Friday, March 26, 2021

Whiny Bankers Anonymous

It’s a sad time for young investment bankers. Having made their way on to the fast track to considerable fortune, these millennial sods are now unhappy that they are working so hard. As it happens, they are working very long hours, just as their forebears did. But, they are millennials, so they complain about it. They belong to a generation of whiners. The only thing that was missing from the PowerPoint presentation was an assertion of the wonders of work/life balance.

Keep in mind, the millennial generation has by now taken over America’s newsrooms. They have a considerable say in the running of the New York Times. Currently, they are running it into a ditch. But, they do not care. They are principled.

Of course, journalism is a dying profession. The Times barely stays afloat. Goldman Sachs, however, is a thriving institution. In fact, it is making so much money that it is preparing to move its asset management division to Palm Beach, FL.

So, its junior analysts have formed something of a cabal. They are not trying to take over the firm, but they are complaining about how much they have to work. And besides, they are being disrespected. Fancy that.

Brooke Masters reports the story for the Financial Times (link unavailable):

The PowerPoint presentation in which 13 young Goldman Sachs analysts complained that they were overworked and disrespected has divided opinion sharply.

It ought to be fairly obvious that they have just shot their careers in the foot, so to speak. No bank needs a coterie of whiners. Many more senior figures dismissed their complaints:

“Snowflakes,” scoffed one bank executive, remembering that he too worked 95 hours a week when deal flow was high. So what if 92 per cent of them felt “ignored” in meetings: “They’re 22 years old and have been working less than a year. What can they add?” Jim Cramer of CNBC was equally snarky: “if they can't live on four hours [sleep] they should be miserable,” he tweeted.

Opinion was divided, of course:

But others called the long hours a “form of hazing” and argued that Wall Street culture must change to diversify workforces and compete for top talent.

What does it mean to diversify the workforce? It’s a sly insertion on the author’s part which does not tell us anything about the diversity of the whiners. Does the bank hire to fill diversity quotas? Or does it hire the best, giving everyone a fair chance? 

One suspects that Masters is implying that women do not like working 100 hour weeks—understandably, of course—and that the workforce must ensure that no one else can work long hours either. Of course, this assumes that the women who are looking for more work/life balance are top talent.

The bank CEO, David Solomon tried to show sensitivity. If he had not, it would have been a PR nightmare:

Goldman Sachs’ chief executive David Solomon tried to split the difference in a tape-recorded message to staff over the weekend. “We want a workplace where people can share concerns freely,” he said, promising stricter enforcement of an existing ban on requiring junior bankers to work on Saturdays. But he asked staff to continue to “go the extra mile for our client, even when we feel that we’re reaching our limit”.

Funnily enough, the banking business is doing very well, thank you. And yet, millennial religious beliefs do not value hard work. Apparently, they do not value getting ahead. So, Masters calls it all a high-paid sweat shop. This in contrast to many businesses that are low paid sweat shops.

The divisions underscore three things. Despite reform efforts after a Bank of America intern died of an epileptic seizure in 2013, investment banking remains something of a high-paid sweat shop. Millennial and Gen Z workers are more willing to challenge their bosses than their predecessors. And the Covid-19 pandemic has made the ensuing conflict much worse.

As it happened, the fault does not lie so much in the long hours as it lies in the isolation imposed by the lockdowns. About that we are in full sympathy, because many people, from children on up to seniors are suffering from the social isolation imposed by the lockdowns.

Financial and professional services firm are on a tear in areas connected to equity capital markets: initial public offerings, mergers and acquisitions and private equity. Complaints are rising about burnout and overwork, although few match the 11-page Goldman slide deck for detail. At the Wallstreetoasis website, one person wrote: “At UBS, it’s the same here. Want to die.” Junior employees at the private equity firm Apollo griped they were “paid to grind”. And an associate at the US law firm Latham & Watkins told the Financial Times that work “has pervaded every waking (and sometimes sleeping) moment”.

And,

Covid has only roiled this toxic stew. With most white-collar professionals still working from home, the lines between work and home are further blurred. Remote work also removes the social benefits of long hours: camaraderie, contact with senior bankers, even bragging rights. Instead of sharing late-night takeaway with work buddies, many analysts are living at home and fending off concerns from protective parents.

