe, will call her out and will expose her as a traitor to the cause.

If she is not a feminist, it doesn’t matter. Feminists believe that all women are natural-born feminists. This means that all women can be forced to adhere to feminist values, lest they be denounced as sellouts to the patriarchy. 

What could it be that has so agitated Katie Roiphe? Could it be the oppression of women in Muslim countries? Of course not.

Roiphe is lathered up because when she turns to the Facebook pages of her female friends she discovers, in the place where she was expecting to see their smiling countenance, a picture of a child.

Roiphe is grievously offended by the fact that these women should have chosen—dare I say, freely—to place a picture of a child on their Facebook page in the place where they should be, as Roiphe sees it, defining their personal identity.

Mistress Betty would not approve. To her zealous mind a woman’s identity is based on personal achievements, especially the ones associated with work.

And Mistress Betty would only approve of women who define themselves, above all else as feminists.

How many women will now think twice before putting up pictures of their children on Facebook? How many women will feel that they now have the right, even the sacred duty, to attack women who post pictures of their children as traitors to the feminist cause?

And what do you think Mistress Betty would have said about pictures of a woman with her husband or boyfriend?

For feminists, “wife” is the ultimate four-letter. Normally, feminists have no real argument with motherhood.

For reasons that escape me Roiphe emphasizes mothers and children; she ignores the possibility that the woman might also be a wife.

If you thought that feminism was about equal rights and free choice, think again. Putting aside the politics, feminists want to dictate how women live their lives.

If you think I am exaggerating, read what Roiphe wrote in the Financial Times:

If, from beyond the grave, Betty Friedan were to review the Facebook habits of the over-30 set, I am afraid she would be very disappointed in us. By this I mean specifically the trend of women using photographs of their children instead of themselves as the main picture on their Facebook profiles. You click on a friend’s name and what comes into focus is not a photograph of her face, but a sleeping blond four-year-old, or a sun-hatted toddler running on the beach. Here, harmlessly embedded in one of our favourite methods of procrastination, is a potent symbol for the new century. Where have all of these women gone? What, some earnest future historian may very well ask, do all of these babies on our Facebook pages say about “the construction of women’s identity” at this particular moment in time?

Ay, there’s the rub. It’s all about “the construction of women’s identity.” Or so Roiphe would like.

In truth, feminism does not allow women to construct their identities freely. It insists that they construct an identity that would confirm the prejudice of ideological fanatics like Mistress Betty.

Of course, women, like men have the right to construct their social identity freely. But that does not mean that any man or woman creates his or her social identity out of nothing.

Society confers roles. You may or may not like it, but he women who are showing pictures of their children are not only expressing pride in their children but they are affirming their roles as mothers.

Feminism does not want women to define themselves as mothers or wives. It insists that they define themselves primarily as feminists.

Roiphe continues:

Many of these women work. Many of them are in book clubs. Many of them are involved in causes, or have interests that take them out of the house. But this is how they choose to represent themselves. The choice may seem trivial, but the whole idea behind Facebook is to create a social persona, an image of who you are projected into hundreds of bedrooms and cafés and offices across the country. Why would that image be of someone else, however closely bound they are to your life, genetically and otherwise? The choice seems to constitute a retreat to an older form of identity, to a time when fresh-scrubbed Vassar girls were losing their minds amidst vacuum cleaners and sandboxes.

One wonders why anyone should care whether Roiphe or Mistress Betty is seriously offended, but, alas, many women take this swill seriously.

Think of it, these women belong to book clubs. They militate for God knows what… and they have the gall to portray themselves as mothers. That’s what Roiphe is saying.

For reasons that must be clear to feminists, Roiphe believes that these women are engaging in “a larger and more ominous self-effacement.”

You see, if you put a picture of young Clarissa on your Facebook page, you are effacing yourself, obliterating your identity in favor of your daughter.

Roiphe does manage to pay lip service to the importance of children:

One’s children are an important achievement, and arguably one’s most important achievement, but that doesn’t mean that they are who you are.

Of course, no woman thinks that she is her children. Roiphe, however, believes that being a feminist, sacrificing your life for an ideological cause is who you are. Why else would she worry about how Mistress Betty would feel.

