Wednesday, November 18, 2009

The Rudeness of Strangers

Rudeness is busting out all over. I am not thinking of your rude friends who cancel appointments at the last minute or do not return your emails. Here I want to focus on the way many of us feel assaulted and assailed by strangers acting rudely.

I suspect that this is most prevalent in large cities where people feel that they are shielded by the cloak of anonymity. When you do not feel like an identifiable member of a community, you do not care whether your behavior irritates other people. Yet,if anyone does interfere with your embarrassing breach of public decorum, you are likely to react with hostility.

We Americans may not be very good at being polite, but we excel at taking offense.

You are patiently waiting to place your order for a Vente Latte at Starbucks and the guy standing next to you is shouting into his cell phone. It doesn't matter whether he is barking at his secretary, fighting with his wife, or arguing about the World Series. You just want him to shut the blank up. He is violating your peace of mind, and preventing you from meditating or ruminating.

And you do not know what to do about it. You are too polite to fling a glass of water at his cell phone, but you are feeling that this man deserves some serious punishment.

You can blame it on technology. Without the vast array of telephonic gadgets that saturate our world, a lot of this rudeness would not be happening. But you do not want to be a total Luddite. You start wondering why there isn't an app for loutish behavior.

Of else, you can blame it on the culture. People have become convinced that they have an inalienable right to free and open self-expression. If you dare criticize the creative genius that is being displayed to a store-full of Starbucks customers you will be treated as though you were undermining his mental health.

Thanks to the therapy culture, when we interrupt someone who is egregiously violating our privacy we are immediately attacked for violating his privacy.

It's a great world, isn't it.

The question remains: how should you deal with the rudeness of strangers?

According to Amy Alkon's book, "I See Rude People: One Woman's Battle to Beat Some Manners into Impolite Society," the best approach is to answer rudeness with rudeness. As New York Times writer Douglas Quenqua so aptly put it, Alkon seems to believe that "two rudes make a polite." Link here.

Alkon recommends that you fight back, that you out-rude the person who is offending you. Teach the boor a lesson, get in his face, call him out on his rudeness.

It may or may not stop him from being rude, but revenge is sweet, and, aside from creating a potentially dangerous scene, you would gain the satisfaction of making him pay, of getting revenge.

Alkon seems to believe that this tactic involves shaming. Actually, it involves guilt and punishment, and feels more like vigilante justice than shaming.

Surely, shaming is a good idea, and people are often shamed into improving their manners and decorum. But the notion that you can guilt-trip someone into better manners is shortsighted.

I was first made aware of Alkon's book on Dr. Helen Smith's blog. Among the interesting remarks offered by her commenters one stood out: Alkon's approach might work for her because she is a woman. If you are a man and you try to get in another man's face over bad behavior in the subway, you will risk more than an unpleasant verbal rejoinder.

On these issues I am happy to propose shaming as a good solution to this problem. In so doing I place myself on the side of the etiquette mavens Quenqua consulted for his article.

They insist that confrontation is not the way to go. They prefer, as I do, "withering glances and artfully worded comments."

Miss Manners believes that answering rudeness with rudeness simply increases the amount of rudeness in the world. You cannot shame someone into adopting good manners if your own manners have descended to his level.

But unless you are feeling especially saintly, the opposite tactic, turning the other cheek, is not a solution either. It might make you feel like a patsy.

So, how do you find a middle ground between lowering yourself to the same level as the rude stranger and allowing your sensibility to be assaulted with impunity?

The answer must involve offering a response that allows the other person to become aware of his own obnoxious behavior without behaving badly yourself.

The only way to do this is to avoid the tendency to punish the person, but to try out more polite and old-fashioned ways of shaming. At the least, they are polite and set a good example.

AS the etiquette mavens say, it is difficult to promote good behavior when you are behaving badly.

Begin with the withering gaze. Staring at someone who is misbehaving is a not-so-subtle reminder that he should take cognizance of the existence of other people and their feelings. Shaming does not involve getting revenge; its purpose is to allow the rude stranger to become aware of how he looks to others. If he has forgotten himself, your gaze should act as a gentle reminder.