Remote work has been a disaster for banks and other businesses that rely on an apprenticeship model. Many of the youngest workers, including the complaining Goldman analysts, have never met their bosses in person. Juniors feel less connected to the institution, and seniors find it hard to judge when underlings are struggling.

Worse yet, today’s millennials are especially sensitive to abuse. They are easily triggered and believe that it their therapeutic right to speak truth to power. 

The Daily Mail explains some of their torments, from being managed to hearing swear words. Surely, they have earned their position as snowflakes:

Meanwhile, 83 percent of respondents said they had experienced 'excessive monitoring or micromanagement'. 17 percent said they 'frequently encountered shouting or swearing'.

A majority of the analysts claimed they felt like they had been a victim of workplace abuse, while three-quarters said they had sought or considered counselling due to stress. 

They are obviously not long for the world of investment banking. And they are saying that the future of the American investment banking business is in doubt:

The outpouring comes as most workplaces are already struggling with clashes between senior managers and millennial and Gen Z workers who refuse to sit quietly in their allotted places. “There is less tolerance for abuse and more of a sense that when you experience abuse you should speak up,” says one senior Goldmanite who expresses a sneaking sympathy.

That’s one reason why many senior bankers, Solomon included, are pushing to get people back to the office. And there is a mad dash on at Goldman, UBS and elsewhere to hire more junior bankers to help share the load….

That would be money well spent.

Thursday, March 25, 2021

Unfollow the Science

John Kerry is a man of science. It took a lot of science, and probably also a lot of cosmetic surgery, to produce that look.

So, our high prince of pomposity recently announced that science had given us nine years before the world would suffer a climate catastrophe that would make hurricane Katrina feel like a drizzle. 

OK, he didn’t quite say that, but Kerry did say that we must follow the science that is predicting the end of the world, and enact the Green New Deal.


Of course, Kerry did not know and will never know that predictions about the future are not scientific facts. At best, they are hypotheses. At worst, they are prophecies. But, they are in no way science. As Wittgenstein so aptly noted, there is no such thing as a scientific fact about tomorrow.


And then there is Dr. Anthony Fauci, elevated to sainthood for his management of the coronavirus pandemic. We recall, yet again, that Dr. Fauci was personally responsible for sending the virus to Wuhan, China. He assessed that the lab over there was well equipped to keep it under control. Evidently, he bore no responsibility whatever for what happened. Huh?


We also recognize that Fauci was leading the charge against the virus. Yet, strangely enough, the media has done a full court press to ensure that Fauci had not the least scintilla of responsibility for the pandemic, but to make it appear that he single handedly stopped it. Surely, responsibility must be shared, but in truth the man in charge was the man in charge. And that was Dr. Fauci. To some large extent the deaths are on his record.


Yet, given the propaganda media that now seeks total mind control, Dr. Fauci is a great hero while Donald Trump is a mass murderer. Fauci is even more of a hero than Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who sent recovering patients to nursing homes, where they infected the residents and caused around 15,000 unnecessary deaths. Remember when Cuomo was a national hero, the ultimate anti-Trump?


Remember especially that the news about Cuomo’s dereliction was common knowledge before the election. Yet, the media refused to report on the story until after the election.


So, the Democratic Party has crowned itself the party of science. And yet, it believes, as an article of secular dogma, that a man who thinks he is a woman and who poisons himself with cross-sex hormones, is really a woman.


It’s a scientific fact, the Democrats say, and it is even a job qualification. Yesterday, the Senate confirmed one Dr. Rachel Levine to be a top official at the Dept. of Health and Human services. Not only did she fail miserably in her job in Pennsylvania, but she was appointed to make history. And yet, no one with eyes to see will believe that she is really a she.


So much for science. We are not dealing with rational thought, the basis for scientific enquiry, but with dogma and superstition. When doing science, or when thinking empirically, you are willing to allow the evidence to refute your theories. You allow experience or experiment to affirm or deny your hypotheses. This means, as Richard Feynman argued, that science is based on skepticism, on an open mind and on a mind that is willing to allow the evidence to cast judgment on theories.


Naturally, if you say that Dr. Levine does not look like a human female, your opinion, to say nothing of the composition of her trillions of chromosomes, will be dismissed as bigotry-- because it might make her feel bad. 


