Friday, March 4, 2022

Has Russia Been Shunned by the World?

How isolated is Vlad? As the West has been fighting aggression by using financial warfare-- without very much of a sense of the repercussions-- other nations in other parts of the world have not been shunning Russia.

Putin and his henchmen may be persona non grata in America and Western Europe, but they are not being rejected across the world. Fair enough, Russia has been frozen out of the world economy, and this is causing some considerable hardship, but we will refrain from concluding that this has brought down the tyrant. In truth, without Russian supplies, of energy, raw materials and grain… the world economy will be in very big trouble.


More on that another day.


For now, we remark, following a Wall Street Journal report, that nations in the Middle East, from Israel to Saudi Arabia to the United Arab Emirates are not joining the chorus denouncing Russia. The same is true of Asian nations, from China and India to Indonesia.


The reasons are complex, and have been obscured by the fog of war.


In some considerable part Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have been alienated from America by the Biden administration’s ineptitude. Surely, the Biden administration’s efforts to rescue the regime in Tehran and to allow them to wreak havoc throughout the Middle East has not improved the prospects for diplomacy. 


Saudi Arabia and the Emirates have other concerns. According to the Journal:


U.S. efforts to sway Riyadh have been complicated by the fraught relations between President Biden and Prince Mohammed, known as MBS, who has been shunned by the U.S. president for his role in the death of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi in 2018.


“The fact that Biden refuses to acknowledge MBS as the de facto leader of Saudi Arabia makes the decision easier for MBS to take the side of Putin, who, despite some hiccups, has been closer to him,” said a Saudi adviser.


It’s cold comfort to know that the Biden team has been working to clean up the mess that it created, but such is the case:


The Biden administration has been working to rebuild relations with Saudis, sending high level delegations to Riyadh and arranging a Feb. 24 call between Mr. Biden and Saudi Arabia’s King Salman, the U.S. official said.


The Biden team also messed up relations with the Emirates by removing the Houthi rebels in Yemen from the terrorist list, the better to suck up to Iran. Said rebels have been shooting missiles into the Emirates, which does not endear its leaders to Joe Biden. 


The administration’s relations with the U.A.E. have seemed even frostier, highlighted by the Emirati abstention from a U.N. Security Council vote condemning Moscow’s invasion, despite direct appeals from U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken.


“We believe that alignment and positioning will only lead to more violence,” Anwar Gargash, a U.A.E. presidential adviser in a tweet on Sunday. “In the Ukrainian crisis, our priorities are to encourage all parties to adopt diplomacy and negotiate to find a political settlement that ends this crisis.”


Abu Dhabi’s decision to not back the resolution also appeared linked to its effort to win Moscow’s backing for a separate U.N. resolution condemning missile and drone attacks against the U.A.E. and Saudi Arabia by Houthi rebels in Yemen.


The story has also made its way to the pages of the New York Times. The Times suggests that the current conflict in Ukraine has pitted the forces of democracy against the forces of authoritarianism. It is not alone in doing so.


If one were feeling cynical, one might say that it’s the boys against the girls. Or better, that it’s the hard power of warfare against the soft power of punishing sanctions. One understands that the greened West has been embracing weakness as a political strategy, and thereby has invited Russian aggression.


So, whose side do you want to be on? That of the boys or that of the girls.


Be that as it may the Times report suggests that Russia has more than a few friends left in the world:


Generals in Myanmar have called Russia’s actions “the right thing to do.” India abstained from a United Nations Security Council resolution to condemn the attack. China has refused to call the assault on Ukraine an invasion. And in Vietnam, Vladimir V. Putin, the Russian president, is being affectionately referred to as “Uncle Putin.”


While most American allies in the region have fallen in line, authoritarian governments and those with weaker ties to the West have been more reluctant to act on the conflict in Ukraine. Across the Asia-Pacific, only Japan, Singapore, South Korea and Australia have agreed to international sanctions against Moscow. Taiwan, the self-governed territory that China claims as its own, has also agreed to sanctions and voiced support for Ukraine.


The uneven response is unlikely to counterbalance the onslaught of Western anger, but it could test the limits of President Biden’s pledge to make Mr. Putin a “pariah on the international stage.”


Russia’s influence in Asia is minimal compared with that of the United States, though it has grown in recent years, with a particular focus on arms sales. Already, the economic ministry in Moscow announced last Friday that it would seek to expand economic and trade ties with Asia to help offset Western sanctions.


“I don’t think we will shun Russia,” said Bilahari Kausikan, Singapore’s former ambassador to Russia. “It is still a big country and is a nuclear weapons state.” It is also a permanent member of the Security Council, a status that is unlikely to change, Mr. Kausikan said.


And also:


“Indonesia does not see Russia as a threat to global politics or as a foe,” said Dinna Prapto Raharja, an associate professor in international relations at Bina Nusantara University in Jakarta. “Unilateral sanctions limit the chance for negotiation and heightens the sense of insecurity to the affected countries,” she added.


