Friday, December 5, 2014

Fifty Years of Feminism

It’s a fair criticism.

Sometimes, some of us are too ready to dismiss second-wave feminism. We see the glass half-empty and don’t notice that there is still something to drink.

Many people think that I should be doing some serious amends on this score, so I will point out some of the positive benefits that feminism has brought to modern women.

Credit where credit is due. We owe the insight to someone named Sarah Vine. For the record, I have no idea who Sarah Vine is, but she wrote her cri de coeur for the Daily Mail. What further validation do you need?

In fact, we do not even have to read Vine’s article. In her case it’s all in the headline:

How did 50 years of feminism end in THIS?

For your edification, she is referring to THIS:


'I’m not a feminist zealot— but I’d happily burn a Victoria’s Secret bra' says Sarah Vine

Are you horrified yet?

Vine became apoplectic at the sight of a Victoria’s Secret fashion show in London. We note, if only in passing, that VS is not a novelty. It has been around since 1977. How did Vine miss it?

Considering how well it has been doing, one must assume that liberated women also shop there.

Now that Victoria’s Secret has made its way into Vine’s raised consciousness, she is horrified:

Victoria's Secret 'fashion show' suggests trashy costumes, strippers, nudity and lecherousness are the most natural things in the world


Some of the 3,000-strong audience had paid up to £10,000 to attend the show, which cost at least £10 million to produce

OMFG! I am not sure that I would say that the costume looks like the most natural thing in the world, but then, that's me.

Think that's bad. Take a gander at this angle:
Sarah is concerned that the younger generation will be taken in by the glamour and glitz of the Victoria's Secret world


I’m all for modesty. But isn’t Vine taking her crusade for a return to modesty a bit too far? Next thing you know she will be insisting that women cover themselves up… in burqas, perhaps.

Did I miss something, but wasn’t feminism supposed to be about sexual liberation, too?

A group that extolled The Hite Report and that was marching to The Vagina Monologues is not very well placed to rail about Victoria’s Secret.

Acting more like a zealot than a free-thinking woman, Vine continues, via the Daily Mail headline:

  • 'I’m not a zealot but I’d burn a Victoria’s Secret bra' says Sarah Vine 

  • She says the brand specialises in tiny, extremely uncomfortable underwear

It’s going to be the new feminist slogan: be liberated; go braless!

Or, was that the old slogan?

And yet, if women want spend the money they earned on VS undergarments, who am I to complain.

Vine, consumed by fury at the way women exercise their freedom to choose… what they wear:

  • 'This is a world where how you look is the only thing that matters'
Obviously, this is a leap into the theoretical void. It is silly to say that a world that gave us Margaret Thatcher, Julie Burchill and Taylor Swift only values women for how they look when they are prancing around in their unmentionables.
'The normally demure(ish) Swift came over all stripper-tastic in black lingerie in a desperate bid to outstrut the Angels, a look that really doesn’t suit her down-home style'



Thursday, December 4, 2014

Did Feminism Save Marriage?

Two cheers for the fact that Americans are divorcing less.

Claire Cain Miller reports that Americans are staying married longer. The wave of divorces that began in the 1970s is tapering off.

Statistically, this means that instead of a divorce rate of approximately 50% we anticipate a divorce rate of 33%.

It’s getting better, but still the rate is far too high.

Miller also points out that Americans are marrying less. Thus, many Americans lack the stability that a long term marriage would provide.

The less educated among us have discovered that it is perfectly OK not to marry, but to have children with different partners. The resulting social chaos ought to bother everyone. It is not a formula for social harmony.

All of this is what it is. It is not the reason I was intrigued by Miller’s story.

Miller also raises a more interesting issue: Was feminism responsible for the wave of divorces that washed up on our shores in the 1970s? Or was it all the fault of men who refused to buckle under to their wives’ new demands?

Were feminists really home-wreckers or did American men fail to adapt to changing mores?

Following the lead of researchers Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolpers, Miller attempts to absolve feminism of responsibility for the chaos it produced:

The people who married soon before the feminist movement were caught in the upheaval. They had married someone who was a good match for the postwar culture but the wrong partner after times changed. Modern marriage is more stable because people are again marrying people suitable to the world in which we live.

