Saturday, June 23, 2012

Feminist Blowback for Anne-Marie Slaughter


As often happens, the furor over Anne-Marie Slaughter’s Atlantic article has brought her question into sharper focus.

Even the expected feminist blowback is illuminating. Writing for Salon.com professional feminist Rebecca Traister takes vigorous exception to Slaughter’s viewpoint.

In her words:

Here is what is wrong, what has always been wrong, with equating feminist success with “having it all”: It’s a misrepresentation of a revolutionary social movement. The notion that female achievement should be measured by women’s ability to “have it all” recasts a righteous struggle for greater political, economic, social, sexual and political parity as a piggy and acquisitive project.

Traister is notably agitated by the notion of having it all. She declares, correctly, that no one can ever have it all. So she concludes that women are being told that feminism wants them to have it all so that when they discover that they can’t they will blame feminism.

Ergo, having-it-all-ism is a patriarchal conspiracy to discredit feminism.

In reality, this notion has been intrinsic to feminist recruiting efforts. Feminism is a cult. It tries to attract followers as any cult does, by promising that if you join it you can have everything that you have always dreamed of. You can be a feminist and be married and have a family and have a great career.

By now even Traister sees that the promise is fraudulent. Feminists are walking away from it because it is no longer luring young women into the feminist cult.

Most of the time, feminism is presented as a form of liberal or progressive politics. Most people, I would venture, see it as mainstream, middle-of-the-road, equally at home on the right and the left.

Who today would dare to say that women do not deserve equal pay for equal work?

On this score I agree with Traister and I give her credit for honesty. Feminism is a “revolutionary social movement,” a form of radical leftist social politics.

Whatever your politics are if you join the feminist cult or if you identify yourself as a feminist you are signing on to do the work of leftist extremists.

Since Traister sees feminism as a righteous struggle against, as it happens, human nature, she is correct to say that it should not be seen in terms of the goodies it can hand out. 

We all know that the verb “to have” might have something to do with possessing something. You can have a car and a home and a husband and children. You can have dinner and you might have a Ming vase on your mantle.

But when you say that you have to do something, the verb “to have” has a meaning that is wildly detached from the idea of possession.

Besides, how warped do you have to be to consider that a husband and children are acquisitions, roughly equivalent to a new pair of shoes?

Yet, Traister is trying to make a larger point here. Allow me to clarify it.

She is saying that feminism does not promise a rose garden or a closet full of shoes. It seeks social justice and the overthrow of capitalism. This implies that those who respond to its siren song are asserting a higher degree of moral virtue than are those who join up because they were promised a house in the suburbs to go along with their careers.

In this context, we can reframe Anne-Marie Slaughter’s question. If a woman is both a feminist and a mother and if she chooses to make certain personal sacrifices to advance the cause, does she also have the right to sacrifice her children to the same cause.

To be more precise, is it Slaughter’s duty as a true-believing feminist to sacrifice her SONS to the cause?

The question involves two different forms of human identity. One is defined by social role; the other by ideological commitment. Any form of identity brings with it duties and obligations. 

Of course, a woman can be a feminist and a mother. She can, with more difficulty, be a feminist and a wife. She can also be a feminist and an executive.

Now, what happens if her duty as a feminist conflicts with her duty as a mother or a wife or an executive?

Situations arise, as Slaughter makes clear, where a woman, like most humans who are not women, have to choose: loyalty to her ideology or loyalty to her children? 

Slaughter recognized that her choice of a career opportunity had hurt her children. She decided that her duty as a mother was more important than her duty to feminism.

That is what most disturbs fanatical feminists like Rebecca Traister. They want to make world cultural history and will allow nothing to get in the way, certainly not their duty to care for a teenage boy.

Explaining her decision, Slaughter quoted Mary Matalin, who once said that she was dispensable as a member of the White House staff she was dispensable, but not as her daughters’ mother.

It was easier for the White House could find someone who could do her job than it would be for her daughters to find a replacement mother.

It is obvious to everyone who is not a true-believing feminist that the role of mother cannot be separated from human biology. As Nancy Chodorow once said, it is a universal fact: “Only women mother.”

The duties and obligations that inhere in the role of mother are consonant with biological realities. When a woman functions as mother to her children her moral behavior is in harmony with nature.