I also favor artfully-worded comments. Again, they should allow the rude stranger to become aware of how he looks to others. Among the more common examples are: "Get a room;" "Would you mind speaking a little louder; I missed the last sentence;" "Perhaps you would feel more comfortable if you discussed it outside;" "Where is my iPod now that I really need it."

All of these are polite and pointed. If the rude stranger does not respond, it is probably best to let the matter drop.

In other circumstances it is usually best to walk away. If you are sitting in a restaurant and the couple next to you has very bad table manners, you can ask the waiter to change your table. You need not address the offending couple.

But if you are riding the New York subway system and someone is playing music loudly, it is probably a bad idea to intervene. At best, you can change cars at the next stop. At worst, grin and bear it. Unless you are stronger and armed, you should not to try to shame someone who is acting obnoxiously on a subway car.

One other alternative might be to inquire about the music. Then, the offending person would have to turn it down to answer your question.

As it happened, I was once seated on an airplane next to someone who was drinking too much and giving every appearance of being ready to keep drinking and becoming more obnoxious.

Clearly, I could not say anything about his drinking. So I tried to start up a conversation. We were flying from Paris, so I asked how he had liked Paris. Perhaps he was simply anxious about flying across the ocean, but we had a good conversation, after which he simply fell asleep.

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Obama in Japan: The Face You Save Is Not Just Your Own

Obama's spinmeisters have been out in force trying to explain away the president's embarrassing gesture of bowing to the Emperor of Japan.

David Axelrod outdid himself by suggesting that it was a sign of strength. Thereby, Axelrod established himself as a master of Orwellian doublethink. Perhaps he spent so much time pondering the apothegms of critical theory that he came to believe that reality is what you say it is. More rational individuals know that calling weakness strength does not make it strength.

I hope that Axelrod and Obama's other apologists know it too.

ABC's Jake Tapper did the best job of cutting through the spin. He was one of the few who had the good sense to solicit the opinion of an expert on Japanese customs, one who was an Obama supporter. Link here.

Most intriguingly, the expert pointed out that the Japanese press did not run the picture of Obama bowing to the Emperor. It chose a more decorous picture of our president tipping his head slightly toward the Empress.

In the expert's words: "Kyodo News is running his appropriate and reciprocated nod and shake with the Empress, certainly to show the president as dignified, and not in the form of a first-year English teacher trying to impress with Karate-Kid level of knowledge of Japanese customs."

He continued: "The bow he performed did not just display weakness in Red State terms, but evoked weakness in Japanese terms.... The last thing the Japanese want or need is a weak-looking American president, and, again, in all ways, he unintentionally played that part."

The moral of the story is clear: the face you save is not just your own. In fact, in Asian cultures it is not even primarily your own.

This is not limited to Asia. When a guest comes to visit and trips on the rug, don't you say something about how the rug needs to be replaced. If you are wearing a tie and jacket and your guest comes to dinner in a sports shirt, you will most likely change into a sports shirt.

In these situations your duty is to cover up for your guest, to save his face.

Most often, of course, we think of face saving in individual terms. Saving face requires us to act with dignity and decorum, to create and maintain a good reputation, and to defend ourselves against attacks on our self-respect.

Yet, this duty to save our own face does not prevent us or preclude us from saving the face of others.

This despite the tender and misleading ministrations of our therapy culture. That culture has fostered the idea that good communication involves expressing yourself freely without regard for the feelings of others.

I have stated my own opinion that following this advice will turn your life into permanent psychodrama. Caveat emptor.

It is equally mistaken to imagine that you are saving someone's face by covering him with flattery. Sycophants are not saving face; they are bedazzling and confusing you, the better to pick your pocket.

Nor is communication a gotcha game where you revel in the mishaps and embarrassments of others. Unfortunately, our press tends, when it finds someone it dislikes making a mistake, to repeat the incident over and over again, to the point where you cannot think of the person without thinking of the gaffe.

When then-Vice President Dan Quayle misspelled the word-- potato-- in a photo-op, the press mercilessly ran the clip over and over again.

