Friday, April 5, 2024

Why Are Young People Troubled?

You are surely aware of the latest and greatest theory explaining the emotional problems young people are suffering these days. Apparently, these problems are not limited to our shores. Children in Scandinavia, Jonathan Haidt has told us, are similarly suffering from increased depression and anxiety.

Apparently, this means that the problem is universal, though I find it difficult to accept that the world comprises the Anglosphere and Scandinavia.


For the record, Haidt has argued in various places that the fault lies with smartphones. Ever since children gained access to these miniaturized computers they have ceased interacting with other children, have withdrawn into the fortresses of their souls, and have shown increasing signs of mental illness.


I have on occasion suggested that I find these explanations too facile. There is more to life than gadgets and it is too convenient to say that we can blame the gadget. What about parental responsibility?


Nevertheless, less time on smartphones is surely a good thing. Discipline and control, imposed by parental authority, is surely a good and positive thing. Banning these gadgets from dinner tables is surely constructive.


So, is the problem the existence of smartphones or the inexistence of parental authority. One wonders whether the wildly reviled Tiger Mom would have allowed her daughters free and open access to smartphones. And, we understand that her children were growing up in the pre-smartphones era. 


This is to say that psycho sciences have determined the way we bring up children, and not necessarily for the better. So explained Abigail Shrier in her new book, Bad Therapy, and we can surely agree with her.


We have learned that the exercise of authority is a bad thing, and we are suffering the consequences. Try explaining that parents should ration their children’s access to these phones.


Now, consider an alternative explanation for the poor mental health of today’s adolescents.


Among the problems that the younger generation is suffering is this one-- bad table manners. Doubtless this is much less sexy than blaming it on a gadget, but if you want people to interact with each other, the dinner table is one place where they can learn how to do it. And they will not be able to do it if they have bad table manners.


We are all aware of the research showing that family dinners are an important factor in children’s emotional well being. But, family dinners require good table manners and disciplined coordination. If each individual at the dinner table is off in his own world or hooked into his own phone, no one will be connecting.


A British survey shows that most young people do not care about table manners. And yet, most of them are irritated by the lack of same.


The New York Post reports:


Over half of Gen Z diners don’t think table etiquette is relevant anymore, according to a survey by restaurant group Prezzo.


The survey found that 77% of Gen Z diners didn’t care if people put their elbows on the table and 60% couldn’t care less about how someone holds their silverware, Yahoo reported.


Table manners aren’t just disappearing among the younger crowd. The survey found that 32% of people of all ages never think about their table manners.


On the contrary, over half of the British diners asked said they are upset about the lack of table manners they observe around them. Meanwhile, 49% of people asked said they wouldn’t date someone who had bad table manners.


The survey showed that 48% of people were irked by loud chewing, 37% were annoyed when people used their food at the table and another 37% hated when people ate off others’ plates without asking.


More than half of survey participants also hated it when people talked with food in their mouths, were very loud or snapped their fingers at servers. 


Besides elbows, another appendage Gen Z can’t seem to keep off the table is cell phones as 38% of young adult diners admitted to using their devices during a meal. 


At the risk of being banal, different cultures have different table manners. If people are going to participate in such bonding rituals they need to use the same table manners. It’s like being a member of a team. You need to wear the uniform, conform to the grooming code, play by the rules and take turns.


We need to make one distinction here. It’s one thing to have different table manners, table manners that may pertain in a different culture. It’s quite another to have no table manners, that is to pretend that you are there to do something other than to share a meal.


And that means, no phones at the dinner table, or even at the lunch table.


Not only is having your phone at the table rude, it’s unhygienic. A study from the University of Michigan found that your phone is 10 times dirtier than a toilet seat.


Noƫl Wolf, the cultural expert at Babbel, agreed that phones at the table should be where people draw the line. We now live in a culture where people post pictures of their meals on Instagram but it should end at that, Wolf and Finney agreed.


“Despite the fact that many of us have openly admitted to using our mobile phone during a meal, it’s generally understood that their use at the table should be restricted,” Wolf told Yahoo.


“Taking a quick snapshot of your food before digging in is usually harmless, though sometimes fellow diners might find this annoying,” Wolf added.


But then, if different cultures have different table manners they will need to adopt a single set of manners if they want to have group dinners. They need to adopt the same customs and follow one set of rules. As Robert Putnam explained in his study, E Pluribus Unum, when we want people from different cultures to get along they need to adopt an encompassing monoculture.