This is seriously disingenuous, though it does show that feminists are incapable of taking responsibility for what their movement produced.

Marriage is a contract. Some of it is explicit; some of it is implicit; some of it is customary. Once a couple establishes a domestic division of labor, it becomes part of the contract.

People who marry agree to live by the terms of the contract. When second-wave feminism convinced large numbers of women to break their part of the contract, to go back on their word, it produced an upheaval. It had to.

The result was a large number of divorces and what was called the feminization of poverty. Airy visions notwithstanding, divorce is not good for women… or for anyone else, either.

It was more about the culture than about equal legal rights. It was about the way women conducted their lives. Feminism declared that traditional ways of dating and mating, or courting and marrying were oppressive to women. They had a right to their opinion. But then, they told women to opt out of traditional marriages and traditional courtship. The result: more divorce, more unwillingness to marry, more hooking up, more sexual abuse… and so on.

Feminists take grievous offense at any suggestion that their movement might be responsible for the ensuing chaos. They do not like being called home-wreckers.

And yet, as Colin Powell famously said: you break it; you own it. Those who broke the old ways of dating and mating are responsible for what ensued… even if it was not what they intended.

Shifting the blame by accusing people of having married unsuitable mates is absurd. The point is not whether your mate is suitable or not. The point is that a lot of women changed the rules… unilaterally.

When someone breaches a contract you do not say that she made a deal with someone who was unsuitable. When someone decides to change the rules you do not accuse her mate of being overly rigid.

Following Stevenson and Wolpers, Miller refuses to blame feminism for anything that has gone wrong since women started living by its dictates.

Instead, in an impressive sleight-of-hand Miller suggests that feminism really saved marriage… by making it all about love.

Or better, she follows the lead of the researchers who declare that marriage has evolved:

Women entered the work force, many of their chores in the home became automated and they gained reproductive rights, as the economist Betsey Stevenson and Mr. Wolfers have argued in their academic work. As a result, marriage has evolved to its modern-day form, based on love and shared passions, and often two incomes and shared housekeeping duties.

“It’s just love now,” Mr. Wolfers said. “We marry to find our soul mate, rather than a good homemaker or a good earner.”

In fact, this was always the feminist promise. It’s good to see it stated so explicitly and so mindlessly.

In the feminist fiction a woman who ran out on her husband and children to go to graduate school will find her soul mate, discover true love and live happily ever after. See Marilyn French’s The Women’s Room.

Feminism did not concern itself with whether or not it was morally reprehensible to abandon husband, home and children.

In another feminist fiction a woman should delay marriage in favor of career. Then she will be so independent that she will not depend on a man for anything. Thus, when she chooses to get married in her mid-thirties she will find a man who can love her for herself alone… and not for her tuna casseroles. Since she does not depend on him they can love each other as equals.

By now most women know the foolishness of this life plan. But, the reproductive endocrinologists have certainly profited from it.

We did not need second-wave feminism to give us love marriage. By my count it originated in the sixteenth century with the Protestant Reformation and became institutionalized in Great Britain in the seventeenth century.

To be clear, it meant that civilization had advanced beyond arranged marriage. As I discussed in my book The Last Psychoanalyst, the important part about love marriage was that it gave a woman a free choice of a husband and held her responsible for the way she conducted herself in her marriage.

Anyone who believes that marriage is simply the union of two soul mates is either an adolescent or a propagandist. Witness the fate of Romeo and Juliet or Tristan and Isolde.

One reason people marry less is that some women refuse to be homemakers and some men do not want to marry until they can support their families. Also some women refuse to marry men who cannot provide for them.

Ignoring these things when you choose a mate is a formula for trouble. One suspects that some young people think that it’s all about love. That’s the reason why, even in a culture where marriages are not arranged, parental guidance often plays a role in the selection process.

And, lest we overlook it, some research has shown that a couple that shares household chores is 50% more likely to divorce. A marriage where both members of the couple contribute equally to the family coffers is twice as likely to contain abuse.

Moreover, when a couple shares all household chores and childrearing tasks equally, one or both will be sacrificing career advancement. This too is not a formula for a happy and durable marriage.

