Saturday, May 6, 2017

The New Arab-Israeli Alliance

To understand what is happening in the Middle East outside of Syria and Iran we need to recognize an important regional alignment, between Israel and its Sunni Arab neighbors. Since the media has mostly ignored this issue—this blog has not—it is worth examining the facts in detail.

The Wall Street Journal reports on the Arab shift toward Israel and away from Iran.

It begins with a rationale provided by the Quran:

Mohammad bin Abdul Karim al-Issa, the secretary-general of the Muslim World League, a Saudi-based global organization that has been accused of spreading extremism, recently pointed to a lesson in coexistence from Islam’s past. “The neighbor of the Prophet [Muhammad] was a Jew, and when that Jew was ill, the Prophet visited him and gave him kind words,” said Mr. al-Issa, who is also a former Saudi minister of justice. “The hard-liners don’t wish to know that.”

In this shift the Saudis are leading the way:

This new tone toward Jews—and, to a lesser degree, Israel—is becoming particularly prominent in the Gulf states, led by Saudi Arabia. For these wealthy Sunni monarchies, it is Shiite and Persian Iran that poses the most pressing current threat to their interests. They view the Jewish state—a foe of the regime in Tehran and its regional proxies, including Lebanon’s Hezbollah militia—as their de facto ally.

The Obama administration’s “empower Iran” policy set the groundwork for the new alliance. The election of Donald Trump, the candidate preferred by both the Israelis and the Saudis contributed:

This unlikely partnership has gathered steam with the rise of Saudi Arabia’s new deputy crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman, the architect of the Yemen war, who wants a more vigorous response to Iran. And it has received new momentum since the election of Donald Trump, the preferred candidate of Israel and the Gulf states. The White House said Thursday that Mr. Trump’s first foreign trip as president will feature stops in both Israel and Saudi Arabia.

Important Saudi leaders are saying so explicitly. And one notes that when Hamas recently revised its charter to remove much of the flagrant anti-Semitism, the hand of Saudi Arabia and the Emirates was evident:

“We have the same enemy, the same threat,” Saudi Maj. Gen. Ahmed Asiri, now the kingdom’s deputy intelligence chief, said in February. “And we are both close allies of the Americans.”

Pressure from the Gulf—particularly from Hamas’s longtime backer Qatar—played a key role in the Palestinian group’s decision Monday to remove slurs against Jews from its revised charter. Israel scoffed at the changes, noting that Hamas retained its goal of “liberating” all of historic Palestine—which would mean eradicating the Jewish state.

Israelis have noted the positive changes:

Still, some Israeli officials have praised the Gulf monarchies’ shift on Hamas. “Most of [Hamas’s] support came from Saudi Arabia and the Gulf in the past,” said Ayoob Kara, a lawmaker from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud Party and the only Arab minister in Israel’s cabinet. “Now the Saudi Arabian coalition understands more and more that Hamas is an extremist organization and that extremism and terror are also against them, not just against Israel.”

Obviously, after filling the minds of its people with hatred for Israel these nations will need some time to change what we call hearts and minds:

Such feelings are widespread among the people of the Gulf states too, so most of the recent cooperation with Israel—focusing on intelligence and security matters—has occurred in secret.

But, the Arab nations have taken some small public steps:

But some small steps have been public. An unofficial Saudi delegation, led by a retired general, visited Jerusalem last year and met with Israeli officials. The United Arab Emirates has permitted a small Israeli mission to the U.N.’s renewable-energy agency, based in Abu Dhabi, and Emirati officials are weighing whether to allow low-key Israeli participation in the 2020 Dubai World Expo.

Importantly, these nations are fed up with the irrational intransigence of Palestinian leaders:

Many in the Gulf shrug at such complaints. “Saudi Arabia has always wanted to support the Palestinian cause. It negotiated on their behalf, it spent a lot of money on their behalf,” said Mr. Ibrahim. “But unfortunately, the Palestinian leaders do not want to get along and are not working for their own people. You cannot just say no to everything.”

Under its new leadership Saudi Arabia has recognized the need to modernize, to enter the modern world, to become a player on the world stage. It has understood that petroleum is not forever and that it needs science and technology to develop as a modern nation. On those scores the Palestinian cause, however much it appeals to brain dead Western leftists, will not provide very much help.

As I have occasionally noted, when it comes to the Middle East, Israel is the solution, not the problem.

Friday, May 5, 2017

Trump and China Allied Against North Korea

Uh oh! First there was Bret Stephens, now we have Christopher Ruddy. Ruddy is the chairman of Newsmax, a conservative news organization. Apparently, the New York Times is hard at work trying to open the minds of its liberal readers.

Recently, Ruddy was in China discussing the Trump policy on North Korea. As you know, serious commentators, unwilling to await developments, denounced Trump’s meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping. They could not but rush to judgment, because, after all, they know how it's all going to turn out.  To declare, as media outlets on the left and the right, that Trump had gotten rolled is to prejudge a situation whose outcome is still in doubt.