Last Thursday, Teuku Faizasyah, a spokesman for Indonesia’s Foreign Ministry, suggested that the country had no intention of imposing sanctions against Moscow, arguing it would “not blindly follow the steps taken by another country.”


Of course, the issue in Asia must be China. I suspect, without possessing any insider information, that if China’s president had not given Putin the green light, none of this would have been happening. We have been denouncing China for genocide and for systematic oppression, but then we cannot figure out why, when the Biden administration asked China to prevail on Russia not to invade, the Chinese passed on the intelligence to Russia. Actions have consequences, even self-righteous rhetorical actions.


Countries in the region might very well see China as the future and decadent America as the past. As I suggested, the boys versus the girls.


And then there is Russian ally, India:


In India, Moscow has been seen as a reliable military partner for decades. New Delhi is the world’s second-largest importer of Russian arms, which account for about half of its military supplies. When Mr. Putin visited New Delhi late last year, Russia detailed the sale of a $5.4 billion missile defense system to the country.


India has been careful not to condemn Russia over Ukraine and upset a time-tested friendship at a moment when China is threatening to encroach on its northeastern border. Moscow repeatedly used its veto power at the Security Council to block resolutions critical of India over Kashmir, a disputed territory India shares with Pakistan. In return, India abstained from a U.N. resolution condemning Moscow over its annexation of Crimea in 2014.


Indian officials said last week that they may even help Russia find workarounds for the new sanctions by setting up rupee accounts to continue trade with Moscow, similar to what it did after the annexation of Crimea.


To expand on the point Gerald Seib, of the Wall Street Journal, assessed the reactions of India and China to the Russian invasion of Ukraine.


China and India, the world’s two most populous countries, are squirming yet not united with the West in isolating Russia. Potentially, they could provide a critical lifeline. Increasingly, a key question for Mr. Putin and his economy is going to be where they land.


Will they be a lifeline that saves Russia from the financial warfare the West has unleashed?


Both countries abstained on a United Nations resolution condemning the Russian invasion. That seems particularly galling, coming after decades of lectures directed to the West from both China and India about the need to honor nations’ sovereignty and territorial integrity. It’s hard to imagine an action more in violation of those principles than the drive into Ukraine.


Seib offers the views of Harvard professor and expert in all things Chinese, one Graham Allison. He remarks, sagely, that Russia and China have been thrown together by American rhetoric demonizing them equally. One likes to imagine that threatening the reputation of world leaders is an innocent exercise in free speech. Unfortunately, such actions often have dire consequences. Threaten the face of such leaders and you might have to pay a price:


Mr. Allison argues that the Chinese leader has “defied political gravity” by building a strong bond with the leader of Russia, with which relations had previously been tense and even confrontational. “This has been done largely by the art of Xi, and by us demonizing both of them,” he says. China and Russia, Mr. Allison says, are constructing what the late strategic thinker Zbigniew Brzezinski feared they might: a coalition in which they are united by shared grievances against the U.S.


China is being cagey and subtle in its diplomacy, suggesting that it wants to be a world leader:


This doesn’t mean China will publicly endorse the invasion. “The Chinese will wiggle and stumble where they can because this is an unambiguous, gross violation of their principles for the international order,” Mr. Allison says.


But beyond the public ambivalence, he believes, China will provide Mr. Putin economic relief: “Every bit of gas he doesn’t sell to Europe the Chinese will buy.” Beijing might provide help for a Russian tech sector cut off from the West. Beyond that, the Chinese probably figure they benefit from a prolonged U.S.-Russian confrontation because American military resources are diverted away from Asia and toward Europe.


For the record, Robert Gates disagrees:


Still, Robert Gates, former CIA director and defense secretary, isn’t so sure. He thinks Mr. Xi may have been unpleasantly surprised by how far Mr. Putin has gone in Ukraine, and is unhappy about that. “He wanted a calm 2022” for his Olympics and a coming Communist Party congress where he will win another term, says Mr. Gates. “I think this is a disruption and a unification of the West that he didn’t want.”


Seib concludes that Putin is certainly not as isolated as we like to imagine:


So yes, Mr. Putin faces a united economic backlash from the West. But he also knows the North Atlantic Treaty Organization would act to directly help Ukraine militarily only by unanimous consent, which isn’t happening. And he knows two countries containing a third of the world’s population aren’t signing up for the economic war against him. Perhaps he doesn’t feel as isolated as some think.


Thursday, March 3, 2022

A Clear-Eyed Look at the War in Ukraine

I do not need to tell you, but I have no experience or expertise in military matters. Thus, I will not presume to offer an evaluation of the state of play in the Russian invasion of Ukraine. 