This means, as I have previously suggested, that multiculturalism, the notion that all cultures are of equal value, militates against social cohesion. And, social disconnection fosters depression and anxiety.


Consider this. Assuming that Scandinavian teenagers are as likely as American teenagers to suffer from emotional distress, we can certainly remark that these countries have recently allowed large numbers of migrants into their country. Nations that had been culturally monolithic suddenly welcomed groups of people from Muslim countries, people who did not know the local language, did not follow the local customs and rejected the local manners.


Might this not have contributed to the breakdown in social cohesion and adolescent mental health?  Especially when the new migrants refused to assimilate. If  Haidt is correct to say that Scandinavian youth are suffering from poor mental health, it might have something to do with smartphones, but it might also have something to do with multiculturalism.


Surely, it is far more acceptable to say that the problem lies in a small gadget than it does in our lust for multicultural diversity.


Please subscribe to my Substack.

Thursday, April 4, 2024

Our New Philosopher Kings and Queens

Do we live in pre-revolutionary times?

You say you want a revolution? Hopefully, you have outgrown the adolescent fantasy of a socialist revolution that will overthrow capitalism and will produce even more starving millions.


No, not that revolution. How about a reprise of the French revolution, where the oppressed people rise up and overthrow a new American aristocracy, comprised of tech billionaires and their ex-wives. Like the ancien regime of pre-revolutionary France this group lives high, insists on having its way, and hands out crumbs to everyone else. 


Joel Kotkin astutely remarks that their antics, to say nothing of their efforts to direct public policy toward more woke goals is producing a reaction.


The situation is unstable, Kotkin might have said. People are beginning to see through the ruse. The new aristocrats may have limitless money, but they do not have limitless reputational capital. 


Note well. With a couple of conspicuous exceptions most of those who are funding these leftist projects did not earn what they have. They are either heirs to gargantuan fortunes or ex-wives of tech entrepreneurs. 


Obviously, they have no real interest in supporting merit as against equity.


Kotkin calls them cognitive elites. Their minds have been colonized by the new ideologies and they are happily purveying them. They have become our philosopher kings. They cannot compete in the marketplace and are vulnerable to the academic thinkers who are selling oppression narratives. Only, they have decided that they will counterbalance the work of the oppressors.


You see, strangely enough, the new philosopher kings believe that they speak for the downtrodden masses, even those who have been oppressed by their ex-husbands,


Given that they are not very bright, they do not want to hear any discouraging word about their so-called thought:


Virtually every ideology that’s undermining the West has its patrons in these ruling cognitive elites. This includes everything from the purveyors of critical race theory and Black Lives Matter to transgender activists and, perhaps most egregiously, campaigners for the climate jihad. 


They are like government officials. Since they are not motivated by the corrupting profit motive, they believe that they are more qualified to tell people how to live their lives:


In each case, these elite activists reject the market traditions of liberal capitalism and instead promote a form of social control, often with themselves in charge. The fact that these ideologies are destructive, and could ultimately undermine the status of these very elites, seems to matter little to them. That they also infuriate the middle and working classes doesn’t seem to register, either.


Kotkin explains that the most important philosopher kings include the ex-wives and heirs of people who accumulated obscene fortunes:


Not only do we have to deal with the beliefs of the oligarchs, but also those of their forsaken wives and their offspring. Jeff Bezos’ former spouse, MacKenzie Scott, worth an estimated $60 billion, has already given $133million to a group pushing for a ‘progressive’ takeover of education. Melinda Gates, the former wife of the Microsoft founder Bill Gates, worth at least $13 billion, is also backing woke causes.


Of course, these philosopher kings are enemies of meritocracy. Surely, MacKenzie Scott and Melinda Gates did not become obscenely rich by competing in the marketplace. Thus, they favor identity groups and the extortionate policies that want to reward people for reasons that have nothing to do with merit, and everything to do with other criteria, like race and/or gender.


The current cadre of elites seem uniquely hostile to meritocracy and individual rights – values that once stood at the heart of liberal, capitalist societies. Rather than promote upward mobility for the plebs, they want to divide them into ‘identity’ groups based on race, sexuality and gender. Black Lives Matter, the enforcers of critical race theory, for years enjoyed lavish support from top tech companies, including Microsoft, Cisco and TikTok. It also became a poster child for a host of nonprofits, like the Tides Foundation, which in turn gets much of its money from oligarchs and their descendants, including George Soros and the MacArthur, Hewlett, Ford, Packard and Rockefeller foundations.