Ruddy began by addressing the fact that Trump had talked tough talk about Chinese trade practices and currency manipulation during the campaign. His Chinese interlocutors did not take it all very seriously. They saw it more as an opening gambit in a negotiation than as a firm policy.

Ruddy explained:

During the campaign, Mr. Trump denounced Chinese trade policies, saying he would not allow Beijing “to rape our country” any longer. In early April, when President Trump met President Xi Jinping of China at Mar-a-Lago, in Palm Beach, Fla., he continued the tough talk. He and his aides told the Chinese delegation that the administration would impose restrictions on Chinese investments in the United States if Beijing did not lower its barriers to American investments in China.

And also:

There are also signs that Mr. Trump’s style is resonating with ordinary Chinese. Considering the harshness of his past statements about China, I was surprised by the number of people I met there who expressed respect for him. “He is a very successful businessman,” one said. “He is strong,” another said. One person noted, “I think in the past your country respected such people.”

Apparently, the Chinese never took Mr. Trump’s campaign rhetoric personally. They saw it as his starting point — a “negotiating position,” as Mr. Trump himself might say.

Apparently, people in China respect Trump more than American citizens do. After eight years of a weak and feckless Barack Obama the Chinese seem pleased to be able to deal with someone that consider to be “strong.” Trump’s actions in Syria were designed to send the same message. Where Barack Obama sucked up to Vladimir Putin for eight years, giving him free reign in the Middle East and Crimea, Trump reasserted America's place in the region. The result is that Putin's spokesman has been whining about how Vlad has not been getting enough time to talk to Trump. A deranged comedian draw our attention to the issue with an intemperate rant about Trump. In truth, as Colbert failed to notice, the president who was Putin's cock-holster was Barack Obama. Remember when Obama whispered to Dmitri Medvedev that he was looking forward to winning his second election because they he would be more forthcoming toward Vlad.

Be that as it may, it is astonishing that someone from China seemed to understand that America used to respect people who had achieved success in business… but that now, the media keeps labeling Trump an authoritarian fascist.

Strangely enough, when Trump, in a decidedly un-authoritarian and un-ideological turn, moderates his policies, the media calls him an inconstant flip-flopper. No longer does the media respect flexibility either.

If we examine the facts on the ground, indications are suggesting that the Chinese have changed their policy toward North Korea. One must keep in mind the delicacy of these changes. If Kim Jong-un feels that he might lose too much face, he will be less likely to concede anything.

In Ruddy’s words:

It is too soon to tell whether the Chinese will change their policies. But there are signs that the president’s antagonistic approach has opened the door to strategic cooperation on one of the world’s biggest problems: North Korea’s nuclear weapons program.

China already has suspended coal imports from Pyongyang in compliance with United Nations sanctions, and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said that China would impose more sanctions if North Korea continues its nuclear testing program. China’s foreign ministry spokesman said last week, “I can say in terms of solving the North Korean crisis, China’s efforts can’t be overstated.”

Of course, Ruddy was offering an analysis coupled with an opinion. Admittedly, it was an informed opinion, but neither he nor we have a full grasp of all the relevant information.

As for the facts, an article in the Wall Street Journal confirms parts of Ruddy’s analysis:

North Korea slammed China’s “insincerity and betrayal” in a commentary published late Wednesday, calling statements in the official Chinese media “an undisguised threat” to Pyongyang, as it sought to stave off pressure from Beijing on its nuclear and missile programs.

“China should no longer try to test the limits of the DPRK’s patience,” North Korea said in the commentary published by the official Korean Central News Agency, using the acronym for its formal name, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. “China had better ponder over the grave consequences to be entailed by its reckless act of chopping down the pillar of the DPRK-China relations.”

The commentary, which was attributed to a person identified only as Kim Chol, comes as China seeks to get North Korea to curb its weapons programs, amid pressure from U.S. President Donald Trump and other United Nations members.

North Korea was responding to statements that appeared in official Chinese publications. One takes them seriously, especially as they seem to indicate a policy shift:

North Korea’s latest statements referred to recent articles in two official Chinese publications, the People’s Daily and the Global Times, that apparently alluded to the possibility of Beijing confronting North Korea militarily, or ending friendly ties between the two neighbors and Cold War allies, if it didn’t halt its weapons programs.

The commentary also referred to Chinese press statements about North Korea’s weapons programs threatening China’s northeast, which borders North Korea, and about how Pyongyang’s actions were giving the U.S. an excuse to deploy more strategic assets to the region. The article said that the U.S. military buildup in Asia was aimed at China, not North Korea.

China’s hardening line on North Korea, the commentary said, showed that Beijing was “dancing to the tune of the U.S.,” and that China was exercising “big-power chauvinism” that meant “the dignity and vital rights of the DPRK should be sacrificed for the interests of China.”