Later, Roiphe adds that this use of a child’s picture is a “particular form of narcissism.” A strange thought, indeed, since Narcissus drowned while looking at his own image in a pond, not while gazing at pictures of his (imaginary) children.

I don’t want to say that Roiphe does not know what narcissism is. Perhaps she is just pretending not to know.

Still, I have no idea how she can assert that a woman who shows off her toddlers is saying that “I don’t matter any more.”

Apparently, she is so lost in her veneration of Mistress Betty that she does not understand that for young children mothers matter enormously. They matter so much that women work very hard trying to be good mothers, to the point where they share advice and counsel with other mothers.

And, these women are proud of themselves for being good mothers and are proud of their children. Only a zealot could see something wrong in that.

Roiphe believes that these women have sold out the feminist cause. In truth, it means that they love their children and take their responsibilities seriously.

Roiphe gets especially annoyed when she goes to a dinner party where her friend, “who wrote her senior thesis in college on Proust, who used to stay out drinking till five in the morning in her twenties,” is sitting around with other women talking about her children.

The indignity of it all. There ought to be a law.

We do not know whether we should be more in awe of the fact that she wrote a thesis on Proust or that she used to stay out all night drinking.

Which would be the greater achievement? Which deserves a place on her resume?

After a while you start thinking that this is self-parody. Didn’t everyone write a thesis on Proust? Have you ever read a senior thesis on Proust? If you ever have, you will never again see the act as the summit of human achievement. Take my word for it.

And how does it happen that staying out all night drinking makes its way on to anyone’s resume?

What sensible woman defines herself by her senior college thesis, her drinking binges and not by her being a mother to her children, or, Heaven forfend, wife to her husband?

Roiphe finds the development ominous. It would sorely displease Mistress Betty:

These Facebook photos signal a larger and more ominous self-effacement, a narrowing of worlds. Think of a dinner party you just attended, and your friend, a brilliant and accomplished woman. Think about how throughout the entire dinner party, from olives to chocolate mousse, she talks about nothing but her kids.

What is even more ominous is the notion that Katie Roiphe and the feminist thought police should presume to dictate what women should and should not discuss at dinner parties.

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Bill Maher on Clint Eastwood


Is Bill Maher’s the last word on Clint Eastwood’s convention dialogue with an empty chair?

Even if it isn’t, Maher has shown that it takes a stand-up comic to appreciate a great comedic routine.

Bill Maher said this about Clint Eastwood:

“As a performer, as a stand-up comedian for 30 years who knows how hard it is to get laughs, excuse me, he went up there … without a net, on a tightrope. There was no teleprompter. He did a bit with just an empty chair and killed…. He committed to it, it was consistent and it worked.”

 “People have been saying for years: these conventions are too scripted, they’re too slick, they’re too overproduced. A guy who went up there who wasn’t slick … and killed with the crowd? I gotta give him props for that.”

Maher has not changed his political opinions; he is still happy to have contributed to the Obama re-election campaign.

But, he is sufficiently gracious to give credit where credit is due.

Props to Bill Maher.

Sunday Morning Services at the Church of the Liberal Pieties


Back in the old days reading the Sunday New York Times was almost a religious ritual. It was like praying at the Church of the Liberal Pieties.

Today, when you open the Sunday Times opinion pages to read at the line-up of liberal columnists, you feel like you have suddenly come upon a bunch of superannuated thinkers, a meeting of the over-the-hill gang.

Maybe there’s something about modern leftist politics that stifles serious thought, but Thomas Friedman, Maureen Dowd and Nicholas Kristof have nothing to say any more and they don’t even say it well.

Tom Friedman seems unwilling to do his own research so he echoes Democratic Party boilerplate about the Republican convention.

His big new idea: lunar exploration, or something like it… a big, bold idea… the likes of which Friedman has not had since the Kennedy administration. 

It is not a bad idea to give the nation a new mission, a new sense of purpose. 

Yet, before blaming the Republicans for not wanting to meet Friedman on the moon, the columnist might have noticed that the Obama administration is far more likely to spend money on women’s jobs than on something as phallic as launching rockets into space.