Returning to the normal human conversation and communication, I would say that when a friend has inadvertently made a faux-pas or a gaffe or has revealed too much that had best remained private, your role is to cover up for him, to save his face. For that he will owe you gratitude.

Friends protect friends from themselves. Not by criticizing, not by attacking, not by gossiping about it all, but by looking away.

When you do so, you are refusing to accept that the embarrassing gesture is meaningful or relevant. You consider that the person was stressed, that everyone else does the same thing, or that it is your own fault.

When athletes win a match, something that always involves some level of embarrassment for the losing team, they walk over to the losers and shake hands. Even though the team lost its members are still honorable and worthy competitors.

I would note that this approach is exactly what Freud precluded when he declared that slips of the tongue and other everyday mistakes were meaningful expressions of repressed unconscious motives.

It is not an accident that Freud invented the supine couch-ridden posture for his patients. He said that he could not stand being looked in the eye, but it is also true that he never showed them any real respect. The industry of psychoanalysis was built on Freud's failure to give his patients any face.

The inverse of the Freudian position involves undeserved flattery. Instead of turning away from an embarrassing gesture by averting your gaze, you stare at it with googoo eyes and pronounce it to be a sign of great creativity or genius, or both.




Monday, November 16, 2009

The Trial of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed

A great deal has been written about Attorney General Holder's decision to try Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and the other 9/11 conspirators in Federal Court in New York. Most observers, myself included, are appalled and horrified by the decision.

Be that as it may, the most intelligent analysis of the situation comes to us from George Friedman at Stratfor.com. Link here.

You may or may not know about Friedman or Stratfor, but, if so, you are in for a treat. In the midst of the general hubbub and furor surrounding the decision, it is worthwhile to read through a thoughtful and dispassionate analysis.

The Leadership Deficit in American Business

Much of what I and others say about leadership seems intuitively obvious. If you manage a company or department you will likely dismiss it as beneath your pay grade. If you do not, you might not understand why people who traffic in platitudes can command such high consulting fees.

Now, John Baldoni reports that McKinsey has done a survey of corporate managers to assess their attitudes toward leadership.Link here.

Before reading this I would have assumed that managers know that they should inspire, motivate, and provide direction to those who report to them. I would have been wrong. According to McKinsey only a minority of managers knows this.

Corporate America has been suffering through a severe crisis. Yet, only 46% of managers believe that they should be providing direction during a crisis. And only 48% believe that they should inspire their staffs.

On other scores the results are less encouraging. A mere 30% of managers believe that their job involves motivating their staff, and only 23% saw that they needed to be more accountable. As for innovation in a crisis, only 33% saw it as part of their job description.

After looking at these numbers Baldoni draws the only sensible conclusion: "If a majority of managers do not believe that inspiration and direction are necessary for corporate performance, and that motivation and accountability are not essential, then our companies are in far worse shape than imagined."

The real question, however, is: What went wrong?

When it comes to inspiration, Baldoni notes that most managers do not understand what it means to inspire their staff. They assume that inspiring equals charismatic and that being it requires soaring rhetoric and Churchillian pep talks.

I sympathize with the managers here. Their failure to understand what inspiration involves can easily be traced back to the management gurus who do not know how to define their concepts.

Apparently, inspiration also means setting a good example. A manager inspires others by showing himself to be organized and motivated, engaged in his work, efficient and effective.

None of this is really about inspiration. And our normal understanding of the term would not include activities like mentoring, coaching, and showing people how to the best job. Yet, Baldoni suggests that management consultants have thrown these important qualities under the category of inspiration.

The ability to set corporate direction ought not to be subject to the same level of misunderstanding. As I have mentioned on this blog, a good corporate manager must define the mission, articulate policy and strategy, and ensure that everyone is working toward the same goal.

Apparently, managers too often believe that these qualities are restricted to the highest executive levels. Yet, if a lower level manager does not demonstrate some skill in setting a direction for his work group, he is unlikely ever to advance to those higher levels.

Leadership involves defining everyone's role and ensuring that each person knows how he or she is supposed to relate to others. Staff members need to know what their job is; what their responsibilities are; when and how they will be held accountable; and how their job fits into the larger corporate structure.