At the least, this shows that some of Trump’s diplomacy seems to be producing a positive outcome. At the least, it has shown that China is willing, albeit subtly, to turn against its ally North Korea in order to secure better relations and a better trade deal with the United States. 

Thursday, May 4, 2017

Good Fences and Good Manners

Whether or not good fences make good neighbors, good manners certainly do. And yet, fences also matter. They create boundaries between what is mine and what is yours. They allow each of us a measure of privacy. They establish a difference between public and private property.

Fences place us somewhere, not everywhere and not nowhere. Being a member of a group means situating yourself, somewhere. You cannot belong if you are everywhere or nowhere.

A good neighbor respects your space. He is not always in your business. This shows his good manners.

We have it on the authority of Judith Martin, aka Miss Manners, that good manners are essential to social harmony and good relationships. Surely, the world would be a better place if all therapists were required to take a course in manners, in etiquette. Admittedly, etiquette does not always coincide with ethics, but still, good manners make you a member of a group. Bad behavior, or even manners that do not harmonize with those of other group members, will designate you an outsider. Trust me, you do not want to be an outsider.

Now, psychologist Ty Tashiro has written a new book about how to overcome social awkwardness. (Via Maggie’s Farm) Being naturally (or unnaturally) awkward himself, he has thought about the problem and has had to work hard to overcome what others might call his social anxiety. As it happens, he does not call it social anxiety, and thus prevents us from imagining that it can be treated with a pill. If you do not know etiquette no pill is going to teach it to you.

Tashiro arrives at some good conclusions about why manners matter, why they have always mattered and why they will continue to matter.

If you imagine that manners are constraining because they do not allow you to express yourself fully to other people, you have had too much therapy and do not understand the basics of social interaction.

Since we all want to know how manners developed in primitive societies, Tashiro quotes the research of anthropologist Mary Douglas. If you have good manners you are seen as a trustworthy member of a group:

Parents and other adults know that good manners are important because they’re a way to demonstrate your spirit of cooperation and respect for others. Anthropologist Mary Douglas has noted in her book Purity and Danger that our sharp attention to manners evolved from small hunter-gatherer groups, whose survival relied heavily on groups functioning as a coherent, cooperative whole. A rogue member who stole food, slacked during the hunt, or committed a treasonous act endangered the lives of everyone in the group.

When group survival depended on active participation in a cooperative enterprise, one that placed the good of the group ahead of personal gratification, manners mattered:

Manners served as a kind of early-warning system—a way to identify people whose actions might go against the broader good. A person who wasn’t good at waiting his turn for food was a potential threat. A simple “thank you” acknowledged that the group member was capable of recognizing the value of other people and their contributions.

If you are cooperative you also become more likable. This applies to you even if you are a robot. Yes, you heard that correctly:

Today, a growing number of scientists are exploring manners as they attempt to design robots that are trustworthy and likable. Early findings from this research suggest that it’s not the processing power or resolution of the graphic interface that matter when it comes to likability, but instead robots’ ability to execute routine manners properly—like not standing too close to a person, or listening when others speak. If people perceive a robot to be poorly mannered, then they don’t care about its technological brilliance.

What makes for good manners? Tashiro has a number of recommendations. True enough, we, and he could conjure up many more, but he had to start somewhere.

First, he recommends that we not force others to share our mood, even if we are happy. We should not, he suggests force others to feel the same optimism as we do. I would add that if we do so we do not respect the boundary between us and them. Thus we are being invasive and intrusive… and ignoring the Frostian theme.

Second, he suggests that we be kind to others. When a friend sends you a draft of an article he is working on, understand that it is a draft and that being a friend means offering support, not criticism. For reasons that escape me—or, should I say, that I wish escaped me— some people feel constrained to offer a ruthlessly critical assessment of work product, regardless of how much it hurts the other person. Or else, they ignore the work because they do not agree with it. Making kind, supportive gestures is a sign of good manners. Doing anything else makes you a moral lowlife.

You want to encourage the other person to keep working, not to make him feel so worthless that he cannot continue to work. Get it!

Third, respecting the privacy of others means not gossiping! When someone confides his problems with a task, you ought not to repeat what he has said, to anyone. This is especially important, Tashiro says, in workplace interactions:

One of the best courtesies you can give to your colleagues to show respect for their privacy. When you do talk about co-workers in their absence—particularly in groups—make sure to avoid putting their trials and tribulations in the spotlight.

Finally, Tashiro recommends that we react to the faults of others with grace. One might also say that we need to be concerned with saving the other person’s face. It is, dare I say, one of the keys to good human relations. If someone spills a drink you should not laugh at him, criticize him or even scowl at his clumsiness. You should pretend that it did not happen, or else, that it does not mean anything:

Unlike patience and tolerance, which involves suppressing a strong feeling of annoyance, grace arises from a spirit of goodwill—a provisional assumption that people mean well. I am more likely than the average person to accidentally call people by the wrong name or spill my drink on their lap. After these gaffes, no one feels worse than me. So it means a tremendous amount to me when people react with grace. They not only show forgiveness, they also demonstrate their faith that I am a well-intentioned person—who also happens to be clumsy at times.