Traister seems to disagree. Like all ideological zealots she is at war with reality, especially with human nature, so she does not accept the need to live in harmony with human biology.

Her solution should make us all cringe. She wants nothing less than to rewire your brain.

In her words:

We are still very much in the midst of reversing eons of gendered injustice, overheated headlines (from the, uh, Atlantic) about contemporary female dominance to the contrary. Brains are still getting rewired, systems are still being reworked to accommodate evolving roles.

I admire Traister for so clearly stating her totalitarian aspirations.

Rewiring the brain is obviously a very contemporary concept. The more traditional term is brainwashing.

Clearly, the culture wars being fought in the media and the schools and in government involve an effort to brainwash the citizenry, beginning with children.

Feminists and other radical leftists are trying to brainwash us all into thinking illogically and irrationally, into favoring ideology over empirical fact, into making us put loyalty to the cause ahead of responsibilities as spouses, parents and citizens.

Your highest loyalty, Traister is saying, should be to the grand cause of global Revolution.



Friday, June 22, 2012

Happiness Is Other People


Jean-Paul Sartre once said: Hell is other people.

The cognoscenti bowed in obeisance.

Whatever the phrase meant in its literary context, it has taken on a life of its own.

Some people take it for an ultimate truth. In fact, it’s a narcissist’s lament.

It also explains why therapy so often fails.

Therapy involves you and your mind. It wants to enhance your self-esteem and your self-confidence. It wants you to feel good about yourself, regardless of what other people think of you.

As one might expect, therapists have gotten it ass-backwards. What really matters in life is how other people see you, whether or not they respect you and whether or not they admire you.

Recent research has shown that happiness comes when other people think well of you, see you in a positive light, and respect you.

Obviously, if people admire you they will seek out your company. If people hold you in esteem you will rarely lack for human companionship.

In other words, if you want to be happy, behave in a way that will elicit good will, admiration, and esteem. Surely, that means that success will do more for your happiness than will high self-esteem.

The research did not ask the question this way. It compared the happiness that you could gain from having lots of money, even from hitting the Lottery jackpot with the happiness you would enjoy by being a respected and admired member of your community.

No one should be surprised to discover that you can’t buy happiness. It would have been better if the research had compared the happiness quotients of people who think the world of themselves and people who are respected by other people.

This raises a crucial question. How do you get other people to respect and admire you? It’s hard enough trying to feel good about yourself. Now you learn that for all the work you put into feeling good about yourself, you really need to learn how to influence other people.

After all, that is the question.

Therapists, however, will tell you that it doesn’t matter how others see you. They want you to get in touch with your feelings and then to shower the world with said feelings.

And then they wonder why there’s so much narcissism in the world today.

Perhaps therapists believe what they are saying. But it might also be true that they do not know how to help you earn the esteem of other people. Their methods are so thoroughly centered on the mind of the individual that they have little choice but to ignore other people.

Thus, psychotherapy has defaulted on the factor that contributes the most to your happiness: the way others see you.

Of course, how you see yourself is not irrelevant to how others see you.

Still, other people do not really know how you feel about yourself. They might guess about it, but for the most part, they don’t care.

They do not know how you behave when the lights are out. For the most part they do not want to know. If you insist on telling them they will think less of you.

Other people will judge you by your public behavior. And they will especially judge you on the basis of how you behave toward them.

And yes, I did notice that I used the idea of judgment here. When we speak about whether other people respect and admire you, we are talking about judgment. Most often, the respect you receive will be a judgment of your character.

The therapy culture wants you to believe that when someone thinks ill of you, you need but denounce them for being judgmental. How much respect do you think that that will that garner you?

If therapists do not have much to tell us about how to earn the respect and admiration of others, who does?

Start with people who are in the business of reputation management, public relations specialists. It is a complicated and difficult task, but I promise you that PR executives do not tell their clients that it doesn’t matter what other people think of them.

Leaders,  managers and coaches also know a great deal about this. They know that if they do not command respect they will never be able to exercise leadership.

Dwight Eisenhower once defined leadership as the ability to get another person to do what needs to be done because he wants to do it.

Obviously, it goes well beyond telling someone what to do. It is not about mind control.

Respect and admiration must be granted freely. If they are extorted they will not be of any value.