And yet, the more I see talking heads on television claiming that Russian president Putin is insane and that the brave Ukrainians are winning the war, the more I suspect that they are all either deluded or lying. Besides, social media outlets is carefully curating the news in order to push the narrative that the Ukrainians are willing and that Putin is crazy.


We like to trust the people who are running our own defense establishment, but, of late, aside from the calamity they visited on Afghanistan, they seem most concerned with making our military more diverse and more co-ed. Oh, and going to war against the weather. If you imagine that an adversary, seeing the silliness coming out of the Pentagon, will feel deterred, you are grossly misinformed.


One does not like to say that one does not trust their judgment, but one does not trust their judgment.


So, seeking a contrary opinion, I discovered an analysis by one Bill Roggio, someone who works for the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies. (via Maggie's Farm) Roggio has a long experience with military matters, and he offered his analysis to The Daily Mail. Why is it that the Daily Mail is willing to go where other media outlets won’t?


Roggio suggests that the prevalent narrative, the one that is being hawked by commentators on the left and the right, and that seems to be underwriting our government’s policy, has it that Putin has lost his mind and that he cannot win out over a vibrant liberal democracy. The other piece of the narrative, one that I will address in a later post, has it that the nations of the world are united in their condemnation of Russian aggression. At the least, we know that, however united Western nations are, the rest of the world is far from supportive of the Ukrainians. Or even of a regime that had been installed by the Obama state department.


So, Roggio opens by suggesting that our sympathies for the Ukrainians have overwhelmed our judgment:


Sympathy for the outnumbered and outgunned defenders of Kyiv has led to the exaggeration of Russian setbacks, misunderstanding of Russian strategy, and even baseless claims from amateur psychoanalysts that Putin has lost his mind.


A more sober analysis shows that Russia may have sought a knockout blow, but always had well-laid plans for follow-on assaults if its initial moves proved insufficient.


The world has underestimated Putin before and those mistakes have led, in part, to this tragedy in Ukraine.


We must be clear-eyed now that the war is underway.


As might be expected, Pentagon leaders have no sense of the reality of the situation. They were not, unfortunately, chosen for their military abilities, but for their acceptance of the ideology of diversity, inclusion and equity. Oh, and for their belief in climate change:


Yet even the professionals at the Pentagon are letting sympathy cloud their judgement.


Just two days into Russia's invasion of Ukraine, U.S. Department of Defense briefers were quick to claim that failing to take Kyiv in the opening days of the war amounted to a serious setback.


DoD briefers implied that Russia's offensive was well behind schedule or had even failed because the capital had not fallen.


But U.S. leaders should have learned to restrain their hopes after their catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan.


Once again, U.S. and Western officials are falling into the trap of failing to understand the enemy and his objectives.


Now, what of Putin? Roggio suggests that Putin would have preferred a quick surrender, but that he planned for a larger, more protracted conflict:


Putin certainly hoped for a swift victory, but he clearly was not relying on his opening salvo as the only plan for success.


Rather, the Russian military was prepared to take the country by force if a swift decapitation strike fell short.


What was the plan for an invasion?


A look at the Russian military offensive demonstrates there was a plan for a full-scale invasion, which Russia is now executing.


Conventional, mechanized warfare is a time and resource consuming enterprise, and an operation of this scope isn't cobbled together in days.


The Russian offensive is taking place on four separate fronts. On a fifth front, in eastern Ukraine, which Putin declared independent last week, Russian forces are tying down Ukrainian troops that are needed elsewhere.


The bulk of the Russian forces are advancing southward from Belarus to Kyiv.


Russian advance forces, including air, mobile and reconnaissance troops, have been engaged with Ukrainian troops outside of Kyiv since the start of the war.


A massive column of Russian troops, estimated at over 40 miles long, is just 20 miles north of Kyiv, and is likely assembling to surround the capital.


If Russian forces can take Kyiv and push southward to link up with forces on the Crimean front, thus splitting Ukraine in two, it would be a major blow to the Zelensky government.


What matters more than a handful of setbacks is that Russian forces have pushed 70 miles into contested terrain in less than a week and are on the outskirts of the capital.


Military analysis looks at how far an army has advanced. Thus, Roggio suggests, the offensive is proceeding according to plan.


This is not a sign of a disorganized, poorly assembled, and failed offensive.


The southward push from Belarus to Kyiv is supported by another Russian column, launched from the east in the vicinity of Kursk.


If this column can link up with Russian troops near Kyiv, it will envelop Ukrainian forces in most of Chernihiv and Sumy provinces, depriving the Ukrainian military of much needed soldiers and war material needed elsewhere, and cutting off the government from two northern provinces.


As for Putin himself, he has not lost his mind. He is not senile and demented like the leader of our great country. He is a calculating adversary, one who seems to lack the empathy we prize in our own deficient and soft-headed leaders.


Putin appears to want to take Ukraine intact, but will not hesitate to increase the level of brutality if needed.


The systematic nature of the Russian assault is at odds with speculation that Putin has lost control of his senses.