If you feel annoyed, do not express your annoyance. You should not follow the advice that infects the therapy culture: to express your feelings, just because you feel them.

You and your friend, even you and your new acquaintance are supposedly on the same team. If you want to remain on the same team, you do best to cut him some slack and to ignore his infelicitous behaviors.

You do so, Tashiro notes, because you assume that your friend’s clumsiness is not intentional. You assume that he has not meant to insult you. You do what you learned in Sunday School: you turn the other cheek.

Turning the other cheek means that you should not retaliate until you know that a slight was intentional. You give the other person the benefit of the doubt, until you know otherwise.

Wednesday, May 3, 2017

Facebook, Heal Thyself.

The tech titans of Silicon Valley like to preach the gospel of political correctness. The great majority of them lean left and they firmly support diversity. That is, they support it everywhere but in their own shops.

As the proverb says: Physician, heal thyself. Apparently, the message has not made its way to Facebook, the tech behemoth whose Chief Operating Officer, Sheryl Sandberg has become a crusader for gender equality in the workforce.

Apparently, she had too much time on her hands. So she set out to teach women to get what was rightfully theirs, by leaning in. She never considered that many women did not want to become like Sheryl Sandberg. And she did not imagine that her advice, which prescribes macho posturing, was as likely to cause trouble as to garner raises. Being assertive, aggressive and in everyone’s face incurs risks, especially for beings who are constitutionally weaker than their male counterparts. Besides, team players do not lean in. Being overly concerned about yourself does not often go down very well in a corporate environment. As articulated, it was bad advice.

One adds, as a point of interest, that the tech company that has made the greatest strides toward gender equity—Marissa Mayer’s Yahoo!—is being sued for discriminating against men in promotion practices. We do not know why Mayer failed to revive the struggling company she took over, but one suspects that other tech companies will not be rushing out to emulate her example, thus to hire and promote more women. And corporate boards in the future are likely to think twice about hiring a pregnant CEO.

Now, the Wall Street Journal reports that Facebook employees have discovered insidious forms of gender discrimination in their own ranks. The horror of it all.

Apparently, female coders do not receive the same level of respect as male coders.

The Journal explains:

Last year, a longtime engineer at Facebook Inc.FB 0.21% gathered data that revealed a controversial finding: Code written by women was rejected much more frequently than code written by their male colleagues, according to people familiar with the matter and screenshots of internal discussions viewed by The Wall Street Journal.

For many female engineers at Facebook, the finding confirmed long-held suspicions that their coding faced more scrutiny than men’s.

The results touched off a debate within Facebook over alleged gender bias among some of its most-valued employees: the engineers who build the features used by nearly two billion people every month.

What was causing this disgraceful sexist discrimination, which was happening under the nose of the ever-watchful Sandberg? How did she, great feminist icon that she has fashioned herself, not notice? Was she too busy promoting her books and crusading for the feminist cause?

Facebook was on the case. The company launched an investigation. It discovered:

In an internal post published a month later, Jay Parikh, Facebook’s head of infrastructure, attributed any gap in rejection rates to an engineer’s rank, not gender. Many employees interpreted this new analysis as a sign that female engineers weren’t rising at the same rate as men who joined the company around the same time.

The higher ranking engineers are mostly male. It was an Ah-ha! moment. The discrimination was even worse than they had imagined. Male engineers were getting promoted more than female engineers. The only rational conclusion, to the politically correct mind, was that this situation had been produced by sexist bigotry. Of course, one might also suggest that the best coders were getting promoted more than those whose work was of inferior quality. Or else, women might be spending less time writing code because they have pressing family obligations. Or else, some people might be better at coding than others. After all, the situation as Facebook is replicated throughout Silicon Valley. Are they all a bunch of sexist bigots? And how does it happen that their companies, rife with discrimination, are doing so well in the marketplace?

What if women do not want to code? What if women are less interested in engineering, as a course of academic study or a career? One recalls that women in college are more likely to major in subjects like art history and psychology while men are drawn toward engineering programs. Ought we not to respect the choices that women make, freely, one hopes, about their careers?

So, we are supposed to be astonished to read that code written by women at Facebook received 35% more rejections than code written by men. Did anyone ask whether the code written by women was as good or better or worse than the code written by men? Is gender the only relevant factor? If both men and women were doing the same coding for the same application, then we might have a fair comparison, but what company has two people doing the same job? Or else, the company can ask two executives to review the same code, telling them that one was written by a man and the other by a woman. Doubtless that would do wonders for company morale.