Getting someone to fear you is not the same as getting him to respect you.

Some people have been puzzled that I have often posted on this blog about political leadership, reputation management, and management issues.

Hopefully, the reason is clear. The new frontier in psychological theorizing does not concern your mind, or even your brain. It concerns the minds of other people.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Work-Life Balance: Why Can't Women Have It All?

In an Atlantic article that will be much read and much discussed Anne-Marie Slaughter sets out to correct the lies that feminists have been telling young women.

Sort of.

By that I mean that she is of two minds about the problem of work-life balance.

Can women have it all? Slaughter says that, as of today, they cannot. A woman cannot have a high-powered career and raise her children as she would wish.

Some women do it, Slaughter recognizes, but they are, as she sees it, super-women. For most women the goal merely promotes feelings of inadequacy, even feelings of having betrayed the feminist cause.

Unrealistic expectations do not help you to conduct our life. Mix them with impossible demands and you are on the road to misery.

The Atlantic summarizes her basic idea:

It’s time to stop fooling ourselves, says a woman who left a position of power: the women who have managed to be both mothers and top professionals are superhuman, rich, or self-employed.

Slaughter herself had held a high-level policy job in the State Department. Her teenage sons lived in Princeton, NJ with their father.

Her husband had stepped in as the primary caregiver. Yet, one of her sons was feeling abandoned and he let his feelings be known.

One day Slaughter was attending an important diplomatic function. She was distracted, however, by the situation at home:

I sipped champagne, greeted foreign dignitaries, and mingled. But I could not stop thinking about my 14-year-old son, who had started eighth grade three weeks earlier and was already resuming what had become his pattern of skipping homework, disrupting classes, failing math, and tuning out any adult who tried to reach him. Over the summer, we had barely spoken to each other—or, more accurately, he had barely spoken to me. And the previous spring I had received several urgent phone calls—invariably on the day of an important meeting—that required me to take the first train from Washington, D.C., where I worked, back to Princeton, New Jersey, where he lived. My husband, who has always done everything possible to support my career, took care of him and his 12-year-old brother during the week; outside of those midweek emergencies, I came home only on weekends.

Slaughter’s situation was ideal. Her husband was not only supportive; he was a tenured professor. Thus, he was not worrying about job security, was not competing for a promotion, and could control his schedule.

Previously, Slaughter had been an academic herself. With a flexible schedule she easily mixed her job and motherhood. Once she joined the State Department all that changed. She got to experience the life in the real world:

In short, the minute I found myself in a job that is typical for the vast majority of working women (and men), working long hours on someone else’s schedule, I could no longer be both the parent and the professional I wanted to be—at least not with a child experiencing a rocky adolescence. I realized what should have perhaps been obvious: having it all, at least for me, depended almost entirely on what type of job I had. The flip side is the harder truth: having it all was not possible in many types of jobs, including high government office—at least not for very long.

Some women can do it; most women can’t.

So far, so good.

Yet, Slaughter holds fast to her feminist creed. She wants to see gender parity throughout the labor market, with an equal number of women and men at every level of every organization.

The American economy has many problems today. Every American should want the economy to improve, to provide more jobs and opportunity for every citizen. Under the administration that Slaughter proudly served the economy has not been doing well at all.

Of course, you cannot grow the economy if you are distracting yourself chasing a pipedream of gender equality.

Achieving feminist goals would require government bureaucrats, lawyers and judges to take over the labor market. How well do you think that new regulations and new lawsuits will advance the goal of economic growth and prosperity? Slaughter does not recommend such a takeover, but it is, by my lights, the inevitable outcome of any effort to achieve her feminist goal.

I will not run through Slaughter’s ideas about how the workplace should adapt to feminist ideology, because, after all, the workplace has already made many of those adaptations and the schools have already introduced gender-neutering education.

How’s that working out for economic growth and employment?

Of course,  you cannot telecommute to a cocktail party. When the cocktail party is an integral part of your workday, as happened in the case Slaughter described, technology is not going to solve the problem.

Telecommuting works for some people, but it also undermines office camaraderie and the different kinds of bonding rituals that co-workers typically undergo.