And, of course, they are true believers in the apocalyptic prophecies about the end of the world. And they have wanted to institute a Green New Deal, the better to shut down energy production. And, of course, to save the tadpoles.


To a remarkable extent, the current ruling oligarchy in tech and on Wall Street have embraced the ideology of Net Zero, even though this threatens to undermine Western industrial power and raise the cost of living for the masses. Elite opinion, in general, is far more engaged on climate issues than the general population. In one recent poll, those living with graduate degrees in big dense cities and making over $150,000 a year are far more likely to favour such things as rationing meat and gas than the vast majority of Americans.


They worship the planet, as a pagan goddess.


The ultra-rich have been particularly drawn to draconian climate positions. Leading billionaires like Tom Steyer have collectively sent hundreds of millions to leading environmental groups. The Rockefellers, heirs to the Standard Oil fortune, have become some of the fiercest advocates of radical climate policies. They even favour punishing corporations that make money from fossil fuels like their own forebears once did.


Fortunes made in the energy business are being squandered to shut down energy production and necessarily to immiserate the rest of the population.


Indeed, green lobbyists outspend so-called Big Oil by more than four to one. The recent drives to ban new natural gas stoves and liquefied natural gas (LNG) come directly from these billionaire-funded campaign groups.


Those same elites who demand climate austerity for the many are widely known to enjoy the use of private jets, build $500 million yachts and own numerous, often enormous mansions. The fact that the most recent climate confab, COP28, had a session on ‘responsible yachting’ tells people all they need to know about the hypocrisy of the super-rich.


You are doubtless aware that European farmers have been in open rebellion against policies that will put them out of business:


The damage being done by the oligarchs’ green agenda is now fuelling a rebellion from the beleaguered European, British and American middle and working classes. Many are becoming increasingly sceptical of elite environmentalism, just as they have been consistently hostile to woke ideas on law enforcement, transgender issues and racial quotas.


The public is catching on, but the philosopher kings have barely noticed. Kotkin explains:


So far, the elites seem barely aware of this discontent. This may stem from the fact that the oligarchs and their minions live in a very different reality from most people. They are shielded from the consequences of the policies they promote, whether from the job losses brought about by eco-austerity, or the rising crime and disorder resulting from efforts to ‘defund the police’ and the refusal to penalise street crime. They live in closeted, gentrified urban neighbourhoods, elite leafy suburbs or country retreats.


Kotkin compares these self-appointed philosopher kings to the French aristocrats before the 1789 revolution.


Like French aristocrats before the revolution, the oligarchs talk largely among themselves. They seem unaware that they may be financing fashionable causes that may threaten ‘their own rights and even their existence’, as Alexis de Tocqueville said of the Ancien RĆ©gime. In pre-revolutionary times, French aristocrats and top clerics preached Christian charity and celebrated the rights of man while indulging in gluttony, sexual adventurism and lavish spending, as well as exercising their historic privileges. Just like the revolutionaries of 1789, many in today’s third estate are disgusted by the hauteur and hypocrisy of the upper classes.


Of course, social programs, handouts and the rest, are the modern form of charity. The pseudo-aristocratic philosopher kings believe that they have the right feelings toward the less fortunate, and are more than happy to hand out occasional goodies.


Ultimately, this rebellion, launched from the left or right, or both simultaneously, represents a direct threat to our insane ruling class. Even those elites who are worried about the financial distress facing the masses have only the most patronising solutions to offer. Meta founder Mark Zuckerberg, Tesla CEO Elon Musk, former head of Uber Travis Kalanick and AI guru Sam Altman have all spoken in favour of an expanded welfare state and direct cash payments for the proles, under the guise of a ‘universal basic income’.


For all their faults, the elites of industrial-era Britain and America at least provided opportunities for the middle and especially the working class. They helped create powerful economies that, ultimately, and with some political cajoling, produced unprecedented mass affluence. In contrast, today’s oligarchs and their ‘expert class’ allies offer nothing more than subsidies and handouts – or what Karl Marx referred to as ‘the proletarian alms-bag’.


These philosopher kings believe that the public loves them. In truth, the public despises them. After all, they have dedicated their lives to depriving others of the opportunities that they are profiting from.