Also, the Facebook analysis also did not take into account an engineer’s relevant pre-Facebook experience. An engineer who had worked in the field for five years before coming to Facebook would probably be better than someone who was beginning a career at Facebook.

Facebook and the rest of Silicon Valley show what happens when deeply felt ideals run into reality. Either you sacrifice the company to your ideals or you paper over the problem with noble sentiments and calls for people to overcome their bigotry. We certainly would not want to think that all of these committed diversity-mongers are really just ordinary hypocrites? Would we?

James Freeman summed it up in a Wall Street Journal column on the topic:

From everything we’ve been told, there is absolutely no shortage of highly sensitive progressives at the social-media giant, and yet the organization doesn’t seem to be leaning in that far toward a more diverse workplace. There is of course an old-fashioned argument that an organization should simply seek to hire and promote employees based on the content of their character and their talent and forget about what people look like on the outside. 

Tuesday, May 2, 2017

The View from Pyongyang

When considering foreign policy questions we should always try to see things through the eyes of our opponents or adversaries. So says George Friedman and he is certainly correct.

Consider an example that he does not evoke. If you recall the Tienanmen massacre of 1989, you know that from our comfortable sofas the student demonstrators looked like they were reliving Woodstock. It looked as though the counterculture had come to China and that democracy was busting out all over.

How many people asked themselves how it all looked to China’s leaders, paramount among whom was Deng Xiaoping. Precious few, I suspect. And yet,  they most likely saw the Red Guards and a risk of a new Cultural Revolution. What anyone should or should not have done is one thing. How the other side saw things provides an important perspective on events.

We ll drool over the therapeutic value of empathy, but how many of us can see things from someone else’s perspective. Especially since it requires extensive knowledge more that sensitivity to feelings.

Now, Friedman offers up a view of the current North Korean crisis, this time from Pyongyang. He warns us against thinking that the North Korean leader is insane. If his actions make no sense, that does not mean that he is necessarily insane. It might mean that you have not thought through the problem.

Friedman writes:

Conducting foreign policy or preparing for war requires the ability to put yourself in your adversary’s position. Unless you understand what he sees and how he thinks, his actions will make no sense to you. This will cause you to miscalculate because you will confuse a lack of understanding on your part with insanity or stupidity on your adversary’s part. If you dismiss your enemy as a clown or lunatic – when in reality he knows what he is doing and he understands what you are doing – his chances of succeeding soar, while your chances plummet. This is an important lesson to apply to the current situation on the Korean Peninsula.

How do the North Koreans see their place in the world and the risks it entails? Friedman answers:

Therefore, the North Koreans believed their position was strategically impossible. They faced three major powers, any one of which could annihilate North Korea. Their strategy was to avoid annihilation by proving it would not be worth anyone’s trouble. This did not mean being meek by any stretch. It required convincing other powers that they would incur a huge cost by absorbing or defeating North Korea. The country’s greatest strength was its relative unimportance. If it could also increase the dangers involved in being subdued, it could survive.

How did they choose to protect themselves?

To do this, the North Koreans would have to build a military machine capable of deterrence. A country as poor as North Korea had to militarize the entire society. It had to produce the wherewithal to survive and field a military force capable of keeping all others at bay. North Korea is still poor, but despite that poverty it is too dangerous to deal with. Modern North Korea is a rational adjustment to its perceived reality. It might follow that the populace would be restive. But whether through intimidation or contentment, little evidence exists that they are. So the North Korean government operates from a stable platform.

Thus, the government in Pyongyang has acted rationally. It has tried to ensure its survival under extremely difficult circumstances.

Friedman continues:

North Korea sees itself as alone and isolated. Its history shows that attempting to cooperate with its neighbors can lead to catastrophe. It also believes that it can predict and control American behavior, but this could also end in catastrophe. It has survived since the Korean War by not being a significant strategic prize and by possessing a force that deters intervention. North Korea’s world consists of China, Russia and the United States. South Korea and Japan are not going to take any steps without the United States. Therefore, the U.S. is the permanent threat, while Russia and China (particularly China) are both dangers and possible allies depending on circumstances. North Korea must be helpful to China but never again become a pawn or a battlefield.

One notes that Trump administration policy, as articulated by Secretary of State Tillerson rejects regime change in favor of denuclearization. One suspects that the Chinese are offering the same bargain. Also, losing nuclear weapons would not leave that nation entirely disarmed. Many people are more worried today about the thousands of rockets that are aimed at Seoul than about the threat of a nuclear attack.

Will North Korea buy it? It’s not obvious. Friedman suggests that they see nuclear weapons as the best insurance against invasion:

A safer course might be to abandon the nuclear program, but the North Koreans calculate that if they were to do this, they would be putting off the inevitable. Their deterrent power would decline, and their dependence on China and Russia would increase. That did not work well in the past. Therefore, the only prudent course is to hope that short-term considerations will force the Chinese and Russians to help them buy time to complete their nuclear deterrent.