Conference calls are nice, but people need face time. Most emotion is communicated through facial gestures. And no one gives managerial responsibilities to someone who does not put in a considerable amount of face time. You are not going to trust someone you never see face-to-face. You are not going to promote someone who refuses to look you in the eye on a daily basis.

People compete for promotions. They compete by working harder and longer, even by sacrificing aspects of their personal lives. Do you want to say that some people should not be allowed to work longer hours because others have childcare responsibilities? How would you enforce that?

Slaughter recognizes, more clearly than most that her dreams of feminist utopia must crash into reality. They fail because mothers and fathers are not interchangeable.

Slaughter writes:

Still, the proposition that women can have high-powered careers as long as their husbands or partners are willing to share the parenting load equally (or disproportionately) assumes that most women will feel as comfortable as men do about being away from their children, as long as their partner is home with them. In my experience, that is simply not the case.

Here I step onto treacherous ground, mined with stereotypes. From years of conversations and observations, however, I’ve come to believe that men and women respond quite differently when problems at home force them to recognize that their absence is hurting a child, or at least that their presence would likely help. I do not believe fathers love their children any less than mothers do, but men do seem more likely to choose their job at a cost to their family, while women seem more likely to choose their family at a cost to their job.

Of course, this is heresy to feminists, and Slaughter compensates by offering  a myriad of ways for women to maintain their face time with their children while still pursuing high-powered careers.

Still, she is quite right to underscore the differences between mothers and fathers. And she is correct to describe the difference in terms that are reflexive and innate, not the product of socialization.

More importantly, Slaughter identifies the set of cultural values that have produced these problems.

She says:

You should be able to have a family if you want one—however and whenever your life circumstances allow—and still have the career you desire. If more women could strike this balance, more women would reach leadership positions. And if more women were in leadership positions, they could make it easier for more women to stay in the workforce.

Slaughter adheres to these values. I consider them to be the problem.

In my view it's a rank distortion to say that life is or should be about getting what you want, when you want, with whom you want and from whom you want.

We owe this misleading idea to the therapy culture.

Life is a negotiation. It’s a negotiation between what you are good at and what the market will pay for. If you want to do what you are good at, fine. If what you are good at is not exactly what you want to do, adjust your expectations.

Life is a negotiation between the biological imperative to reproduce and the available supply of potential mates.

Life is a negotiation between your duties to your family and your duties to your job.

One thing that it’s not about is getting what you want no matter what.

The notion that we ought to reconstruct the marketplace in order to ensure that feminists can continue to tilt at windmills is serious mistake.

As for the larger question: why can't women have it all? The answer is simple: because no one can.


[All discussions of Slaughter are referring to Facebook executive Sheryl Sandberg. I posted my thoughts on Sandberg previously. Link here. ]

More Reviews of Aaron Sorkin's "The Newsroom"


Imagine being Aaron Sorkin today.

You believe firmly in all leftist dogmas. You are convinced that you possess a superior intelligence. You have written a television show that glorifies leftist dogmas, putting them in the mouth of a blowhard broadcaster who reminds people of Keith Olberman.

You expect to be showered with plaudits from television critics... for your brilliance, your audacity, and the utter correctness of your opinions.

At the least, you assume that the liberal media will cut you some slack. After all, you are doing God's word, indoctrinating the ignorant masses in leftists pieties.

But then, on Monday, as posted here, The New Yorker’s television critic Emily Nussbaum did not just pan your show. She trashed it to within an inch of its life.

It was an inauspicious start.

Then yesterday, Maureen Ryan weighed in on the Huffington Post. She echoed Nussbaum’s views.

In Ryan’s words:

The biggest problem with "The Newsroom" -- and it's one of many, many problems -- is that its goals and its narrative strategies are in direct conflict with each other. The result is a dramatically inert, infuriating mess, one that wastes a fine cast to no demonstrable purpose, unless you consider giving Sorkin yet another platform in which to Set the People Straight is a worthwhile purpose.

She continued:

Everything about it is overblown or undercooked to the point of being laughable; a palpable and occasionally comical cognitive dissonance arose between the admiration the swelling soundtrack told me I was supposed to feel and the buzzing annoyance I actually felt during the four episodes I watched. Even aesthetically, the whole thing feels off: The cinematography in Will's airless newsroom is pallid and clumsy, and the interactions of the characters feel flat and contrived.