Is Kotkin becoming a Republican?


Please subscribe to my Substack.


Wednesday, April 3, 2024

Wednesday Potpourri

First, the scandal du jour involves the Transgender Day of Visibility. Apparently, this made-up holiday always falls on March 31-- why not the ides of March, you will be thinking-- and this year March 31 was Easter Sunday, the holiest day in the Christian calendar.

So, the Biden administration issued a proclamation, in the name of POTUS himself. When he was criticized by Republicans like House Speaker Mike Johnson, Biden denied the facts. He claimed not to have said that.


One suspects that tired old Joe did not know that the proclamation had been issued in his name. He is too senile to pay very close attention to the workings of the White House.


We also learn that 38% of Americans believe that if Joe Biden is elected in 2024 he will not live out his term. A vote for Biden is thus a vote for Kamala Harris. Yikes.


Second, while Biden has done everything in his power to desacralize Easter, he was all-in with prayers for Ramadan. 


Third, it looks like the era of DEI is winding down. Corporations are becoming more skeptical of diversity initiatives and are downplaying their commitment to it.


Axios reported:


Diversity, equity and inclusion, or DEI, was the hot thing in corporate America a few years ago. Now: not so much.


Why it matters: The business community, long averse to political risks or controversies, backed away from DEI programs over the past two years in the wake of widespread attacks from lawmakers, high-profile rich guys and conservative activists like former Trump aide Stephen Miller.


The big picture: Companies that never cared much about DEI, or that fear lawsuits over programs, are using the moment to back away. Others are sticking with these efforts but doing it quietly.


Between the lines: Some business leaders are increasingly reluctant to speak publicly about the subject, but behind the scenes they're fed up with DEI, Johnny Taylor, president of the Society for Human Resource Management said in a January interview with Axios.


Fourth, at the Powerline blog John Hinderaker takes the measure of national attitudes toward DEI:


Woke capitalism is one of the strange phenomena of our era. I understand why government agencies might go in for DEI (Didn’t Earn It), since government at all levels is mostly in the hands of liberals and government employees, by their nature, are inclined to social engineering. But why corporations should sign up en masse for this left-wing nonsense is beyond me.


It is beyond most Americans, too. Rasmussen asked more than 1,200 Americans whether they are familiar with DEI and whether they think it has a positive or negative impact on companies. The linked article’s text is a little garbled, but this is what the pollster found:

Sixty-four percent (64%) of those surveyed are familiar with DEI….


So quite a few people, around a third, said they were not “familiar…with diversity, equity and inclusion policies, usually abbreviated as DEI.” Of those who are aware of DEI, a plurality think it has a harmful effect:


[J]ust 25% of American Adults think diversity, equity, and inclusion programs make companies better…while 34% think DEI is making companies worse. Twenty-five percent (25% say) DEI programs don’t make much difference and 16% are not sure.

Those who say they are very familiar with DEI are most negative toward it, perhaps because of personal experience:

Among Americans who are Very Familiar with DEI, 51% say such policies are making companies worse.


Rasmussen asked separately whether respondents think DEI programs make companies’ products or services, in the form of entertainment, better or worse. The results were similar:


37% of Americans believe diversity, equity and inclusion programs are making products and entertainment worse, while 22% think DEI is making them better.


Fifth, the student government of Harvard Law School passed a resolution accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza.


To which Larry Summers responded by suggesting that these students are damaging their reputations and making all graduates of Harvard Law School less desirable as hires.

Sixth, now that the Harvard law students have embraced Hamas propaganda, the Times of Israel reports that Hamas is collapsing, thanks to the Israeli military efforts. This, via Israeli defense minister Gallant:


“In the last week or two, hundreds of terrorists have been captured and what they say about what happened to them tells the whole story. They say that Hamas is collapsing from within, the price they are paying is very heavy,” Gallant said following an assessment at the 98th Division’s headquarters.


“We’re going to eliminate everyone who was involved in the events of October 7, the junior [officials], the senior ones and the very senior ones; those who were inside [Israel] or who gave instructions,” he said, referring to the date of Palestinian terror group Hamas’s massive attack on Israel that started the ongoing war.


Seventh, in the meantime, anti-Semitism is alive and well in America. Katya Sedgwick reports a scene from a synagogue in New Jersey:


Something significant is happening here: a large group of Arabs and allies showed up at a synagogue in New Jersey chanting “we don’t want Israelis here”. It’s a turning point — an entrenched authentic minority American group is being chased out by new arrivals, all with implicit approval of American institutions.