When you enforce opinions you are dealing with dogma. When you do not allow people to express any opinions that would run counter to your most cherished beliefs, you are promoting dogma.


Those who believe in science are merely using the term to impose their beliefs on a gullible populace. They are not interested in discovering scientific knowledge, but in changing the world to make it conform to their beliefs. There is a massive difference between negotiating with reality and changing it. Wherever did we get the idea that we must change reality when it does not affirm our dogmatic beliefs.


Clearly, to be very specific, the Democrats believe that if they can force everyone to think that the transgendered are really the gender they believe they are, well then, they will be the gender that they believe they are. Fact yields to groupthink.


Victor Davis Hanson argued the larger point in a recent article on American Greatness.


In truth, leftists and Democrats have become the purveyors of superstition. Their creation of a fantasy world is not because they do not believe in science per se, but because they believe more in the primacy of ideology that should shape and warp science in the proper fashion for the greater good. What prompted Paul Ehrlich, Al Gore, or Representative Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) hysterically and wrongly to forecast widespread demographic or climatological catastrophe in just a few years was not ignorance of science per se, but a desire to massage science for our own good.


Not only that, but it was prophecy masquerading as science.


And then there is Dr. Fauci. He is a master at public relations, at messaging, but, from the time he declared that the virus was not going to be a problem-- remember that-- to the time that he said that masking was unnecessary, he has been consistently wrong. And yet, he has become an object of veneration, so we are not allowed to say so. There is nothing scientific about the worship of Dr. Fauci.


Hanson continues:


Dr. Fauci has not just been flat-out wrong on the science of COVID - in his assessments of the origins and possible dangers of COVID-19, of when we can get back to normal, of when the vaccinations would appear, and of which particular governors have been doing the most or least effective management of the disease. He has also, by his own admission, deliberately lied. 


Currently, the nation is engaging a long overdue debate about the efficacy of lockdowns. By most accounts, locking down a state like California did not produce any better results in terms of the disease than did opening a state like Florida. But, lockdowns cause significant damage to businesses, to families and to children. About that the party of science does not really care-- it can throw money at the problems.


Fauci does not care, because he is obviously a true-believing leftist:


Unspoken, is that Fauci usually errs on the side of what is deemed progressive orthodoxy. In contrast, Dr. Scott Atlas warned us that extended and complete lockdowns in any cost-benefit analyses might well inflict more human and economic damage than the virus. And he added that an opened-up Florida and Texas might do no worse virally than a locked-down California or New York, while avoiding the severe recessionary collateral damage.


And let us not forget, Hanson explains, that in the midst of the pandemic throngs of people took to the streets to protest the murder of George Floyd. And that the Democrats, for all their professed confidence in the science, had not a word to say. The protests made Donald Trump look bad. The protests ginned up Democratic voter turnout. What are a plethora of new coronavirus cases when the politics can be turned to your favor?


Hanson writes:


Consider another scientific debacle. In the midst of the quarantine, when governors and mayors were threatening to jail any who violated social distancing, mask wearing, or assembling en mass outdoors, hundreds of thousands hit the nation’s streets in crowded phalanxes of screaming and saliva-projecting protestors—all supposedly in violation of “the science” of epidemiology and public health. 

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

Aggrieved Muslim Opens Fire on White People; Blame White Supremacy

Let’s see, an aggrieved Muslim opens fire on white people in Colorade, killing ten of them, and the problem is-- you guessed it, white supremacy.

People who believe in their narrative, who take it to be dogma, should be cheering this act of rebellion against white privilege. After all, they have been militating for it. They have been supporting every manner of violence against white people and their interests. 


And yet, when their rhetoric becomes reality, they are the first ones running for the exits. First they declared Ahmad al Aliwi Alissa to be white. After all, he looked white, and he fit the narrative. So he had to be white. 


When they discovered that he was a Muslim, they immediately declared that he was aggrieved by Islamophobia. Thus, white bigots had incited him to violence. That he had committed this violence against white people did not make a lot of sense, but it’s not the point to make any of it make sense. The point is to advance the narrative.


Finally, our thought leaders have declared that Ahmad al Aliwi Alissa was mentally ill, and thus sorely in need of treatment. Of course, we know nothing about whether he sought treatment or whether his parents had him on their insurance. Thanks to Obamacare, he, being 21 years of age, qualified for parental insurance. 