Nobody knows for sure, but Putin's actions appear to be that of a cold and calculating adversary.


Dismissing his decision to invade Ukraine as a form of madness is effectively an excuse to ignore Putin's likely motivations and future actions.


Strategically, Putin's advance on Ukraine began well over a decade ago, when he invaded and Balkanized Georgia by recognizing the Kremlin's puppet regimes in the regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.


Perhaps, Putin miscalculated the extent of Western sanctions. He might have underestimated the vigor of the Ukrainian resistance. And yet, that merely requires him to recalibrate his battle plan. Which army has never had to do the same?


Today, Putin has calculated that taking Ukraine by force is in his and Russia's interest.


He no doubt anticipated that the West would impose diplomatic and economic sanctions, which U.S. and European leaders threatened beforehand.


Putin may have miscalculated Ukrainian resistance and the intensity of the West's opposition, but it doesn't mean he is crazy, or didn't consider the possibilities and chose to invade regardless.


It remains to be seen if Putin's plan will succeed or fail, but what is clear is that there was a plan to invade Ukraine in force, and that plan has been executed since day one.


Ukrainian troops are putting up a valiant fight facing long odds and difficult conditions. Russia holds most if not all of the advantages.


It can, and has, attacked Ukraine from three different directions. The Russian military holds a decided advantage in manpower, as well as air, naval and armor superiority.


It has vast resources to draw on. While Ukraine has the support of much of the international community, which is providing weapons, Ukraine is fighting alone.


Believing Russia's assault is going poorly may make us feel better but is at odds with the facts.


We cannot help Ukraine if we cannot be honest about its predicament.


It would be a welcome improvement over today’s cheerleading for what appears to be a lost cause.



Socialized Medicine Is Failing in Great Britain

How is that socialized medicine working out? We recall, with some chagrin, that sad day in 2012 when Great Britain, hosting the Olympic Games for the third time, produced a song and dance number extolling the greatness of its National Health Service. We recall an absurdist dance of patients, doctors and hospital beds. The nation had somehow lost its creative spark.

Anyway, at the time when Americans were being instructed to embrace Obamacare, and where some strange souls insisted that it was a step toward socialized medicine, its defenders argued: it works so well in Great Britain, so why should we not try it over here.


If so, they spoke too soon. Now, the NHS is failing in its task. It imposes unconscionably long wait times for the most routine procedures, and even for some not-so-routine services.


The result, dutifully reported in the Guardian-- not a piece of the right wing media-- is that more and more people are going private. That is, they are buying private insurance and even paying out of pocket for more prompt and more effective medical care. Thus, once-Great Britain is instituting a two-tiered medical system-- one that, horror of horrors, resembles nothing if not the American way.


Growing numbers of Britons are paying for private medical treatment in a shift that could undermine the NHS and create a “two-tier” health system, a report has warned.


Declining access to and quality of NHS care, both worsened by the Covid-19 pandemic, have begun to “supercharge” the trend, with one in six people prepared to go private instead of waiting.


That is among the findings of a report by the left-leaning IPPR thinktank, which warns that in future getting fast, high-quality care on the NHS could become as difficult as the situation that already exists in regards to state-funded dental treatment, which has become a postcode lottery.


“People are not opting out of the NHS because they have stopped believing in it as the best and fairest model of healthcare,” said Chris Thomas, the IPPR’s principal research fellow and co-author of the report.


“Rather, those who can afford it are being forced to go private by the consequences of austerity and the pandemic on NHS access and quality, and those without the funds are left to ‘put up or shut up’.”


The report says that unless the NHS starts performing better “people who can and are willing to do so will supplement their entitlement to NHS care with private healthcare products”.


Wednesday, March 2, 2022

Energy Wars

Michael Shellenberger is hardly the only voice arguing that the West’s green energy mania helped produce the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Yet, I offer his views, printed on Bari Weiss’s Substack site, for your edification. (via Maggie's Farm)

Of course, Europe is highly reliant on Russia for energy. You know it. Vladimir Putin knows it:


Putin knows that Europe produces 3.6 million barrels of oil a day but uses 15 million barrels of oil a day. Putin knows that Europe produces 230 billion cubic meters of natural gas a year but uses 560 billion cubic meters. He knows that Europe uses 950 million tons of coal a year but produces half that.


The former KGB agent knows Russia produces 11 million barrels of oil per day but only uses 3.4 million. He knows Russia now produces over 700 billion cubic meters of gas a year but only uses around 400 billion. Russia mines 800 million tons of coal each year but uses 300.


That’s how Russia ends up supplying about 20 percent of Europe’s oil, 40 percent of its gas, and 20 percent of its coal. 