Not a word about this from the Biden administration. Tell me you are not surprised.


Eighth, while the Biden administration, along with Chuck Schumer and Tommy Friedman, believes that the Palestinian Authority ought to be a partner for peace, the following incident occurred in Jerusalem. Reported by Daniel Greenfield:


Earlier this month, Muhammad Manasra, who is affiliated with Fatah, the ruling PLO group behind the Palestinian Authority, and had graduated from the Egyptian Police College, who had served as a Palestinian police officer, at a rank equivalent to major, opened fire at an Israeli gas station, killing a medic, before being taken out by the owner of a Humus restaurant.

Now it happened again, and this time the target was a school bus.


Ninth, on a lighter note, from the Twitter account of Libs of TikTok:


Trans people are the most brave, courageous and resilient people on earth and also their happiness is dependent on you gendering them correctly and if you misgender them they might commit suicide.


Tenth, don’t get sick in America. The following, from Roger Cohen on TomKlingenstein.com. Corporate America is waking up to the failures of DEI, but the medical profession has not gotten there yet:


The medical profession’s leaders, almost without exception or dissent, now vigorously enforce this new orthodoxy of anti-racism. Most notably, they have designed and implemented a new version of medical education explicitly grounded in ideology rather than scientific excellence. In pursuit of this project, the president of the AAMC (which accredits U.S. medical schools) and the chair of the AAMC’s Council of [Medical School] Deans stated publicly in July 2022: “We believe this topic [Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion] deserves just as much attention from learners and educators at every stage of their careers as the latest scientific breakthroughs.”


The AAMC’s DEI Competencies, issued in October 2021, details the new required social justice skills that medical students must acquire. In addition, the AAMC has discouraged the use of the rigorous Medical College Admissions Test (MCAT) as a filter to help select medical students. Dozens of the 158 allopathic (MD granting) U.S. medical schools have made the MCAT optional. Several medical schools, including the prestigious University of Pennsylvania, have programs to admit students from designated “underrepresented” identity groups without requiring the submission of MCAT scores at all. The MCAT itself has been revised to include social justice questions that are easy to ace because the answers are always the same: structural racism is the cause of any group disparities that disfavor underrepresented groups. But even this re-engineered test shows persistent group disparities in test scores, which means that Asian applicants must score almost 4 times higher than black applicants to have an equal chance of admission.


Tenth, in America’s new idiotocracy, the name of Judith Butler has a special place, designating the most profound stupidity. Consider this sentence, taken from Butler’s writings:


The move from a structuralist account in which capital is understood to structure social relations in relatively homologous ways to a view of hegemony in which power relations are subject to repetition, convergence, and rearticulation brought the question of temporality into the thinking of structure, and marked a shift from a form of Althusserian theory that takes structural totalities as theoretical objects to one in which the insights into the contingent possibility of structure inaugurate a renewed conception of hegemony as bound up with the contingent sites and strategies of the rearticulation of power.


I did not make that up. I did not find it in the Babylon Bee.


If you are a college student and you are assigned Butler’s writings, drop the course. If you cannot drop the course, then ask for a tuition refund.


Eleventh, you will be happy to learn that J. K. Rowling will not be prosecuted under the ridiculous new Scottish anti-biology law.


Some people are too important to prosecute.


The Daily Mail reports:


As the 58-year-old [Rowling]'s comments whipped up a social media storm, she won support from Prime Minister Rishi Sunak who said: 'People should not be criminalised for stating simple facts on biology.'


A Police Scotland spokesperson said of the tweets: 'We have received complaints in relation to the social media post. The comments are not assessed to be criminal and no further action will be taken.”


Rowling said of the police response: 'I hope every woman in Scotland who wishes to speak up for the reality and importance of biological sex will be reassured by this announcement, and I trust that all women - irrespective of profile or financial means - will be treated equally under the law.' 


She added, in full defiance mode:


If they go after any woman for simply calling a man a man, I'll repeat that woman's words and they can charge us both at once.


Please subscribe to my Substack.


Tuesday, April 2, 2024

Human Sacrifice Today

“First, do no harm.” So begins the Hippocratic oath, the moral foundation of medical practice in the Western world. 