But, the only treatment that is guaranteed to work in such cases is involuntary commitment-- locking him up in a psych word. And yet, as we discovered in the case of the Aurora, Colorado shooter, James Holmes, it is extremely difficult in Colorado to get someone committed against his will. You recall that Holmes had been consulting with a psychiatrist who wanted to have him committed. And who could not do it, given state laws. You may thank the civil liberties lobby for that one. 


From this we can only conclude that the fault lies with guns. And with the gun lobby.


If that is not true, the American left would have to admit that Ahmad al Aliwi Alissa was merely acting on the eliminationist rhetoric that the radical left has been spewing for the past few years. From hating Trump to hating white people to excusing violence against white people to blaming white people for any violence committed by people of color.


It is a sad and sorry reflection of the current state of the American mind.


Dr. Bandy X. Lee, Fired from Yale, Sues

One wonders why this story never made the news. Last May, Yale University’s School of Medicine fired Dr. Bandy X. Lee for her unhinged statements about President Donald Trump.

The story was reported in the Yale Daily News, but rarely in other media outlets. Obviously, this contrasts with the coverage that Dr. Lee's initial diagnosis of Trump received.


You will recall that Dr. Lee led the charge against Trump’s mental fitness for office, denouncing him as a pathological narcissist, or some such. Trump detractors wanted to use her testimony in order to have the president removed from office via the 25th Amendment.


But, she did not just limit herself to denouncing Trump. She denounced Trump supporters for  sharing the same psychosis.


Now, of course, she is suing Yale. The Daily Mail has the news:


Dr Brandy Lee, a former faculty member in the Department of Psychiatry in School of Medicine, filed a complaint against the Yale Monday claiming that she was unlawfully terminated 'due to her exercise of free speech about the dangers of Donald Trump's presidency.' 


Dr Lee has been a vocal critic of Trump over the years, notably sending a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2019 claiming that President Trump is showing 'signs of delusion' amid his first impeachment inquiry. 


The former professor said in her complaint that Yale fired her for a January 2020 tweet where she described how 'just about all' of Trump's supporters suffered from 'shared psychosis.'


Among those she denounced, was Prof. Alan Dershowitz. See this blog's post about that issue. Perhaps she picked a fight with the wrong opponent. She accused Dershowitz of having taken on Trump’s psychotic symptoms by contagion. To which Dershowitz responded by filing a grievance against her.


The Yale Daily News has also reported the story about her lawsuit:


According to court documents, after Dershowitz sent his letter on Jan. 11, chair of the Psychiatry Department John Krystal MED ’84 warned Lee via an email that the department “would be compelled to ‘terminate [her] teaching role’” if she continued to make similar public statements. She continued to tweet about the mental fitness of Trump even after Krystal’s warning. Lee then met with Krystal and additional unnamed faculty members and was told that she “breached psychiatric ethics,” according to an email excerpt in the filing. According to court documents, Yale refused to hold additional discussions or investigate the accusations further. On May 17, 2020, Lee was notified that she was terminated. She appealed the decision multiple times in August and September, to no avail.


Krystal wrote to Lee in a Sept. 4 letter included in the court filing that the department’s main consideration in the termination was her “clinical judgement and professionalism” after she publicly stated her “diagnostic impressions” of Trump and other public figures. Krystal emphasized in the letter that the termination “was not because of the political content” of her statements.


“Although the committee does not doubt that you are acting on the basis of your personal moral code,” the letter read, “your repeated violations of the APA’s Goldwater Rule and your inappropriate transfer of the duty to warn from the treatment setting to national politics raised significant doubts about your understanding of crucial ethical and legal principles in psychiatry.”


Good. 


Julie Burchill on Wokeness

Just what the doctor ordered-- a little Julie Burchill with your morning coffee. The following excerpts come from an article Burchill wrote for The London Telegraph two months ago. Link unavailable. 

Burchill is always fun to read. Lately, she has been taking out after the woke minions in the press and the academy.