How did it happen? According to Shellenberger, Europeans caught climate change fever and decided to reconfigure their energy sourcing in order to save the planet from the pending climate apocalypse. They wanted to replace fossil fuels and nuclear with renewables like solar and wind:


How is it possible that European countries, Germany especially, allowed themselves to become so dependent on an authoritarian country over the 30 years since the end of the Cold War? 


Here’s how: These countries are in the grips of a delusional ideology that makes them incapable of understanding the hard realities of energy production. Green ideology insists we don’t need nuclear and that we don’t need fracking. It insists that it’s just a matter of will and money to switch to all-renewables—and fast. It insists that we need “degrowth” of the economy, and that we face looming human “extinction.” (I would know. I myself was once a true believer.)


What was the result? Or better, what happens when you take your marching orders from a Swedish schoolgirl who knows nothing about science?


At the turn of the millennium, Germany’s electricity was around 30 percent nuclear-powered. But Germany has been sacking its reliable, inexpensive nuclear plants. (Thunberg called nuclear power “extremely dangerous, expensive, and time-consuming” despite the UN’s International Panel on Climate Change deeming it necessary and every major scientific review deeming nuclear the safest way to make reliable power.)


By 2020, Germany had reduced its nuclear share from 30 percent to 11 percent. Then, on the last day of 2021, Germany shut down half of its remaining six nuclear reactors. The other three are slated for shutdown at the end of this year. (Compare this to nextdoor France, which fulfills 70 percent of its electricity needs with carbon-free nuclear plants.)


Renewables might well be renewable, but they are also costly and unreliable.


Germany has also spent lavishly on weather-dependent renewables—to the tune of $36 billion a year—mainly solar panels and industrial wind turbines. But those have their problems. Solar panels have to go somewhere, and a solar plant in Europe needs 400 to 800 times more land than natural gas or nuclear plants to make the same amount of power. Farmland has to be cut apart to host solar. And solar energy is getting cheaper these days mainly because Europe’s supply of solar panels is produced by slave labor in concentration camps as part of China’s genocide against Uighur Muslims.


It’s the Angela Merkel legacy. And she was not even a leftist. She was a center right politician.


The upshot here is that you can’t spend enough on climate initiatives to fix things if you ignore nuclear and gas. Between 2015 and 2025, Germany’s efforts to green its energy production will have cost $580 billion. Yet despite this enormous investment, German electricity still costs 50 percent more than nuclear-friendly France’s, and generating it produces eight times more carbon emissions per unit. Plus, Germany is getting over a third of its energy from Russia.


If you were hoping that the West could hurt Russia by cutting down on imported energy sources, you were easily disabused. As it happened, European companies needed to buy more energy from Russia. Ukraine notwithstanding, they did what they had to do.


Naturally, when American sanctions on Russia’s biggest banks were finally announced in concert with European allies last week, they specifically exempted energy products so Russia and Europe can keep doing that dirty business. A few voices called for what would really hit Russia where it hurts: cutting off energy imports. But what actually happened was that European energy utilities jumped to buy more contracts for the Russian oil and gas that flows through Ukraine. That’s because they have no other good options right now, after green activism’s attacks on nuclear and importing fracked gas from America. There’s no current plan for powering Europe that doesn’t involve buying from Putin.


Q. E. D.



The War Is Only in the Third Inning

The ongoing military conflict between Russia and Ukraine is taking place on two fronts. On the one side, the Russian military incursion seems bogged down, though that might simply be the way the news is being reported in the West. On the other side, the West, and only the West has risen up to smite the Russian bear-- through economic sanctions. Some accounts have it that the Russian economy is about to collapse completely, along with the Russian military effort in Ukraine.

Dare I say that we ought to be skeptical about these ideas. The game is still in the third inning and we do not know the outcome. On the one side, if things are not going well for the Russian military that might lead to increased bombardment and more civilian casualties. On the other side, if Russia has become an economic pariah, this might also mean that it is being pushed into a deepening alliance with China-- and also with countries in the Middle East and South Asia. One notes that the crushing economic sanctions and the violent rhetoric directed against Russia is not coming from nations outside of the West.


Anyway, here are two takes on the war’s two fronts. Writing in the Atlantic David French suggests that Russia seems to have miscalculated the Ukrainian resistance. One might also say, French writes, that Russia seems to have wanted to limit the number of civilian casualties, and thus did not begin the invasion with a bombing campaign:


Russia seems to have believed that Ukraine would collapse. It didn’t begin its invasion with a truly intense aerial or artillery bombardment because it didn’t think that would be necessary. Why destroy a city you intend to almost immediately control? Why risk inflaming Ukrainian (and world) opinion when you’d be presenting the international community with a fait accompli—something like the Crimean takeover, except on a national scale?


While we all thrill to the apparent breakdown of the less-than-formidable Russian military machine, we should take special heed of French’s next point, namely that the initial failure will most likely be followed by a stepped up campaign of violence:


But for all of the stories of Russian failure, here is the very bad news: Russia will far more likely respond to battlefield setbacks the way it traditionally has—with overwhelming firepower—than by seeking peace.