He continues:

It is an enormously risky path for the North Koreans, but ever since the Soviet Union collapsed and the Chinese focused on Walmart, they have been on a precipice. They have survived by cunning, bluffing and the indifference of others. That is hope, not a strategy. Their strategy is to become too dangerous to attack. The U.S. is unpredictable, but one thing is certain: It will not engage a nuclear state that can strike back. The North Koreans have drawn China into the game, buying them more time. It is the witching hour for them, but they expected this and will play it out.

The North Korean government does not consist of one man. It has been pursuing a consistent policy for over half a century. It is now in the end game, and we do not know the answer to the most important question: Have the North Koreans already built a nuclear weapon, and if not, how much time do they need? We also do not know if China wants North Korea to be a nuclear power to absorb U.S. attention, or if it would be afraid of a nuclear North Korea. The U.S. and North Korea likely don’t know the answer, and perhaps the Chinese haven’t yet decided. But the point here is that North Korea is not stupid nor crazy. Such powers do not create conundrums vastly beyond their apparent resources.

At present, China seems to be putting more economic sanctions on the nation. If it really is no longer shipping oil to North Korea, the nation will suffer shortages and gas lines. If it ceases to buy North Korean coal the nation will have far fewer foreign currency reserves. And there is always the threat of mass starvation and famine. In the past North Korea has used this threat to extract concessions and food shipments from the West. One does not know whether the Trump administration and the Chinese will be quite as generous.

The Climate Change Debate Engaged

The debate is engaged. New York Times readers, having finished baying at the moon over Bret Stephens's views on climate change, are peppering the columnist and the paper with their questions. Good! These readers have every right to ask questions, even if those questions do not reveal very much deep thinking. It’s what happens when you live in a bubble and have never exchanged views in the marketplace of ideas.

And Stephens has responded to some of his detractors in the paper, or online. Again, good. It’s what debate is supposed to be.

The first detractor, named Len Sherman, feels that the ideological rigidity of climate change true believers is matched by Donald Trump’s disregard for facts, even by Trump’s failure to get his facts right. One recalls Barack Obama’s pronouncement that America had 58 states. The people who are trashing Trump’s obvious errors thought that Obama was right about the number of America’s states.

But, I digress.

Sherman is also discomfited by the fact that evangelical Christians dismiss science. While there must be some religious people who reject science, how many of today’s radical left believe in evolution? How many of them believe in Darwin’s theory about the difference between the sexes? How many of them believe that gender identity is a scientific fact? Or do they believe that it’s all a matter of belief? Since most of them do, they should shut up about who does or does not accept science.

But, I digress again.

Anyway, Sherman declares that, based on the scientific evidence that he has seen—one might wonder whether he has seen it all or whether he is qualified to evaluate it—the need for what he calls “righteous behavior” is a no-brainer. I assume that he means that people without a brain invoke the authority of science to justify what they consider to be “righteous behavior.” Does one not smell a whiff of piety?

Stephens responds by invoking an economic principle. We possess limited resources— this is true—and therefore we must judge where it would be best to invest those resources. It’s perfectly rational and even reasonable:

The human race is forced to confront multiple environmental threats with limited economic resources. We have to make hard choices about how we assess the threats and how we allocate the resources — knowing all the time that information is imperfect and economic and environmental conditions are subject to change over time. Climate change is one of those threats, but not the only one: think of malnutrition, “ordinary” pollution, land mismanagement and so on. We need a serious debate not only about how to allocate those resources, but also about whether we have the tools right now to make a switch to less carbon-intensive energy sources in a way that doesn’t impose its own set of grave and unanticipated economic and environmental problems.

In other words, if we accept the apocalyptic vision of pending climate doom, we should allocate all of our resources toward building windmills and installing solar panels. And  yet, what will this potential misallocation of resources cost those who inhabit the planet today?

Responding to the next questioner, Susan Fitzwater, Stephens notes that different counties have tried different ways to address global climate change, with not-so-encouraging results.

There were, for example, ethanol subsidies:

A decade ago we were plowing money into ethanol subsidies as one response to climate change. But that turned out to be not just environmentally destructive but was also arguably responsible for the spike in food prices that soon followed, as farmers turned away from cultivating corn for human consumption to cultivating it for ethanol production.

And then the British encouraged people to shift to diesel fuel, the better to diminish London’s pollution. How did that work out?

Stephens responds:

Another example: The New York Times recently reported on the massive increase in smog over London. The cause? Let me quote from the story:

“The British government provided financial incentives to encourage a shift to diesel engines because laboratory tests suggested that would cut harmful emissions and combat climate change. Yet, it turned out that diesel cars emit on average five times as much emissions in real-world driving conditions as in the tests, according to a British Department for Transport study.”

Next, Jason questions Stephens’s comparison of election polling with climate modeling. Since Stephens compared projections of the state of the climate with the prophetic powers of polling, Jason is asking a good question.