Finally, when estimating the divorce rate we must keep in mind parents today know that feminists were lying to them. They know that children suffer from divorce. Thus, they often try to keep their marriages together while their children are growing up. Responsible adults, they make choices based on the best interest of someone other than themselves.

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Blog Appreciation Week Continues

Black Friday has come and gone. Cyber Monday has become Cyber Week.

Thus, the holiday season has officially begun.

I suspect that it’s the time of year when you start thinking about how you can express your appreciation for the work that goes into producing this blog. It may not always seem to be the case, but putting up these posts every day does require work.

If I may be so bold, one way to express appreciation is to make a donation. If you glance at the left column of this page you will see an orange oval-shaped button that says: Donate.

Click it and the folks at Paypal will make the donation process as painless as possible.

And always remember: it is more blessed to give than to receive.

If these few words do not put you in the mood, I add a video that was sent to me a while back by a commenter. I knew that I would find a place for it in the blog. Now I have.




Addendum: Since various marketing geniuses extended Black Friday for a week I will place myself in their good company by extending Cyber Monday into Blog Appreciation Week. Thus, I will repeat this post a few more times throughout the week.
Several people prefer the U. S. Mail to Paypal. For them, my address is:

310 East 46th St.  24H
New York, NY 10017

P. S. My thanks to those who have already donated.



Jackie's Story: Rape at UVA

No one is comfortable doubting the word of a woman who says that she was raped. Yet many people have begun to doubt a young woman named Jackie who told Rolling Stone magazine that she was gang raped at a University of Virginia fraternity house.

As reported by Sabrina Rubin Erdely, Jackie’s accusations ring true. Many have questioned the facts of the case, and they ought to be questioned, but Jackie’s account of her mental trauma and emotional pain seems plausible.

The psychological aftershock makes the story appear to be true.

And yet, the story comes at a time when colleges, and especially fraternities are being denounced for encouraging and countenancing the sexual assault of innocent young women. In today’s world the narrative often counts more than the facts.

We know that a University of Chicago student recently fabricated a story of a rape threat in order to help disseminate the narrative.

In a world where we have increasingly been told that everything is a narrative, facts only matter to the extent that they sustain the beliefs of those who have bought the narrative.

Bret Stephens explained it well in the Wall Street Journal yesterday:

It isn’t surprising that a generation of journalists schooled in the idea that “narrative” contains truth independent of fact are so easily taken in by stories that ultimately prove less than accurate, if not utterly untrue. Nor is it surprising that American distrust in the news media is near an all-time high. Bad journalism is bad for journalism, and good journalists have a responsibility and an interest in calling out sensationalist stories whose details ring false even as they play to what we’re inclined to believe is true.

Jackie’s story was first questioned by Richard Bradley. Former editor of George magazine, Bradley noted astutely that we are more likely to accept stories that confirm the narrative we believe in.

Stephens explains:

Which isn’t to say that the rape did not happen, even if it may not have happened precisely in the way described in the piece. But it ought to raise a skeptical eyebrow. Mr. Bradley’s sharpest observation is that the journalistic fabrications that most often make it into print are those that “play into existing biases.” In the UVA case, he notes, those include biases against fraternities, men and the South—exactly the kinds of biases that led to the fabricated rape charges against the Duke lacrosse players in 2006.

Bradley has stated that Erdely was remiss for not having spoken to the young men who were accused in the story. It is a simple question of correct journalistic practice. Moreso since the author made no effort to hide identifying characteristics.

In the judicial system and in journalism someone who is accused of a crime should be able to offer his version of events.

Erdely claimed that Jackie did not want her to interview the men, but now that their reputations are being destroyed, we ought at least to allow them to decline to comment.

One is surprised that with this much attention no one has “outed” the accused men. Surely, enough information exists online to allow an enterprising reporter to identify the guilty Phi Kappa Psi fraternity brothers.

One understands that Jackie herself does not want to come forward, but if she allowed Erdely to use her name, by now a lot of people must know who she is. One appreciates their concern for her privacy and her safety, but now her story is being investigated by the police—as it ought to have been from the first—so privacy is not going to be the issue for very long.