The history of warfare (including the history of Russian warfare) is replete with examples of early failures and terrible command decisions. But armies tend to be learning organisms. If the fight doesn’t go as they expect, they adjust tactics.


While we are cheering on the Ukrainian resistance, we should understand that the more they hold out, the worse things are going to get:


Indeed, as much as Ukrainian resistance has inspired the West, it’s hard to believe that a few days of fighting have chastened Russia or deterred President Vladimir Putin. Much more likely is that he believes he has no choice but to press on to victory. To preserve his power, he has to win. Prediction is a dangerous business, but the likelihood now is that Putin will step on the gas and increase the violence and intensity of his attack. The possibility that he’ll halt his forces in place—to say nothing of retreating from Ukrainian territory—is far slimmer.


For the record, remember what happened in Tiananmen Square thirty or so years ago. The students had achieved a great moral victory by standing down the Chinese authorities. And then we saw the image of a lone citizen standing strong against a column of tanks. The image has become iconic; we all marvel at the man’s courage.


A humiliated leadership, however, is a dangerous leadership. Once the man was removed from the street the Chinese authorities turned off the lights and cameras and directed the tanks to run over the students who were still remaining in the square. Using snipers and tanks they massacred the student demonstrators. When you think of how wonderful it was to see a single man stopping a column of tanks, keep in mind that it was a moment in time, one that led to an appalling tragedy.


For his part French sees some rather bad outcomes:


Putin can still lose by winning. In other words, the cost of his likely battlefield victory could be so great that it ultimately diminishes Russian power or even destabilizes his regime, but even so, imagining a scenario where Ukraine wins outright is difficult. NATO-supplied weapons may bleed the Russian army, but they seem unlikely to turn the tide on the battlefield. One can hope that the combination of Ukrainian courage, NATO weapons, and low Russian morale can turn the tide, but the odds against Ukraine are long.


It can choose to go “full Grozny” and turn Ukrainian cities into the most destroyed cities on Earth.


Yes, that would further galvanize world opinion against Putin, but he’s already isolated. He’s already sanctioned, and the Russian economy is already “reeling.” Moreover, it’s still early in the conflict. If the Russians ultimately break through, seize Kyiv, and kill or capture Ukrainian leaders, hope will give way to despair, the people of Ukraine will pay a terrifying price, and true independence will once again be a distant dream.


French concludes:


The West has woken up. NATO is united. Russia has already been made to pay for its aggression. But its army is still in Ukraine, grabbing more territory every day. It may learn from its mistakes, growing more aggressive to both destroy the Ukrainian resistance and deter additional foreign interference in the fight. If Russia does ultimately break Ukraine, the first flush of hope is likely to be forgotten amid the ashes of defeat.


As for the impact of economic sanctions and wealth confiscation, we are hardly qualified to assess it. And yet, listening yesterday to a member of New York City’s City Council promoted the idea of confiscating the city condos owned by Russian oligarchs elicited this reflection.


We wonder how much of the New York and the Miami real estate markets are being kept solvent by foreign money. And how much of that money is being parked in American condos because America is a safe and secure place to leave your money. We already saw what happened in Canada when the hapless Justin Trudeau decided to freeze bank accounts and credit cards. And we know that he had to revoke the order, apparently because there was a run on banks. What would happen to American real estate if foreigners decided not to invest-- not to mention what would happen if they chose to start selling out.


Anyway, one Pepe Escobar has reflected on the cost of the economic sanctions being visited on Russia. We have already offered David Goldman’s view, namely that they will push Russia closer to China and will damage the viability of the dollar as a reserve currency.


Escobar asked Michael Hudson his view of the current state of the economic war against Russia, one that, if you read the papers, seems to be succeeding:


To get the hang of how these NATO sanctions will “ruin Russia,” I asked for the succinct analysis of one of the most competent economic minds on the planet, Michael Hudson, author, among others, of a revised edition of the must-read Super-Imperialism: The Economic Strategy of American Empire.


Hudson remarked how he is “simply numbed over the near-atomic escalation of the US.” On the confiscation of Russian foreign reserves and cut-off from SWIFT, the main point is “it will take some time for Russia to put in a new system, with China. The result will end dollarization for good, as countries threatened with ‘democracy’ or displaying diplomatic independence will be afraid to use US banks.”


If you think it will be bad for the condo market if we start confiscating homes owned by Russian oligarchs, what will happen if foreign countries stop using our banks. That does not just include Russia-- it includes many Middle Eastern countries and even Asian states. The threat of confiscation now looms over Western banks.


And then there is the issue of the West’s need for Russian raw materials. As you doubtless know, we in America are still buying a considerable quantity of Russian oil. Apparently, Joe Biden did not take responsibility for that in his speech yesterday.