So, for your edification, she begins by explaining that wokery was produced by universities. Academics brainwashed students in this leftist totalitarianism. Said students then went out and got jobs in the media and in publishing. They then allow their ideology to metastasize:


When we consider where we are today, mithering over the misgendering of a potato, it’s worth remembering that the whole silly thing started in our hallowed groves of academe. Snowflake lecturers raised snowflake students who are led to believe that contrary to the Latin root of the word, “education” is not “to lead out” but rather “to shut in”. The approved manner of learning in too many universities is no longer by listening and debating but by putting one’s fingers in one’s ears and squealing indignantly – removing them only when the rich history of the world is safely turned into a Good vs Evil struggle that makes Tom and Jerry look nuanced.


The second salient point about wokeness echoes an idea that I myself have been arguing. People who insist on shutting down debate by silencing their opponents are in truth too stupid to engage in any serious debate:


They used to say that socialism was the politics of envy – but it had a lot going for it, and lots of people involved, from Lenin to Jessica Mitford, weren’t poor to start with. Woke really is built on jealousy because, although its adherents are massively privileged, they’re generally half‑witted and unoriginal. 


The silencing comes from the intellectual inadequacy of the envious; well‑connected nobodies working at publishers bring down good writers while students too dim to convince de-platform great speakers. 


Of course, Burchill herself, a well-known author, did have a book canceled-- thus, her derision.


And yet, she is optimistic that this madness will soon pass:


Maybe it’s the weather, but it’s hard not to be cheerful at this sea‑change; the green shoots of freedom are poking through the leaden carapace of stagnation and soon the days when it is always winter and never Christmas may be done.


We can hope that she is right. Though we are less optimistic than she. If America’s failing culture is deciding that we need more wokeness, more indoctrination, more proselytizing-- it has learned precisely the wrong lesson.

Tuesday, March 23, 2021

Now Let Us Praise Naomi Wolf

Among the few encouraging signs at the current historical juncture are the number of liberal thinkers who have been standing up against the move toward totalitarianism.

During the Trump presidency, liberals and some more radical leftists like Matt Taibbi, Glenn Greenwald, Stephen Cohen, Aaron Mate, Jonathan Turley and Alan Dershowitz stood tall against the simple fact that Donald Trump was not being held to the same standards as were other presidents, or even other citizens. They denounced the Russia hoax and the impeachment charade, often more effectively than their conservative colleagues. They emphasized that the rule of law means that the same law should be applied equally to all citizens. They were not Trump supporters. They had not voted for Trump. Some admired some policies. Others disagreed with other policies. They were appalled at the way Trump was being treated, by the political class and in the media.


Naturally, as some of these writers moved away from the mainstream press onto platforms like Substack, the ever more fascistic left has tried to shut them down. They are happy to censor ideas they do not like. To them, freedom has become a four letter word. The fact that many of these writers have been staunch supporters of liberalism over the years does not count, now that they have exercised some independent judgment and intellectual integrity.


Now, we can add the name of one Naomi Wolf to the list. A staunch feminist, certainly not a member of the vast right wing conspiracy, Wolf was recently  temporarily banished from Twitter for the crime of appearing on the Tucker Carlson Show.


Her thought crime-- she sees America’ current cultural moment as fascistic and totalitarian. She abhors cancel culture because it violates liberal values concerning, for instance, the free trade in ideas. She refuses to accept government control over everyone’s behavior. 


In truth, as she reminds us in the current essay, she has been sounding the tocsin of alarm about America’s totalitarian leanings for years now. So, we grant her credit and add her to the list of the profiles in both integrity and courage. Here are some of the recent developments that she deplores.



Emergency measures in many states, which suspend due process of law. This is the hallmark of a police state. Covid-19 is invoked as the reason for the introduction of emergency law – but there is no endpoint for lifting these emergency laws.


The closures of schools, which break the social contract with the next generation.


Forced closures of businesses. By intervening directly in the economy and allowing certain businesses to flourish (Amazon, Wal-Mart, Target) at the expense of small businesses, Main Street shops, restaurants, and sole proprietor businesses in general, the State has merged government and corporations in a way that is characteristic of Italian fascism, or of modern Chinese communism. (Indeed the fact that tech stocks rose by 27% in one quarter of the pandemic shows one driver of this war against human freedoms and human society: every minute human beings spend in a classroom, at the pub or restaurant, or in a church or synagogue, is time that tech companies lose money by being unable to harvest that data. Covid policies driven by “Covid-19 Response” – tech companies – ensure that humans are not allowed to connect except via digital platforms. The reason is profit as well as social control).