Megan McArdle points out:

If the Rolling Stone article's allegations are true, there’s also enough detail to put at least a couple of people in jail, and possibly the whole group, even if Jackie (the victim) is reluctant to assist the investigation.

For starters, there are two people whom the university can surely identify right now. First is “Drew,” the boy who worked as a lifeguard at the university pool with her, invited her to the party, and handed her over to his brothers to be raped. There are about 80 brothers in this fraternity; the odds that more than one of them was an upperclassman lifeguard in 2012 seem pretty small, unless this happens to be the swim team frat.

Second is the kid who raped her with a beer bottle when he found himself unable to maintain an erection; she says she recognized him as a classmate from a small anthropology discussion group. The story strongly implies that the rape was an initiation ritual for the fraternity, and since fraternity rush takes place in the second half of freshman year at UVA, this boy was almost certainly a sophomore, or maybe an upperclassman who transferred in. At any rate, it’s very unlikely that there is more than one young man who was a new member of Phi Kappa Psi in 2012, and also a member of lower-level anthropology class. The university ought to be able to identify these two young men in a matter of a few hours.

The fact that no one yet knows the identity of any of these people has caused some people to doubt the story.

If we assume that Jackie is so afraid of Drew that she does not want to mention his name, we must add that publishing the story and making it easy to identify him does not solve her problem. Also, once he is identified he is much less likely to approach her for any reason whatever.

Writing in the Washington Post, Paul Farhi raises some important considerations:

One of the many remarkable things about Erdely’s article is that no one had reported it before. At least a few dozen people in and around U-Va. were aware of Jackie’s story — friends, family, administrators and the small circle of people associated with One Less, the campus sexual assault awareness organization that Jackie had joined. Yet, for more than two years after the events described in the Rolling Stone article allegedly took place, the story remained untold.
  
Some elements of the story, however, are apparently too delicate for Erdely to talk about now. She won’t say, for example, whether she knows the names of Jackie’s alleged attackers or whether in her reporting she approached “Drew,” the alleged ringleader, for comment. She is bound to silence about those details, she said, by an agreement with Jackie, who “is very fearful of these men, in particular Drew. . . . She now considers herself an empty shell. So when it comes down to identifying them, she has a very hard time with that.”

Unfortunately, the gory and grisly details of the rape itself produce doubt. Here is the Rolling Stone account:

"Shut up," she heard a man's voice say as a body barreled into her, tripping her backward and sending them both crashing through a low glass table. There was a heavy person on top of her, spreading open her thighs, and another person kneeling on her hair, hands pinning down her arms, sharp shards digging into her back, and excited male voices rising all around her. When yet another hand clamped over her mouth, Jackie bit it, and the hand became a fist that punched her in the face. The men surrounding her began to laugh. For a hopeful moment Jackie wondered if this wasn't some collegiate prank. Perhaps at any second someone would flick on the lights and they'd return to the party.

Bradley comments:

A young woman is led young woman into a “pitch-black” room. She is shoved by a man, who falls on her; they crash through a glass table and she lands in shards of glass. She bites his hand; he punches her; the men laugh. (Really? A man punches a woman and people laugh?) With the smell of marijuana (not usually known as a violence-inducing drug) hovering over the room, he and six more men rape her. The last uses a beer bottle; allegedly he can not get an erection, so his fellow frat brothers goad him on, mock him, then finally give him a tool with which to violate Jackie. (This is the man whom Jackie allegedly knew because they were in an anthropology seminar together.) This, after all, is who men really are, in anonymous darkness.

The story of what happened to Jackie is similarly horrifying—and similarly incredible. Having been raped for three hours while lying in shards of glass “digging into her back”—three hours of which Jackie remembers every detail, despite the fact of the room’s pitch-blackness—she passes out and wakes up at 3 AM in an empty room.

Jackie makes her way downstairs, her red dress apparently sufficiently intact to wear; the party is still raging. Though she is blood-stained—three hours with shards of glass “digging into her back,” and gang-raped, including with a beer bottle— and must surely look deeply traumatized, no one notices her. She makes her way out a side entrance she hadn’t seen before. She calls her friends, who tell her that she doesn’t want to be known as the girl who cried rape and worry that if they take her to the hospital they won’t get invited to subsequent frat parties.