When you think of big scientific and construction projects, keep in mind that the environmental wing of the Democratic Party is trying to sue us back to the Stone Age.

The Obama campaign will tout the fact that it has created new jobs in health care, hospitality and education… all fields that are dominated by women. It does not much care about all the jobs it could have spurred by having a pro-growth energy policy.

In the meantime Maureen Dowd channels her eighth grade self and declares that Republicans are a bunch of meanies.

If she doesn’t up her game I predict that she will soon be retired.

Then the hapless Nicholas Kristof informs his readers that Republicans are opposed to abortion rights. Can you imagine that anyone who reads Kristof does not know that Obama has made a campaign issue out of the supposed Republican war against women?

Naturally, Kristof has no interest in the differences of opinion within the Republican ranks or the nuances that inform these views.

If a columnist does not tell you something you did not know or provide you with a new way to analyze the information you possess he or she has descended to the level of political hack.

For that reason it was refreshing to read George Will’s column in the Washington Post this morning.

Will begins by fact-checking, in detail, one of Obama’s campaign promises:

After a delusional proclamation — General Motors “has come roaring back” — Obama said: “Now I want to do the same thing with manufacturing jobs, not just in the auto industry, but in every industry.” We have been warned.

Obama’s supposed rescue of “the auto industry” — note the definite article, “the” — is a pedal on the political organ he pumps energetically in Ohio, Wisconsin, Michigan and elsewhere. Concerning which:

He intervened to succor one of two of the U.S. auto industries. One, located in the South and elsewhere, does not have a long history of subservience to the United Auto Workers and for that reason has not needed Obama’s ministrations. He showered public money on two of three parts of the mostly Northern auto industry, the one long entangled with the UAW. He socialized the losses of GM and Chrysler. Ford was not a mendicant because it was not mismanaged.

Today, “I am GM, hear me roar” is again losing market share, and its stock, of which taxpayers own 26 percent, was trading Thursday morning at $21, below the $33 price our investor in chief paid for it and below the $53 price it would have to reach to enable taxpayers to recover the entire $49.5 billion bailout. Roaring GM’s growth is in China.

Of course, Will is a Republican. Yet, he does not rely on campaign rhetoric and slogans. He analyzes Obama’s statement by offering the facts about the “rescue” of the automobile industry.

Will’s theme today is what has happened to modern liberal thinking. He begins with the fact that liberals today are no longer willing to call themselves liberals. They label themselves progressives.

The point has been made in the past. If I don’t miss my guess, it has been made on this blog.

Will is right to say that jettisoning the word “liberal” showed respect for the language. Today's liberals are really not liberal.

In Will’s words:

Jettisoning the label “liberal” was an act not just of self-preservation, considering the damage liberals had done to the word, but also of semantic candor: The noble liberal tradition was about liberty — from oppressive kings, established churches and aristocracies. 

Unfortunately, the replacement-term, progressive, has increasingly become a misnomer.

Speaking of misnomers, progressives have gotten themselves involved in other forms of verbal deceit. The most obvious example: they no longer talk about spending money; they prefer the notion of infrastructure investments.

He writes:

The substitution of “invest” for “spend” (e.g., “We must invest more in food stamps,” and in this and that) is prudent but risky. People think there has been quite enough of (in Mitt Romney’s words) “throwing more borrowed money at bad ideas.” But should progressives call attention to their record as investors of other people’s money (GM, Solyndra, etc.)?

Ironically, the Republican nominee for president is a master investor while Barack Obama has failed as an investor.

More importantly, today’s progressives are really what I would call regressives, or reactionaries.

Will waxes slightly nostalgic for the time when Bill Clinton looked fearlessly into the future and promised to end welfare as we know it.

Clinton did not fear the future, but today’s so-called progressive are peddling fear. They are saying, Will reports, that a Romney/Ryan administration will end Medicare as we know it.

As it happens, and as Erskine Bowles freely admitted, the Ryan budget and the Republican plans to reform entitlement spending are far more bold and audacious than the plan to put a man on the moon.

It will be lot more difficult to make progress reforming entitlement spending than it was to rally the nation toward space travel. No one had to sacrifice anything to go to the moon.

Saturday, September 1, 2012