And then:

A show in which paper-thin characters spend so much time congratulating themselves for "speaking truth to stupid" is always going to have an uphill climb in the hearts and minds of viewers used to more subtle delights, but when "The Newsroom" isn't obvious and self-congratulatory, it's manipulative and shrieky. 

Apparently, Ryan did not like the show.

But, what about Washington Post television critic, Hank Stuever? Yesterday he offered his less-than-favorable review. In a slap to Sorkin he found the writing especially bad. 

In Stuever’s words:

The word pile that once seemed so melodious in Sorkin’s other projects — especially that millennial anti-anxiety medication known as the “The West Wing” — now has the effect of tinnitus. The men talk like Sorkin writes; the women talk that way, too; the 28-year-olds talk like that, as do the 41-year-olds, as do the cast’s septuagenarians, who include Sam Waterston as the head of the network news division and, later on, Jane Fonda as the network owner who puts the arch in matriarch. (In other words, Jane Fonda as Ted Turner.)

In case you missed the point, he added:

Characters never stop speechifying to one another, replacing believable dialogue with that unmistakably Sorkinesque logorrhea of righteous self-importance. It’s a puppet show with Sorkin as the only hand, expressing his displeasure with the tenor of public discourse. (Which everyone knows has reached an unctuous low.) 

Of course, the show’s first episode had not yet aired. Still, it does not look good for Wunderkind Aaron Sorkin. 

A Coup in Egypt?


The situation in Egypt is not very promising. The people have voted for a parliament and a president.

After Islamic factions won the parliament, the military dissolved it.

Not exactly a democratic outcome.

The results of the presidential election have not been announced, but the Muslim Brotherhood candidate seems very, very likely to have won the presidential election. Will the new president be empowered or will he be disempowered by the military? As of now, we don't know.

According to David Goldman the Egyptian military is receiving financial support from Saudi Arabia.

No one knows exactly where we are going from here, but the possibility of a military coup increases by the day.

Naturally, the Obama administration is siding with the Muslim Brotherhood, threatening to withdraw military aid if the Brothers are not given complete power in Egypt.

Well over a year ago, when the Arab Spring made its way to Egypt,  commentators the world over were predicting that democracy was coming to Egypt, just as it had come to Eastern Europe. At the time, I suggested that we would do better to see the potential parallel with what happened in Algeria two decades ago.

There, an election was held. Islamist parties won. The military nullified the election, and s civil war ensued.

As of today, I’m looking a lot more prophetic than certain columnists.

One reason I was able to remain rational about the Arab Spring was that I paid close attention to the views of David Goldman. This morning Goldman offered his perspective about the current state of things in Egypt. In passing her makes reference to the pundits and commentators who got it so wrong last year.

In his words:

There are still democracy activists on Tahrir Square wondering where their revolution went, calling for a million-man march against the military’s “coup.” But the punditeska that hailed the Arab Spring as the best thing since the American founding is thunderously silent. Where is the snow job of yesteryear? The punditeska’s infatuation with the Arab Spring ran across the whole political spectrum, from Tom Friedman at the New York Times to Bill Kristol at the Weekly Standard. When it came to the crunch, the “tech-savvy activists” of Tahrir Square turned out to be “benzine bubbles floating atop the viscous Nile mud,” as I called them in February 2011. Both the Facebook revolution and the Facebook IPO since have gone pear-shaped, and what is left is the mud of Egyptian society: the military against the Muslim Brotherhood.

The collective sigh of relief is audible. The prospect of a Muslim Brotherhood regime controlling Egypt’s parliament as well as the presidency was too horrible to contemplate, especially in light of the unending horror in Syria. Democracy is betrayed by collusion of Egypt’s old regime and one of the world’s nastiest regimes, but the punditeska is too pleased to protest. Not even Tom Friedman wants the Muslim Brothers to get control of the Egyptian state. For the moment, Egyptians have Saudi Arabia to thank for their penny-a-loaf pita ration, and the hand the military had to kiss in order to get it. And that is immeasurably better than the alternative.


Wednesday, June 20, 2012

What is Slavoj Zizek?


When Plato declared that communities should be ruled by philosopher-kings he meant that philosophers should be made into kings or that kings should learn how to philosophize.