Put that way, doubt seems to be a legitimate response.

One understands that the events recounted would have traumatized Jackie severely.

One also understands that someone whose back was cut up by shards of glass might look to be in urgent need of medical attention.

One understands that college students are morally deficient—something about brain development—but one suspects that at least one of Jackie’s friends, seeing her bleeding and bruised from a gang rape would think of something other than frat parties.

One does well not to overestimate the moral sense of college freshmen. One does well not to overestimate the moral scruples of fraternity brothers. But, how does it happen that today’s liberated young women will sell out a friends’ well-being for an invitation to a frat party? And, how does it happen that no one noticed Jackie when she walked out of the party, bloodied and bruised, and how does it happen that no one thought to take Jackie to a hospital?

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

Teaching People To Hate You

Elizabeth Wurtzel is not only a very talented writer. She has become the poster child for the therapy culture.

With age has come wisdom. Experience has taught her how to overcome the lessons she received from therapy.

Now, she offers some guidance for people who want to become more likable. She does so by arguing the opposite: she offers some ways you can teach people to hate you.

One might say that it is not a good thing to be hated. One would be right to say so. But, some people would rather be hated than ignored, so her advice is not altogether ironic.

Wurtzel does not provide a therapeutically correct analysis of her previous bad behavior. Had she done so, had she used the tool that therapy has given her, she would have explained that her traumatic childhood forced her o irritate people to the point that they hated her.

Instead, she lists some of her previous bad habits, habits that she has presumably overcome, and shows how her sense of shame helped her to overcome them.

With her first point she explains that if you want people to hate you, you should always be late. Not just a few minutes late, but an hour or two. Not just occasionally, but all the time.

In a past life Wurtzel had developed the habit. She describes it:

I used to be extremely late, mostly because I was slow and distracted, which is what does it. I would be hours late, for events that were my idea, and even though everyone was gone by the time I showed up, I did bother, in my ridiculous way. Mostly I was just something like a half hour or forty-five minutes late, and people expected it, and somehow forgave it—Lord knows why. No one likes having to forgive you all the time—they hate being the forever patsy. 

How did she overcome this habit? She did so when she recognized that being late was rude, offensive and abusive:

What finally set me straight is someone telling me that lateness is nothing more than a sign of disrespect: It is saying that the other person’s time is not valuable, he might as well wait for me, what else has he got to do? I had not thought of it quite that way. I just believed I was slow and distracted, and the 4 train was always delayed, and traffic on Third Avenue was always bad. But after I realized being late is mean, I learned to wake up earlier and be on time. People hate me a lot less.

She did not discover the childhood roots of tardiness. She did not punish herself for being late. She simply came to understand what her lateness was saying to other people. It might not have been the message she intended to send, but you do not control the meaning of your messages.

This point should be engraved in the notebook of everyone who ever tells you to do as you please because no one has a right to judge you.

Wurtzel proceeds to explain that sometimes it happens that people hate you for being successful. Surely, it cannot be because your success is rude and abusive, but that does not prevent some people from thinking that it is.

True enough, people will like you when you succeed because people always gravitate to success. But many people will resent your success because it exceeds theirs.  They will even believe that your success was unearned, that you did not gain it honestly. Surely, you are no better than they are. If you succeeded where they did not, you must have cheated.

Today, resentment rears its head in the currently fashionable attack on what is called white privilege.

How do you manage success? Perhaps by being excessively humble, by not flaunting it. Wurtzel does not quite say it this way, but I am confident she would agree.

If success is double-edged, failure is not.

No one likes a failure, Wurtzel explains, because failures bring everyone down. They damage the group reputation and they require excessive care and tending.

In her words:

Every family has a mishap who is always broke, can’t keep a job, is in and out of trouble with the law, is drunk and disorderly mostly at the most inappropriate times, and in all manner of ways has no capacity to get his life together. Okay, maybe not every family. Some have several. There are wretched clans who are all doing time together. But there are lots of lovely people who are stuck with a miscreant who just can’t get it right, even after all those alternative summer camps and all that tough love.