And yet, beyond the obvious obscenity of the physicians and paramedical professionals who are inducing, enticing and seducing children into being sexually mutilated, we also have the phenomenon of assisted suicide.


To be clear about it, the great minds of European medicine have embraced assisted suicide, not just for nonagenarians who are suffering from terminal cancer, but for perfectly healthy, but depressed young people,


Consider the case of Zoraya ter Beek, reported by Rupa Subramanya in The Free Press. Read this description and tell me what strikes you about her reason to commit suicide, at age 28:


[Zoraya] Ter Beek, who lives in a little Dutch town near the German border, once had ambitions to become a psychiatrist, but she was never able to muster the will to finish school or start a career. She said she was hobbled by her depression and autism and borderline personality disorder. Now she was tired of living—despite, she said, being in love with her boyfriend, a 40-year-old IT programmer, and living in a nice house with their two cats. 


She recalled her psychiatrist telling her that they had tried everything, that “there’s nothing more we can do for you. It’s never gonna get any better.” 


At that point, she said, she decided to die. “I was always very clear that if it doesn’t get better, I can’t do this anymore.”


We are not dealing with assisted suicide. We are dealing with induced suicide. She trusts her physician and her physician tells her that she will never get better. He is counseling suicide.


How does he know? How does he know what medical science will or will not discover tomorrow or next month? Whatever gave him the notion that science does not advance, does not discover new treatments.


It reminds one of the climate change activists who claim that they possess scientific knowledge about the future, even the future a century from now.


One must keep in mind an old notion from Wittgenstein, namely that there is no such thing as a scientific fact about tomorrow. The only proper use of the word “never” in this context is that a physician should never give up on a human being.


But, if we are not dealing with science, what are we dealing with? Why not call this for what it is, a modernized form of human sacrifice, an adjunct to the pagan practice of mutilating children in the name of what is called gender equity? Physicians have now forgotten science and have engaged in pagan religious rites.


Now that assisted suicide has become something of a treatment of choice for intractable depression, we can ask how Western cultures have managed to blind themselves to the obvious.


That is, in our neo-paganism we are concerned about feeding the goddess. Apparently, the voracious goddess requires a diet of young people. So, our medical professionals have stepped forth and tried to keep the goddess fed. By the terms of the pagan mythology, a well-fed goddess will protect us, or at least will leave us alone.


Also, for people who inhabit a world of pagan mythology, it is easier to contribute to society’s well-being by offing themselves. It is surely easier than working to produce a good life, for yourself and for others. It is an altruistic act, one that does not require very much effort.


The movement toward assisted suicide has led to an increase in the number of suicides. It has glamorized and glorified suicide:


From 2018 to 2021, countries where euthanasia or assisted suicide is most popular saw sizable increases in the number of people signing up to die: In the United States, where ten states and the District of Columbia have physician-assisted suicide, there was a 53 percent jump; in Canada, 125 percent.


One group in the Netherlands has been trying to make it easier for people to commit assisted suicide. It does not seem to trust the medical profession and wants to allow people to off themselves if they feel like it:


The Dutch group Coƶperatie Laatste Wil or Last Wish Cooperative (CLW) is at the cutting edge of the movement. It is pushing for even cheaper, easier to access assisted suicide. One day, if CLW has its way, everyone will have suicide kits—including sodium azide pills, painkillers, anti-nausea tablets, and sleep aids—in their medicine cabinets. The kits will be readily available at the local pharmacy, grocery store, or on Amazon. (To ensure toddlers can’t pop sodium azide, each kit will come with a fingerprint-identification lock.)


But for now, CLW is fighting to de-medicalize assisted suicide—allowing anyone to end their life without the help of a doctor. In late 2022, CLW filed a lawsuit against the Dutch government arguing that its regulation of assisted suicide violates the European Convention of Human Rights. The suit is ongoing, with 80 percent of Dutch people voicing support for the bill in a poll last October.


So, the Dutch do not trust their medical professionals. Like good pagans, they want to allow anyone, for whatever reason, to engage this form of self-sacrifice, the better to improve living conditions by feeding the goddess.


Please subscribe to my Substack.

Monday, April 1, 2024

Do We Need Freud?

I am not an aficionado of the thought of Toronto psychologist Paul Bloom. I was made aware of it in the past through his book, Against Empathy. I have maintained considerable respect for anyone who is willing to challenge the current mania about empathy. 