Restrictions on assembly. Some states such as California are fining people for seeing their friends in their homes, and making it unlawful for kids to have playdates with their friends. 


Massachusetts restricted gatherings of more than ten people at a time, forcing synagogues and churches to stay closed, in spite of a Supreme Court ruling against states forcing churches to close. Parks, playgrounds and beaches have been closed off. In countries such as Britain, people are fined for leaving their homes for more than an hour’s exercise a day.


Forced face coverings. In Massachusetts, people are fined if they are not wearing masks outdoors – even children as young as five are forced to do so by law. Again this mandate has not been undergirded by peer-reviewed studies showing medical necessity; and there is no endpoint proffered for these extraordinary violations of personal freedom.


Suppression of free speech. Big Tech companies are censoring critics of Covid policy and vaccine policy, as well as censoring views that are on the right hand of the political spectrum. “Incitement,” a word that has a long history in the 20th century for closing down free speech, has been weaponized by the left to shut down First Amendment freedoms of expression. In other forms of censorship and management of speech and public debate, tycoons such as Bill Gates have been funding major news outlets, with millions of dollars directed to “Covid education.” As a result, dissenting voices are marginalized and shamed, or even threatened with legal action or job losses.


Science has been hijacked in the interests of “biofascism.” By heavily funding scientific commentators such as Dr Fauci in the United States, Imperial College and SAGE in the UK, and Dr Christian Drosten in Germany, a dominant set of policies and pronouncements about Covid that benefit a small group of bad actors – notably tech and pharmaceutical interests, acting in concert with governments – have had secured credentialled supporters. But when other scientists or institutions seek debate or transparency, they are threatened with job loss or reputationally attacked, as in the case of Dr Simon Goddeke of the Netherlands, who was told to keep quiet by his university, when he challenged the flawed Covid PCR test protocols.


She closes with the following reflection about masking the human face, point with which I concur, and point which has rarely been explained as clearly:


Masks break human beings’ ability to bond face-to-face and enjoy human contact, smiles and jokes. Masks turn down the effectiveness of human “technology,” by making it hard for us to “read” each other and to pick up social cues. Forbidding assembly keeps us from forming human alliances against these monstrous interests. Forbidding human assembly also prevents new cultures, new heroes and new business models from arising. We are all stuck with the Rolodex and the ideas we had in March of 2020.


So, we praise Naomi Wolf for her courage. She is doing what many others should be doing, denouncing the new American totalitarianism. Some will agree and some will disagree with the points she made. I have quoted most of them. And yet, she is now leading the debate that we should be having. Hats off to her.

Monday, March 22, 2021

The Whole World Is Watching

Back in the day, in 1968, protesters at the Democratic National Convention coined a slogan-- The whole world is watching.

They were referring to the oppressive tactics of the Chicago police department and were trying to shame Mayor Richard Daley and other Democratic officials.

Nowadays, as the United States descends into cultural senescence, the whole world is not just watching. It is also laughing at us.


For reasons that defy reason, we pride ourselves on our capacity for empathy, but we are completely incapable of judging how we look to other people. Of course, empathy is about feeling someone’s feelings. It takes more than sanctimoniously blubbering about feelings.


We have no idea of how we look to others because we are so chock full of self-esteem that we think that it doesn’t matter what other people think. We lack the analytic capacity to see ourselves through the world’s eyes.


Or else, we do not want to recognize that the rest of the world sees us as a broken and declining civilization. And that they do not want any part of it. Considering how poorly democracy works here it should surprise no one that other nations around the world are not buying it. 


We should have long since overcome the Hegelian illusion that the arc of history is inexorably moving toward liberal democracy. Apparently, we have not.


We recall that French intellectuals, seconded by the government of President Emmanuel Macron have labeled American wokeism a threat to everything they value. Their message to America-- keep your woke nonsense to yourself.


And now there is Baizuo. Tucker Carlson reported the other evening that the Chinese state media has a special name for wokeness. It’s Baizuo. Carlson said that it translates roughly as “white liberal” and it is not considered to be a compliment.


Some of us have been trying to warn others of us against adopting this mental deformity, to little avail. What constitutes Baizuo. Carlson explained:


“Here’s how Chinese state media describe baizuo,” Tucker began, quoting, “‘They are people who only care about topics such as immigration, minorities, LGBT and the environment, who have no sense of real problems in the real world, who only advocate for peace and equality to satisfy their own feelings of moral superiority and who are so obsessed with political correctness that they tolerate backward Islamic values for the sake of multiculturalism.'”