Next she says that people will grow to hate you if you are constantly complaining. She might have mentioned that more than a few people have cultivated this unfortunate habit in therapy.

Most therapy encourages patients to complain constantly about problems that become more insoluble the more you complain about them:

If you’re ever about to say, I don’t mean to complain but, don’t. There is nothing more idiosyncratic than the things that bother you–or the way you express them or the moment it hits you, but somehow it is going to come out wrong. The initial filing in a lawsuit is called a complaint, and what is worse than a lawsuit? Inmates on death row have righteous indignation galore, because you can justify anything. If there really is a problem, fix it yourself or resolve it with the powers that be, but don’t make everyone else feel lousy by talking about it. 

In many therapy sessions complaining is legal tender. Many therapists do not tell their patients to stop complaining. They do not work to help their patients to fix their problems or to resolve their issues. They are more interested in knowing how you feel than in what you should do.

When therapists try to help their patients to understand why they have these problems and not other problems they are encouraging them to whine. And whining causes people to hate you. So says Wurtzel. I believe she is right.

Finally, Wurtzel suggests that people will hate you if you are boring. If you monopolize a conversation with tedious information… often about yourself… people are not going to like you. If you talk to hear yourself talk they are going to end up hating you.

Obviously, it takes a certain amount of astute observation to tell whether people are hanging on your every word or wanting to hang you. One suspects that you learn it through experience.

In Wurtzel’s words:

There is nothing wrong with being the center of attention and dominating a dinner party if that’s how it happens to work out. It is not bad manners to talk too much if everyone loves listening. But if you are boring, people will hate you and walk away. 

How do you become less boring? Wurtzel has the perfect antidote:

Usually people are boring because they are bored. They don’t read or listen to music or see movies or watch tv or in any way engage. Or worse: They do all that, and even still. If people tell you that you talk too much, you are boring. So do something about it. Or keep quiet.

You become less boring when you share information. You become less boring by reading a lot. You should read newspapers and magazines, history books and novels. You should listen to music, go to the movies and watch television. This will give you something to talk about.

When you offer information that everyone can relate to, when you try to engage people on common ground … you will be contributing to a conversation. You do not need to entertain people, because entertaining can easily become tedious. You do not need to talk as much as Wurtzel does.

Your conversation should engage others on common ground, communicating more information than opinions and feelings. You need to show that you are present but that you are attuned and attentive to other people.

After a time people might grow to like you.



Monday, December 1, 2014

Blog Appreciation Week

Black Friday has come and gone. Cyber Monday has arrived.

Thus, the holiday season has officially begun.

I suspect that it’s the time of year when you start thinking about how you can best express your appreciation for the work that goes into producing this blog. It may not always seem to be the case, but putting up these posts every day does require work.

If I may be so bold, one way to express appreciation is to make a donation. If you glance at the left column of this page you will see an orange oval-shaped button that says: Donate.

Click it and the folks at Paypal will make the donation process as painless as possible.

And always remember: it is more blessed to give than to receive.

If these few words do not put you in the mood, I add a video that was sent to me a while back by a commenter. I knew that I would find a place for it in the blog. Now I have.


Addendum: Since various marketing geniuses extended Black Friday for a week I will place myself in their good company by extending Cyber Monday into Blog Appreciation Week. Thus, I will repeat this post a few more times throughout the week.

Hooking Up Or Rape?

Not so long ago that the media was all atwitter about the hook-up culture on college campuses.

Certainly, it existed. Certainly, the old custom of dating had fallen by the wayside. Certainly, the hookup culture was embraced by sex-positive feminists as a sign of true liberation. In their minds women’s liberation meant having sex like a man, or, like whatever they thought men did.

In truth, there was less hooking up than everyone thought, but once the discourse infected the media—the prurience quotient was undeniable—it begat more hookups. It also created an environment where young women were expected to hookup, whether they wanted to or not.

More than a few women who would never have imagined dropping to their knees at a fraternity party to service a young man they had met a half-hour before did just that. But, to do it, they needed first to imbibe large quantities of alcohol and to consume disinhibiting drugs.

One professor even suggested that equality, in the modern sense of the term, meant matching a man shot for shot.