One suspects that Stephens was using a rhetorical ploy. But, anyway, here he uses the question to ask about the accuracy of climate modeling, especially those that pretend to predict the future to a scientific certainty:

The climate is an intensely complex system. Seemingly tiny differences in terms of inputs can make dramatic differences in terms of results. We should be humble about what we can know a year into the future, never mind a century, and we should be refining our assumptions continuously. That calls for more investment in science, not less.

I would add the obvious point, often noted her, drawn from the work of Ludwig Wittgenstein, to the effect that there is no such thing as a scientific fact about the future. Stephens argues a slightly different point, namely, that the systems that produce the climate are so complex, what makes you think that your calculations have included all the elements? After all, we miscalculated on ethanol and diesel. Why do you think that we have not done the same with the computer modeling?

Then Nils asks what harm would be done if we simply make the world a better place, regardless of the truth of the science. Of course, nothing about science tells us what constitutes better or worse. The question does expose one of the unstated presuppositions in the current environmental movement: namely the wish to repeal the Industrial Revolution. Because nothing has created as much pollution as those giant engines and their “dark Satanic Mills.”

To which one must respond that there has been good and bad with the Industrial Revolution. True enough, cars and steam engines have created pollution. But the IR has also greatly enhanced the quality of life for hundreds of millions of people and has nearly doubled the human lifespan. While we are trashing the IR let’s not forget modern sanitation and medicine, to say nothing of heating and air conditioning. Let's not forget that bacteria and viruses are part of the pristine beauty of the natural world. The same is true of mosquitoes and feral hogs.

Stephens has a slightly different take:

Interesting question, because it helps explain why so many people are drawn to the subject of climate change. To wit, it’s not just a matter of pure science. It’s also about morality, or at least a particular version of it. That’s why I’ve always thought there’s a quasi-religious dimension at work in climate-change advocacy, which not only describes the science but offers a catalog of prescribed (or proscribed) behaviors, and which tends to demonize people who aren’t wholly in tune with their assumptions.

He continues:

After all, even if you’ve diagnosed the cancer correctly doesn’t mean you can’t harm the patient with the wrong prescription. I’m urging sensible readers to be thoughtful about this, to look before we leap, to be aware that “do something!” may be satisfying as a moral reaction to a given problem but rarely makes for smart policy.

Stephens is obviously correct to point out the moralizing and moralistic basis behind the climate change crusade.

Finally, Elizabeth Berg explains that we should have engaged in the battle sooner. If we had, she opines, it would now be far less costly. Obviously, Stephens responded to this question when he pointed out the error of our ways with ethanol subsidies and diesel fuel. 

To Berg he offers the example of Angela Merkel’s environmentalist effort to shut down the nation’s nuclear power plants and to replace them with vastly more expensive windmills and solar panels:

For yet another example of what I mean, consider Germany’s “energy revolution,” an incredibly ambitious bid by Angela Merkel’s government to wean itself from fossil fuels. An in-depth report in Der Spiegel (admittedly from 2013) notes some of the effects:

“German consumers already pay the highest electricity prices in Europe. But because the government is failing to get the costs of its new energy policy under control, rising prices are already on the horizon. Electricity is becoming a luxury good in Germany, and one of the country’s most important future-oriented projects is acutely at risk.”

Suffice it to say that this dialogue shows the good that comes from engaging in debate with someone who disagrees with them. For many Times readers this must have been the first time that they had their most cherished beliefs challenged cogently. It is a very good thing.

Monday, May 1, 2017

The Fourth Reich

It was one hell of a weekend for the New York Times opinion pages. On Saturday new columnist Bret Stephens dared question the dogma of man-made global warming. Times readers, never having been exposed to such heresy, reacted… fast and furious. They canceled their subscriptions and poured out their anguish on Twitter.

Apparently, Times readers live in a bubble where theirs are the only opinions. It was as though they were warding off a witch by waving sprigs of garlic. And Stephens was merely arguing for scientific doubt. But, science has become a new religion and many scientists insist that their views be taken as gospel truth. Beyond even a smidgen of doubt.

Some Times readers  were shocked to the roots of their being to discover that theirs is not the only viewpoint. They might have suspected that other views exist, but, they were counting on the Times to protect them from such pollution.

They resemble the campus radicals who refuse to give a hearing to viewpoints that they consider heretical and that were—get this—a threat to their very being. They see ideas as weapons threatening them. John McWhorter suggested that they are trying to ward off a stench… the smell of pollution and corruption.

For the record, we applaud the Times for opening its opinion pages to a climate change heretic. If it could stop slanting the news, perhaps I would subscribe.