But, it is not just oil:


This, Hudson says, leads us to “the great question: whether Europe and the Dollar Bloc can buy Russian raw materials – cobalt, palladium, etc, and whether China will join Russia in a minerals boycott.”


Hudson is adamant that “Russia’s Central Bank, of course, has foreign bank assets in order to intervene in exchange markets to defend its currency from fluctuations. The ruble has plunged. There will be new exchange rates. Yet it’s up to Russia to decide whether to sell its wheat to West Asia, that needs it; or to stop selling gas to Europe via Ukraine, now that the US can grab it.”


As David Goldman and others have noted Russia will now be obliged to replace SWIFT with the Chinese version:


About the possible introduction of a new Russia-China payment system bypassing SWIFT, and combining the Russian SPFS (System for Transfer of Financial Messages) with the Chinese CIPS (Cross-Border Interbank Payment System), Hudson has no doubts “the Russian-China system will be implemented. The Global South will seek to join and at the same time keep SWIFT – moving their reserves into the new system.”


De-dollarization is not a good thing for America. Escobar explains some of the potential consequences:


As the managing director of Bocom International Hong Hao told the Global Times, with energy trade between Europe and Russia de-dollarized, “that will be the beginning of the disintegration of dollar hegemony.”


Those with IQs over 50 in the European Union (EU) must have understood that Russia simply could not be totally excluded from SWIFT, but maybe only a few of its banks: after all, European traders depend on Russian energy.


From Moscow’s point of view, that’s a minor issue. A number of Russian banks are already connected to China’s CIPS system. For instance, if someone wants to buy Russian oil and gas with CIPS, payment must be in the Chinese yuan currency. CIPS is independent of SWIFT.


Additionally, Moscow already linked its SPFS payment system not only to China but also to India and member nations of the Eurasia Economic Union (EAEU). SPFS already links to approximately 400 banks.


With more Russian companies using SPFS and CIPS, even before they merge, and other maneuvers to bypass SWIFT, such as barter trade – largely used by sanctioned Iran – and agent banks, Russia could make up for at least 50 percent in trade losses.


The key fact is that the flight from the US-dominated western financial system is now irreversible across Eurasia – and that will proceed in tandem with the internationalization of the yuan.


Dare I say that this is not good news. Nor is our continuing dependence on Russian raw materials:


As for blocking Russian raw materials exports, “this threatens to cause breaks in supply chains for key materials, including cobalt, palladium, nickel, aluminum.”


And that leads us, once again, to the heart of the matter: “The long-term dream of the US new Cold Warriors is to break up Russia, or at least to restore its managerial kleptocracy seeking to cash in their privatizations in western stock markets.”


That’s not going to happen. Hudson clearly sees how “the most enormous unintended consequence of US foreign policy has been to drive Russia and China together, along with Iran, Central Asia and countries along the Belt and Road initiative.”


Then, Escobar makes another telling point, one that I have not seen elsewhere. If Russia is a pariah state, what would prevent it from its own confiscation-- of Western technology:


Arguably, the lethal weapon in Russia’s arsenal of responses has been identified by the head of the Center for Economic Research of the Institute of Globalization and Social Movements (IGSO), Vasily Koltashov: the key is to confiscate technology – as in Russia ceasing to recognize US rights to patents.


In what he qualifies as “liberating American intellectual property,” Koltashov calls for passing a Russian law on “friendly and unfriendly states. If a country turns out to be on the unfriendly list, then we can start copying its technologies in pharmaceuticals, industry, manufacturing, electronics, medicine. It can be anything – from simple details to chemical compositions.” This would require amendments to the Russian constitution.


Koltashov maintains that “one of the foundations of success of American industry was copying of foreign patents for inventions.” Now, Russia could use “China’s extensive know-how with its latest technological production processes for copying western products: the release of American intellectual property will cause damage to the United States to the amount of $10 trillion, only in the first stage. It will be a disaster for them.”


As it stands, the strategic stupidity of the EU beggars belief. China is ready to grab all Russian natural resources – with Europe left as a pitiful hostage of the oceans and of wild speculators. It looks like a total EU-Russia split is ahead – with little trade left and zero diplomacy.


Sorry for the length of this post, but the points made, by both French and Escobar, are well worth pondering. Or, as the old saying goes, don’t get cocky.


Tuesday, March 1, 2022

The Law of Unintended Consequences

Actions have consequences. Sometimes-- or better, most of the time-- they have unintended consequences. When a country makes policy, it ought in the best circumstances to consider all of the possible and even impossible consequences. It should avoid the therapy-driven error of imagining that policy should be designed to express one’s deepest personal feelings. 

One suspects that the Biden administration has been expressing its feelings by imposing sanctions on Russia. One suspects that it believes that it is on the side of the angels and therefore that things will work out well.


For now, they seem to be working out better than expected. But, the chances are good that the Russian bear will refuse to accept humiliation at the hands of Ukraine. Thus, sanctions or no sanctions, in Ukraine the worst is yet to come.