Now the hookup culture is fast becoming a relic. It is being stifled and suppressed by what is called the rape culture.

Again, we are speaking about a concept that has come to dominate media commentary and general discussion.

Heather MacDonald explains that there is no epidemic of campus rape or of off-campus rape. And yet, once the characterization takes hold students expand the definition of rape and sexual assault to include actions that would not normally be categorized as such.

By her reckoning, most college rape accusations are not taken to criminal court because they are not strong enough to prevail in that venue.

MacDonald recounts an incident from Occidental College, one that I have referred to in the past, where a young woman declared herself to be the victim of sexual assault after she did the following:

Now someone who asks a male if he has a condom, who conspires with him to have sex, who announces to a friend that she intends to have sex, who voluntarily goes to his dorm room in order to have sex, who has sex through no coercion or force on the male’s part, is as voluntary and responsible an agent in that sex act as the male.

MacDonald believes that we should all be cheering the shift in the discourse about sex on campus. She sees it as a way to free coeds from the obligation to hookup and to make male college students more gentle in their treatment of young women.

Her point is well taken, but only by a half. True enough, it is good thing that the hookup culture is being thrown into the dustbin of history. And yet, the concept of a rape culture, with its caricature of all men as potential sexual predators and rapists is not such a good thing.

First,it suggests that the primary responsibility for the hookup culture belongs to men. The fact is, women bear some responsibility for their own behavior. In particular, MacDonald points out, the sexual revolution, coupled with feminism has contributed mightily to the ethos that defines sexual behavior on campus.

If a man had come along to recommend that young women engage in random, anonymous sexual encounters he would have been widely excoriated as an agent of patriarchal oppression.

Second, the hue and cry about a rape culture might not be the right way to induce young men to start behaving more courteously and respectfully toward women.

Telling men what not to do does not tell them what to do. Worse, when you try to regulate human behavior with taboos, the enterprising human mind sees a challenge: how to get away with circumventing the taboo. Surely, the detailed prescriptions for consent contain loopholes, don’t you think? If they don’t, some men will surely set to work trying to create them.

Also, filling male minds with images of rape and sexual assault is probably not the best way to produce more courteous and respectful toward women. It might do just the opposite. Allowing men to think that they are naturally inclined to rape women is not the best way to induce good behavior.

In the meantime, MacDonald offers a masterful comparison between dating culture before and after the sexual revolution and second-wave feminism.

First, she describes the situation as it was in the early 1960s:

Males and females were assumed on average to have different needs regarding sex: The omnivorous male sex drive would leap at all available targets, whereas females were more selective, associating sex with love and commitment. The male was expected to channel his desire for sex through the rituals of courtship and a proposal of marriage. A high premium was placed on female chastity and great significance accorded its loss; males, by contrast, were given a virtual free pass to play the sexual field to the extent that they could find or purchase a willing partner. The default setting for premarital sex was “no,” at least for females. Girls could opt out of that default — many did — but placing the default at “no” meant that a female didn’t have to justify her decision not to have sex with particular reasons each time a male importuned her; individual sexual restraint was backed up by collective values. On campuses, administrators enforced these norms through visitation rules intended to prevent student couplings.

As I have occasionally mentioned, there were no co-ed dorms at the time and parietal rules regulated how late a woman could stay out at night.

Then, the sexual revolution and feminism changed it all. Most interesting is the way that it undermined a woman’s No:

From then on, males and females would meet as equals on the sexual battlefield. The ideal of female modesty, the liberationists declared, was simply a cover for sexism. Chivalry was punished; females were assumed to desire sex as voraciously as males; they required no elaborate courtship rituals to engage in it and would presumably experience no pang of thwarted attachment after a one-night stand. The default for premarital sex was now “yes,” rather than “no”; opting out of that default required an individualized explanation that could no longer rely on the fact that such things are simply not done. In colleges, the authorities should get out of the way and leave students free to navigate coital relations as they saw fit.

Her point is well taken. The fundamental difference lies in the default position. In the one culture women are assumed to mean No unless they say otherwise. In the other, women are assumed to want sex just as much as a man and to want to have sex just like men do. There, the default is Yes unless the woman says No.