All good managers do this, and do it well.

We can speculate about the reasons why a majority of managers do not know or do not practice these leadership skills. I suspect that the culture at large, and the therapy culture in particular, bears some responsibility for this failure. After all, business does not exist in a vacuum. Today's staff was educated and trained by the school system and the media long before they arrive at corporate headquarters.

Our therapy culture allows each person to be an autonomous individual and insists that everyone's likes and dislikes be respected equally. You cannot run a team if everyone's opinion is taken to be equally valid. You cannot exercise leadership when no one has ever learned the art of followership.

Nor can you run a team if there are no accepted standards. A school system that tells students that there are no right or wrong answers, that creativity counts more than strict instruction, is not preparing them to work within a corporate group.

We also live in a culture where people are taught, sometimes explicitly, to disrespect authority. We are told, through schools and the media, that following someone's lead and doing what you are supposed to do are bad for your mental health.

Having had to deal with the products of this acculturation many managers may simply have given up on exercising leadership. How can you lead people who have been trained to believe that the only authority worth following is the authority of their personal feelings.


Sunday, November 15, 2009

Coaching Lessons: How Do You Perform Best?

Impressively, Peter Drucker's writings possess great clarity of thought and expression. If you, as I, are looking for a theorist who can help us formulate a high concept for coaching, then Drucker is a good place to start. As I mentioned in a previous post, his concept of self-management fits coaching well. Link here.

In that post I discussed Drucker's idea that the first step in the self-management process is to identify what you are good at. It is better and easier to develop the talents and aptitudes you have than to work on areas where you begin with a deficiency or handicap.

As he put it, memorably, it is easier to go from good to great than from incompetent to mediocre. And why would you want to spend you time trying to develop a talent that will, at best, only rise to the level of mediocrity? Link here.

Drucker continues that the second step in a good self-management program involves figuring out how you perform optimally.

Different people have different aptitudes and skills. Similarly, different people function better under different circumstances.
Surely, society values some roles more than others, but it is not a great idea to try to make yourself into a great leader when your talent lies in giving advice.

As for the question of whether leaders are born or made, I offer my opinion that they are born and developed. If you do not have the right temperament or personality, you are not going to be able to perform optimally as a leader. As I believe most people know from observation, children are born with their personalities. You cannot create a child's personality out of nothing and should not try to thwart its development.

Some people work best in circumstances that would easily defeat others.

Drucker's approach is multivalent. He does not suggest that everyone should try to be a leader or a subordinate. He sees that society has many different roles that allow different people to perform at levels that are optimal for them.

Not every aspect of society is organized in this way. Noting that Winston Churchill had a terrible time of it in school, Drucker observes: "Schools everywhere are organized on the assumption that there is only one right way to learn, and that it is the same for everyone. But to be forced to learn the way a school teaches is hell for students who learn differently."

Drucker suggests that some people learn by reading, some by writing, some by listening, and still others by talking things out.

Some people are voracious readers; they absorb enormous amounts of information by reading reports. Warren Buffett is a notoriously avid reader of annual reports.

Others learn by writing things down. In fact, they spend an enormous time taking notes. They fill piles of notebooks with random and not-so-random jottings. They might never go back to look at these notes once they have finished writing, but they will have learned the material nonetheless. Drucker suggests that Beethoven fell into this category.

Some people learn best by listening to other people. They sift through opinions and information that is provided orally and they come to master it completely. Give them a report to read and they will learn less efficiently and effectively.

Finally, some learn best by talking things out, almost in a monologue, with people they use as sounding boards or scribes. As they are talking thoughts clarify themselves and they learn. If you ever wondered why and how it was that Thomas Aquinas spent his time dictating his writings to a series of scribes, perhaps the reason was that he learned and thought best while talking.

Next, ask yourself this question: Do you perform best as part of a team or when working alone? If you have great athletic talent and work well as part of a team, then perhaps football or basketball would be best for you.

If you have great athletic talent but work best on your own, then you should avoid football and basketball and work on your golf or tennis.