As for unintended consequences, especially as regards the removal of Russia from the SWIFT banking system, yesterday we quoted David Goldman, far savvier than yours truly, on the potential unintended consequences.


Today, we quote Jamie Dimon the CEO of JP Morgan Chase bank, and Financial Times columnist Rana Foroohar. The latter is notably liberal, but is far more intelligent than the idiot savant who fulfills a similar role at the New York Times.


First, Dimon, via Zero Hedge and Bloomberg News. For Dimon the issue is not about an unintended consequence, but about a spectacular backfire:


Just hours after western leaders slapped Russia with unprecedented sanctions the likes of which the world has never seen, including a targeted SWIFT expulsion of key Russia banks as well as an asset and transaction freeze of the Russia central bank, JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon explained not only why this harsh escalation may be futile but why it could backfire spectacularly in the years to come.


In an interview with Bloomberg TV, the CEO of the world's largest bank said that "there are a lot of workarounds for SWIFT, so there are different tools we use for different reasons" adding that “the banks are talking with the government so everyone understands the issues, not because they’re for or against any particular thing."


While SWIFT sanctions mean companies can’t use the messaging system to do business with the Russian entities affected, they can still do business with them, Dimon said. In fact it's as simple as sending an email with payment instructions, because what SWIFT really is, is a messaging remnant from a bygone era, before emails, even before the fax machine.  


Dimon also said that disconnecting Russian banks from the SWIFT messaging system may bring “unintended consequences” that include third parties finding ways around the penalty.


“What countries do you hurt? What people are going to do workarounds?” Dimon said, referring to "bad players" and others finding workarounds, not his own firm, according to a company spokesperson. Dimon said sanctions, by contrast, are “very targeted, very specific, very clean.”


As Bloomberg reported on Friday, JPMorgan was among Wall Street firms that had counseled Washington against kicking Russia off SWIFT, arguing that it could have far-reaching fallout that could hurt the global economy and undermine the purpose of the penalties.


And Foroohar, sounding like she is on the same page as the more conservative David Goldman, had this to say in her column yesterday:


The process of financial decoupling between Russia and the west has, of course, been going on for some time. Western banks reduced their exposure to Russian financial institutions by 80 per cent following the country’s annexation of Crimea in 2014, and their claims on the rest of Russia’s private sector have halved since then, according to a recent Capital Economics report. The new and more aggressive sanctions announced by the US will take that decoupling much further.


It will also make Russia much more dependent on China, which will use the US and EU sanctions as an opportunity to pick up excess Russian oil and gas on the cheap. China is no fan of Vladimir Putin’s war. But it needs Russian commodities and arms, and sees the country as a key part of a new Beijing-led order, something Moscow is aware of.


“China is our strategic cushion,” Sergei Karaganov, a political scientist at the Moscow-based Council on Foreign and Defense Policy, told Nikkei Asia recently. “We know that in any difficult situation, we can lean on it for military, political and economic support.”


That does not mean China would break US or European sanctions to support Russia, but it could certainly allow Russian banks and companies more access to its own financial markets and institutions. Indeed, just a few weeks ago, the two countries announced a “friendship without limits”, one that will certainly include closer financial ties as Russia is shut out of western markets. This follows a 2019 agreement between Russia and China to settle all trade in their respective currencies rather than in dollars. The war in Ukraine will speed this up. Witness, in the past few days, China lifting an import ban on Russian wheat, as well as a new long-term Chinese gas deal with Gazprom.


All of this supports China’s long-term goal of building a post-dollarised world, in which Russia would be one of many vassal states settling all transactions in renminbi. Getting there is not an easy process. The Chinese want to de-dollarise, but they also want complete control of their own financial system. That’s a difficult circle to square. One of the reasons that the dollar is the world’s reserve currency is that, in contrast, the US markets are so open and liquid.


But the Chinese are playing a long game. Finance is a key pillar in the new Great Power competition with America; currency, capital flows and the Belt and Road Initiative trade pathway will all play a role in that. Beijing is slowly diversifying its foreign exchange reserves, as well as buying up a lot of gold. This can be seen as a kind of hedge on a post-dollar world (the assumption being that gold will rise as the dollar falls).


While sanctions against Russia herald more decoupling, it is also possible that the economic fallout from the war (lowered demand, even higher inflation) would push America and other nations into succumbing to pricing pressures that would favour Chinese goods. While there is likely to be a lot of political posturing on both sides of the aisle about standing up to Russia and China, it takes a long time to decouple supply chains. Policymakers in Washington have yet to get really serious about it.


I refrain from offering too much commentary about matters in which I am not at all competent to offer any commentary at all.


And yet, when considering the chess game that is being played on the world stage, one does well to consider the possible outcomes and consequences. Just because we side with the Ukrainian people does not mean that our actions supporting them will not backfire spectacularly.