Empathy is not a panacea. Given that the best way to enhance your capacity for empathy is to get pregnant-- no kidding-- the feeling seems to have real value when dealing with infants. If you use empathy in your standard therapy practice you will be infantilizing people, which is not a good idea when dealing with adults.


Anyway, Bloom offered a rather strange and wrong-headed view of Freud in a radio interview, on station KCRW.


Astonishingly, Bloom seems to want to raise Freud from the dead. As you know and as Bloom knows, Freud’s reputation has been seriously undermined. His theories have largely been debunked as pseudo-science, and the treatments conducted according to his ideas have consistently been ineffective.


And, of course, Freudian institutions have come to function as cults. Take it from someone who spent time in the bosom of one of them.


“To some extent, modern psychologists see him as if we're sort of a pharmaceutical company that got its start by selling meth,” Bloom explains “Freud is an embarrassment, with his florid claims about penis envy and the Oedipal complex, his bizarre personal interactions, [and] his cult-like following, and now we're a science, so we want none of him.”


And yet, the Oedipus complex is not a trivial excrescence. It is the essence of Freudian theory. The Viennese neurologist was selling a narrative, a mythos, a story that pretended to explain human behavior and the human mind.


Most people now see Freud as useless; Bloom sees glimmers of truth.


Bloom explains that “we get some glimmers of truth in Freud” as he had “the view that we live a life at war with ourselves, where we have all of these psychological systems designed to keep forbidding stuff from rising into consciousness.” 


He was assuming that the mind is merely designed to trick us into thinking too much of ourselves. Doesn’t your mind have better things to do with its time?


And then, Bloom trots out a shopworn argument, namely that we are led around by our feelings and emotions, and do not act rationally. As it happens, Freud did not argue that we are led around by our passions; he argued that we are influenced by our desires.


And yet, didn’t Aristotle suggest that, our passions and desires notwithstanding, we are capable, as rational beings, of suspending our biases and making an intelligent decision. If Freud were right, the world would be a rather chaotic place. Nothing would ever get done.


Freud recognized that “we're not rational computers making our way through the world by making the best decisions in our own interest. Rather, there's this inner turmoil, a lot of which goes beneath the surface.”  At the time, Freud’s claim that “we don't know why we feel what we feel” was considered radical and shocking. 


Truth be told, the psycho field has been chock full of therapists who want us to feel our feelings and to know why we feel what we feel. They are not really Freudians. It has far too few practitioners who want us to do what we ought to be doing to be honorable citizens.


Having warped Freud beyond recognition, Bloom introduces an unfortunate caricature of B. F. Skinner, the founder of behaviorism. He slanders Skinner and ignores the therapies that have derived from his theories.


Skinner was the founder of “behaviorism” and  saw humans as “just rats in a more complicated environment.” Bloom explains Skinner’s view that “there’s no coherent sense of talking about the complexity of the mind, because there is no mind.” Skinner’s theories that “the same psychological processes that could explain the behavior of rats and pigeons could explain the behavior of humans,” ultimately turned out to be a disaster, but very much like Freud, Skinner demonstrated “enthusiasm” and “willingness to take an idea and push for it.”


If you are happy to traffic in metaphysical entities, you can whine about the mind. And yet, aside from Skinner, we can also read the works of one Gilbert Ryle, especially his book, The Concept of Mind, to find these ideas explained, without even worrying about rats.


Obviously, Bloom’s is a gratuitous slander, one that ignores the successful treatments that have been offered by behavioral and cognitive psychologists. These psychologists do not see behaviors, normal and pathological, as expressions of mental processes, but more as bad habits. In truth, this notion comes to us from Aristotle, who did not believe that human beings were all rats.


So, the minds of the psycho profession have been marinating in Freudian theory for more than a century. The result is not encouraging:


What surprises Bloom the most is how “stagnant” advances in psychology have been over the last 30 years. Not much has changed with regards to treatment for even severe conditions like schizophrenia, he notes. “We don't know what to do about it, we can't cure it,” Bloom says. “You would have thought that we would have made more progress, but we haven't.” 


So, therapy has been stagnant. Aside from cognitive and behavioral approaches, psychologists have little to offer schizophrenics. It might be useful to consider that schizophrenia is not a psychological condition, but is a neurological condition, one that responds fairly well to some medications. 


I am surprised that Bloom does not refer to the advances in psychopharmacology, especially those that have largely improved the treatment of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.


Please subscribe to my Substack.