Today’s America has more than a few aspiring philosopher-kings, public intellectuals who want to wield political power and to exercise political influence. Some segments of the population even believe that we should place intellectuals in public office, regardless of how incompetent or unqualified they are.

Still, that is penny ante when you look at an aspiring philosopher-king like the great Nazi philosopher Martin Heidegger. A member of the Nazi party and a strong defender of the Third Reich Heidegger believed that Hitler could improve his policies if only he would allow Heidegger to teach him philosophy.

European philosophers and intellectuals have long been held in thrall by tyrants and despots. Utterly lacking in shame they have glommed on to Lenin, Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Pol Pot… whoever.

It’s a lot easier to capture the mind of a despot than to rustle up votes via retail politics or to implement real policies in the real world.

Philosophers believe in a world where their great minds can impose their great ideas on a human race that they take to be so much silly putty.

Of course, the world is not exactly awash in great philosophers these days. There is no new Sartre, no new Heidegger, no new Foucault on the horizon.

So we have reached the next stage in human intellectual evolution: the advent of the philosopher-clown.

Of course, I am referring to famed Slovenian philosopher and culture critic, Slavoj Zizek.

As self-styled post-Marxist thinker Zizek has come to embody the truth of one of Marx’s more famous dicta:

History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.

How else to see Zizek than as a philosopher-clown involved in an extraordinary intellectual farce.

If you will allow me to be properly Zizekian, I would also say that Zizek is a symptom of a cultural moment, a crisis of faith among hyper-educated intellectual leftists.

Disaffected intellectuals the world over have become flotsam and jetsam, scattered over the ocean, the detritus remaining after the sinking of the good ship Communism.

Now that Communism has definitively failed what will become of the graduate students, the deconstructionists, the critical theorists, the Occupiers.

What will become of their grand ideas, their visions and their dreams? Now that they have no more gods to worship are they destined to become capitalist entrepreneurs?

Their gods have failed them, but they have taken consolation through the erudite entertainment offered by Slavoj Zizek. Or better, he has found them.

A consummate intellectual entrepreneur Zizek has succeeded in exploiting their credulity and ignorance of the disaffected left by selling them tome after tome of barely intelligible verbiage.

They were looking for a new master and a new way to be duped. Zizek has obliged.

Only a Neo-Communist, i.e., a Neo-com, like Zizek could be such a perfect capitalist. He has found a way to exploit and monetize the ignorance of leftist intellectuals. He has found a way to feed their pretensions. He has found a niche market and has flooded it with goods and goodies.

Zizek’s writings do not instruct; they do not engage in the hard labor of ratiocination. Proud of their intrinsic illogic, they are a rhetorical performance. They shock; they awe; they entertain. They produce emotion, not thought.

Disaffected leftists can read Zizek, not understand a word of it, but still feel that they belong to something, to a cause perhaps, but, more likely to a virtual community of great minds that modern capitalism has left behind.

Of course, there’s method to Zizek’s self-proclaimed madness. Marx failed, Zizek tells us, because it tried to mold the real world. There was nothing wrong with Marx’s Hegelian theories except that he chose to address practical problems.

It was a fatal error. So, Zizek, if I may paraphrase, wants to offer membership in a giant virtual community of minds, thereby creating a group of cult followers who have no idea what they think and no real engagement with reality.

Zizek is happy to tell them what they want to hear. Disaffected post-Marxists and Neo-Communists want to hear about the failure of capitalism. Green to the gills, they want to hear that capitalism is destroying the planet, that it is an offense against the natural order.

If these ideas do not correlate with reality, so much the better. That makes them more pure.

Perhaps you have to live on the European continent to appreciate it. When British philosopher John Gray took to reading some of Zizek’s latest tomes—surely to save the rest of us from having to do so— he dared to follow the tradition of good British empiricism and to evaluate Zizek’s claims against the facts:

With its sweeping claims and magniloquent rhetoric, this passage is typical of much in Žižek’s work. What he describes as the premise of the book is simple only because it passes over historical facts. Reading it, no one would suspect that, putting aside the killings of many millions for ideological reasons, some of the last century’s worst ecological disasters—the destruction of nature in the former Soviet Union and the devastation of the countryside during Mao’s Cultural Revolution, for example—occurred in centrally planned economies. Ecological devastation is not a result only of the economic system that exists in much of the world at the present time; while it may be true that the prevailing version of capitalism is unsustainable in environmental terms, there is nothing in the history of the past century that suggests the environment will be better protected if a socialist system is installed.