Anyway, if Stephens was bad,  Ross Douthat was surely worse. To the best of one’s knowledge Douthat’s effort to make the case for Marine Le Pen did not elicit the same cries of anguish as Stephens’ screed, but still, it took some serious chutzpah to publish such a thing. One suspects that left-thinking Times readers had exhausted their capacity for rage on Saturday. They didn’t have enough left to go after Douthat on Sunday. At least, not yet.

As often happens, Douthat wrote a challenging column, asking us to reconsider our general disapproval of a woman who seems destined to lose the French presidential run-off this Sunday.

The trouble with Le Pen, Douthat notes, is her association with a political party—the National Front—that has trafficked in Holocaust denial. The person most associated with this heinous opinion was Le Pen’s father, Jean-Marie Le Pen.

As it happens, Marine Le Pen denounced her father and purged him from the National Front… for continuing to deny the Holocaust. The two are no longer speaking.

Douthat explains:

Nor is there much evidence that Le Pen herself draws any personal inspiration from the Vichy right. However incomplete the project, she is the reason that her party has ejected Vichyites and disavowed anti-Semitism and moved toward the French mainstream on many issues.

This has been done, of course, in the hopes of gaining power. But that is how the purging of poisons always happens, and being disowned by one’s father is a quite costly and dramatic act of political purgation.

On this side of the Atlantic one draws an analogy between Marine Le Pen’s purge of her father and Barack Obama’s renunciation of Rev. Jeremiah Wright. How many people fell all over themselves proclaiming Obama’s break with the bigoted anti-Semitic and anti-white minister do not accept Marine Le Pen’s purge of her father? While no one is willing to forgive Le Pen for the history of the National Front, American liberals, in particular, thrilled to the prospect of forgiving Barack Obama for having spent twenty years listening to Jeremiah Wright… without having understood a word of what he was saying.

After mentioning that Marine Le Pen differs from the current American president because she brings a high level of political competence to her quest, Douthat addresses the salient issue.

France’s problems are in many ways worse than America’s. And France’s ruling elite—all of whom went to the same school—has no idea for solving them. Thus, Douthat finds Le Pen’s critique compelling:

These are the same sort of issues that helped Trump win the presidency, but in the European context the challenges are more severe and the populist critique more compelling.

There is no American equivalent to the epic disaster of the euro, a form of German imperialism with the struggling parts of Europe as its subjects. There is no American equivalent to the challenge of immigrant-assimilation now facing France — no equivalent of the domestic terror threat, the rise of Islamist anti-Semitism, the immigrant enclaves as worlds unto themselves.

Which means that while much of Trump’s notional agenda was an overreaction to the country’s problems, some of Le Pen’s controversial positions are straightforwardly correct.

If I may be permitted a discouraging word, Trump’s national agenda, especially the anti-immigrant part, might be an effort to ensure that America does not end up with the same problems that Europe does not seem capable of solving.

Muslim immigrants in France are responsible for a rising tide of anti-Semitism. They are committing acts of terrorism and have set off a crime wave. No one has a real solution to the problem. Worse yet, the European Union, will be forced to absorb the immigrants welcomed by German Chancellor Merkel.

Many are starting to see the European Union as a Fourth Reich—especially now that Great Britain is departing. Note how appalled the Merkel government is over the British departure. It almost seems willing to go to war against Theresa May’s government. Naturally, a Le Pen victory would remind French voters of Vichy France, when the nation was cowed into collaborating with Hitler.

Then, Douthat continues to list what Le Pen has gotten right:

She is right that France as a whole, recent immigrants as well as natives, would benefit from a sustained mass-immigration halt.

She is right that the European Union has given too much unaccountable power to Brussels and Berlin and favored financial interests over ordinary citizens.

And while many of her economic prescriptions are half-baked, her overarching critique of the euro is correct: Her country and her continent would be better off without it.

As for whether the continent would be better off without the Euro, I will leave it to others to decide. Since Macron has already been pushed around by Merkel, one expects that once he is president she will continue to treat him like a junior partner. It’s not quite the same thing as the ridicule he has received from the British tabloid media, but still.

The Telegraph reported the run-in on Sunday:

Emmanuel Macron, the man widely expected to be the next French president, tried to help Greece avoid crippling austerity measures but was frozen out of negotiations by Germany's Angela Merkel, the Sunday Telegraph can reveal.

The confrontation at the height of the 2015 Greek debt crisis is revealed in “Adults in the Room”, the new memoir of Yanis Varoufakis, the controversial former Greek finance minister who tried - but failed - to win debt relief for Greece. 

The episode sheds new light on the potentially awkward relationship between Mr Macron and Mrs Merkel who, polls suggest, is on track to win a record-equalling fourth term as German leader later this year.

Douthat ends his column by suggesting that he prefers Macron to Le Pen. History matters, he adds, and the history of the National Front disqualifies it from holding serious public office. And yet, beyond the fact that Macron is likely to have a very difficult time governing the nation, failure to address France’s Muslim immigration problem will surely bring her back.

We have not heard the last of Marine Le Pen.