Similarly, do you work well in large corporations or small ones? If you perform best in a corporate environment then you might not do your best managing a boutique. If you function well when you are involved in constant team meetings and group interactions, you are not likely to excel as a coach or consultant.

And, do you work best in a highly structured environment where you know exactly what is required of you? Or do you do better when you are working on your own, without institutional constraints?

Do you prefer that your workday contain predictable tasks or that it provide you with a constant stream of challenges and crises? Evidently, if the latter you would probably function well as an emergency room physician. If the former, then perhaps work as an accountant would suit you well.

As I mentioned above, some people are natural leaders; others are natural advisers. James Carville, Karl Rove, and Dick Morris... are natural advisers. They would be inept as leaders.

Some people thrive when they are making decisions and organizing groups. They need not, however, be great at articulating complex ideas. Dwight Eisenhower was a great leader; he gave rather weak press conferences.

By this reasoning we err when we believe that we need our president to be a great thinker or to give great speeches. Leadership is about making decisions and taking responsibility, not offering a course in political philosophy.

While it is clear that an adviser cannot function without someone to advise, Drucker also suggests that leaders often need advisers: "... to force themselves to think; then they can make decisions and act on them with speed, self-confidence, and courage."

Another salient point resembles one I discussed in my other post on Drucker: how do you know the conditions that will allow you to perform at your best? Surely, I am not going to advise you to look deep into your soul to discover whether your heart's desire has destined you to work in a bureaucracy or as an individual coach.

The only way to find out is by trying out different situations.

How many times have we found someone who believes he is allergic to corporate life, being forced to work in a corporate environment, and discovering that he is thriving there? And how many times have we seen corporate executives retire from what they call the rat race in order to write their novel or paint landscapes, only to discover that they cannot tolerate the isolation and solitude of the more contemplative life?


Saturday, November 14, 2009

Obama Bows to the Emperor of Japan

First he bowed to the King of Saudi Arabia. Now Barack Obama has bowed to the Emperor of Japan. Is this simply a trivial gesture or does it signal a new era in American subservience?

At the least we know that kings and emperors take these things extremely seriously, especially in Asia.

The most interesting example occurred in 1793 century when the King of England sent Lord McCartney to the court of the Emperor Qianlong with an offer to share the scientific and technological advances of the Industrial Revolution.

As the story is told, Qianlong rejected McCartney's offerings because the envoy refused to kowtow to the Emperor. For a detailed account, see Alain Peyrefitte's "The Immobile Empire."

As it happens Peyrefitte's explanation has been disputed, perhaps because when Qianlong wrote to the King of England explaining his decision, he did not highlight Lord McCartney's failure to kowtow.

The fact remains, however, that in Confucian and Asian cultures gestures are enormously important. Barack Obama may or may know this, but his instinctive bowing to foreign dignitaries is hardly an assertion of American pride and confidence.

For a fuller analysis of these gestures and what they say about Obama and the new American foreign policy, I link Scott Johnson's analysis from the Powerline blog. Link here.


Preparing for a Job Interview

Surely, it matters that jobs are increasingly hard to find, but, even if they were plentiful, when you walk into a job interview you must be prepared.

How well or poorly you do depends in large part on how you approach the process. Looking for a job is a job. The people who do best in the process are often the people who have worked at it the hardest.

When it comes to the job hunt your youthful insouciance is not your friend. Often when you do not work hard enough what you think of as a cool and calm demeanor will look like: I don't give a damn; or else, I'm too good for this job.

You want to look confident and in control, but that can never happen if you decide to go into the interview unprepared, thinking that you can wing it.

I may be exaggerating somewhat when I say that when it comes to a job interview there is no such thing as over-preparation. At the least, the greatest risk is not that you over-prepare, but that you under-prepare and appear not to be taking the process seriously.

If you do not take the interview seriously, your interviewer will not take you seriously.

So, I have tried on this blog to provide my own advice on how to prepare for an interview, coupled with links to other articles and posts on the topic. Link here.

Today I am linking yet another article on what can go wrong in a job interview, coupled with some advice about how to make things go right for you. It's from the Wall Street Journal, so, in principle, it should be taken seriously. Link here.