Gray is writing in The New York Review of Books. He is not a fan of global capitalism. He is surely as green as Zizek.

Yet, he sees that Zizek is courting danger by making outrageous claims in the interest of titillating the masses of disaffected intellectuals.

Zizek would reply that he does not want to put his ideas into practice. He has no interest in logic or in common sense. When he talks about violence he does not mean it as the way the language prescribes.

Zizek said:

It’s crucial to see violence which is done repeatedly to keep the things the way they are. In that sense, Gandhi was more violent than Hitler.

Of course, this is gibberish. Zizek is trying to shock people. And yet, what happens when someone goes out to kill a few Jews because, after all, such actions are less violent than what Gandhi did?

Zizek celebrates violence and terrorism because it will alienate people from reality. It will lead them to live within a virtual community of true believers and cult followers. Gray explains:

…though Žižek accepts that violence has failed to achieve its communist goals and has no prospect of doing so, he insists that revolutionary violence has intrinsic value as a symbolic expression of rebellion…

Rather than denounce the great mass murderers of the last century Zizek declares that Hitler, Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot were not violent enough!

If they had taken the next Hegelian step and destroyed the apparatus of state power, they would have liberated the World Spirit and ushered in a new world of great minds.

For Zizek, that would be the true 1%. Interviewed by the Guardian Zizek recently declared that 99% of the human race counts as: “boring idiots.”

Zizek does not fault the Nazis for their violence or for the holocaust. He objects to Hitler on more philosophical grounds:

In Zizek’s words:

The true problem of Nazism is not that it “went too far” in its subjectivist-nihilist hubris of exercising total power, but that it did not go far enough, that its violence was an impotent acting-out which, ultimately, remained in the service of the very order it despised.

This suggests that if Nazism had created a new social order then there would have been ample justification for the methods it used.

As Gray says, this is utterly "repugnant and grotesque." In his words:

Describing mass murder in this way as an exercise in hermeneutics is repugnant and grotesque; it is also characteristic of Žižek’s work. He criticizes Stalin’s policy of collectivization, but not on account of the millions of human lives that were violently truncated or broken in its course. What Žižek criticizes is Stalin’s lingering attachment (however inconsistent or hypocritical) to “‘scientific’ Marxist terms.” Relying on “objective social analysis” for guidance in revolutionary situations is an error: “at some point, the process has to be cut short with a massive and brutal intervention of subjectivity: class belonging is never a purely objective social fact, but is always also the result of struggle and social engagement.” Rather than Stalin’s relentless use of torture and lethal force, it is the fact that he tried to justify the systematic use of violence by reference to Marxian theory that Žižek condemns.

 Zizek would not be bothered by the contradiction. His post-Cartesian slogan might be: I contradict myself, therefore I am.


Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Making Good Use of Anxiety


If you use it properly anxiety can help you. If you don’t, it can defeat you.  If you never feel it, you have a real problem.

The right anxiety used correctly can help you to focus on the task at hand and to work harder to succeed. If you are moderately anxious about failing you will be more motivated to do what it takes to succeed.

In excess, anxiety might cause you to freeze up or to lose focus. Too much anxiety can cripple you, cause you to worry so much that you focus more on the emotion and less on the job.

If you are facing a difficult or challenging task and you feel no anxiety you are showing that you do not understand the stakes and do not see the possibility of failure. This complex of emotions will most likely cause you to slack off.

When it comes to anxiety, you can feel too much, too little or just enough.

The question is: how do you find what the cognitive psychologists call the sweet spot? Or better, how do you find what Aristotle called the golden mean between the extremes of too much and too little.

Cognitive psychologists are hard at work on the issue. They would do well to consult with Aristotle. After all, the philosopher defined ethical behavior as the ability to find the mean between two extremes.

When defining bravery, Aristotle declared that it existed somewhere between trigger-happy and gun-shy.

We know that it’s wrong to be trigger-happy. We know that it’s wrong to be gun-shy. We are not so sure that we know whether an action is brave or not.

The same applies to emotions. As Aristotle had it, it’s wrong to be angry all the time, and it’s wrong never to be angry. Ethical behavior involves showing anger at the right time in the right place under the right circumstances.

How do you know when you have reached the sweet spot? How do you know when you are being courageous and when you are being trigger-happy or gun-shy?

Unfortunately, you don’t. You are left to rely on your own good judgment, judgment forged in the crucible of experience.

And, of course, you cannot really know whether you have hit the sweet spot until you have acted, courageously or not. If it is impossible to know before the fact, then your actions, even your ethical actions, must always contain an element of anxiety.

The results of your actions will tell you whether you were being  brave, cowardly, or reckless.

The principle applies to anxiety. You can be frenetic and frantic; you can be lackadaisical and detached, or you can be intent and focused. Only by translating your anxiety into effective action can you know whether you have hit the sweet spot.

Melinda Beck reports in the Wall Street Journal:

Somewhere between checked out and freaked out lies an anxiety sweet spot, some researchers say, in which a person is motivated to succeed yet not so anxious that performance takes a dive. This moderate amount of anxiety keeps people on their toes, enables them to juggle multiple tasks and puts them on high alert for potential problems.

The cognitive-ethical approach does not, one must emphasize, see anxiety as something to medicate.

Obviously, some anxiety is so extreme that it requires medication. Yet, the extremes should not make the rule.

Cognitivists and ethicists are suggesting that we ought first consider that anxiety can be useful, and that can direct you toward success and achievement.

It's better to be positive than to think that anxiety is an emotional pathogen that must be eliminated, no matter what.

Beck explains:

Anxiety is especially self-defeating when people focus on the fear itself, rather than the task at hand. The best way to stay in the "sweet spot," Dr. Moser says, is to channel the anxiety into productive activity—like studying and acing the test. "I tell a lot of my patients that Nike really has a great slogan—Just Do It," he says.

Turning anxiety into action is also a major component of cognitive behavioral therapy, which is widely seen as the most effective treatment for anxiety disorders. Identifying and challenging self-defeating thoughts, and gradually facing the source of fears, can provide more lasting relief than antianxiety medications, psychologists say.

Exactly right: don’t focus on the fear; turn anxiety into action. Direct your attention away from the anxiety and toward the situation at hand. The more you know about the situation and the less you are focused on your emotional state the more effective you will be.

If you are worried about an upcoming test or report or project chances are that you have cause for worry. But it does not mean that you need to take a pill to calm down. It means that you need to work harder, study harder, prepare better.

Cognitive therapists consider medication a short-term fix, at best. At worst, they see it as a way to avoid the problem.

Beck reports:

"If you have to take Xanax to get on the elevator, you never learn that the elevator isn't something to be afraid of," says Dr. Josephson. "You have to embrace the anxiety to overcome it."

That is often how psychologists help performers overcome stage fright or athletes snap out of a slump. Relaxation techniques such as meditation and deep breathing can bring a toxic level of anxiety down, but harnessing it can ultimately be more effective. Rehearsing a scenario repeatedly can help manage and defuse the fear.

Clearly cognitive and ethical approaches are far superior to insight-oriented psychoanalytically-inspired treatments. As you might imagine, Freudian treatment has an entirely different approach to anxiety.

If you are suffering from anxiety and you consult a Freudian therapist he will see your anxiety in terms of unacknowledged guilt. You are anxious because you fear that you will be caught and punished.

For what, pray tell? Sometimes for your criminal acts, but mostly for your depraved motives and criminal intentions.

Freudian theory posits that you are caught in a guilt/punishment narrative. It does not see you actively engaged in confronting a real challenge or even a real danger. Freudian therapists are more likely to recommend that you postpone confronting a difficult challenge.

If you are anxious about the golf tournament or your next interview Freud therapy will want you to understand that you are feeling anxious because the current situation reminds you of a past situation where you cheated or lied or wanted to do something that was very, very bad.

It will try to induce you to embrace your guilt, or better, to misread your anxiety as guilt. Then, it will teach you how to palliate it by doing penance, by punishing yourself. It will want you to perform acts of moral self-flagellation… like criticizing yourself and telling yourself that you are not worthy.

How well do you think that this therapy will prepare you for your next presentation or for the big game? More likely it is setting you up for failure... and for further psychoanalysis.