Hmmm. Sums it up well, don’t you think. We call it virtue signaling, and the Chinese understand it better than we do. Incapable of addressing the real problems of the real world-- which might those be?-- we are tolerant of backward Islamic values because we are multiculturalists.


Which values might they be? For instance, try the rape culture that Islamic migrants brought to Sweden. And what about the grooming gangs in England, the drug traffickers in Western Europe, the No-Go zones, the honor killings and female genital mutilation practiced in America and Europe. Let's not forget, even though it has nothing to do with Islamic values, but we are happy to mutilate children.


It’s not how we feel about ourselves. We feel great about ourselves. We have done lots and lots of therapy and we have learned to feel great about ourselves-- while the good ship USA is floundering on the reefs of multiculturalism.


Better yet, the Chinese state media has mocked us for refusing to tolerate differences of opinion. One might ask whether the Chinese media tolerates differences of opinion, but one does not read it often enough to have an opinion. One suspects that it is about as tolerant as the propaganda media in America. 


Carlson explains:


Carlson said that Chinese state media has criticized woke liberals in America because “they advocate inclusiveness and anti-discrimination but cannot tolerate different opinions. Baizuo political opinions are quote ‘so shallow that they tend to maintain social equality by embracing ideologies that run against the basic concept of equality.’ Amazing.”


Carlson concluded:


The Fox News host noted another description of baizuo as “phony and hypocritical and will make the situation in the West go from bad to worse.”


“Talk about insightful: they know our leaders well,” Carlson said. “So whatever you think of the Chinese, they’re definitely not stupid. And they’re on to something here,” he concluded.


Definitely not stupid. But, what does that make us?


As for the American propaganda media, why not introduce a few words from a dissent offered by a federal judge named Laurence Silberman last week. For the record he was echoing arguments offered by Justice Clarence Thomas.


His description of the one-sided and one-minded American media correlates well with the Chinese view. For the record he was addressing the Supreme Court decision, Sullivan v. The New York Times which allowed the media to defame public figures with near impunity. It was the story of the Trump presidency.


While we are mentioning the unprecedented abuse the American media heaped on Donald Trump, we will again remind readers that the magical mystical powers of empathy caused many of Trump's supporters to feel empathy for him. And that has led them to feel righteously angry at the media and Democratic politicians for their abusive behavior.


Back to the Sullivan case, the defendant in a defamation or libel has to prove actual malice. Judge Silberman explained his position, arguing that the Sullivan decision should be reconsidered:


The increased power of the press is so dangerous today because we are very close to one-party control of these institutions. Our court was once concerned about the institutional consolidation of the press leading to a “bland and homogenous” marketplace of ideas. 


While we deplore the one-party control of the Chinese media, we are not very far from it ourselves:


Although the bias against the Republican Party—not just controversial individuals—is rather shocking today, this is not new; it is a long-term, secular trend going back at least to the ’70s. (I do not mean to defend or criticize the behavior of any particular politician). Two of the three most influential papers (at least historically), The New York Times and The Washington Post, are virtually Democratic Party broadsheets. And the news section of The Wall Street Journal leans in the same direction. The orientation of these three papers is followed by The Associated Press and most large papers across the country (such as the Los Angeles Times, Miami Herald, and Boston Globe). Nearly all television—network and cable—is a Democratic Party trumpet. Even the government-supported National Public Radio follows along.


As has become apparent, Silicon Valley also has an enormous influence over the distribution of news. And it similarly filters news delivery in ways favorable to the Democratic Party. See Kaitlyn Tiffany, Twitter Goofed It, The Atlantic (2020) (“Within a few hours, Facebook announced that it would limit [a New York Post] story’s spread on its platform while its third-party fact-checkers somehow investigated the information. Soon after, Twitter took an even more dramatic stance: Without immediate public explanation, it completely banned users from posting the link to the story.”).


It is well-accepted that viewpoint discrimination “raises the specter that the Government may effectively drive certain ideas or viewpoints from the marketplace.” R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul, Minn., 505 U.S. 377, 387 (1992). But ideological homogeneity in the media—or in the channels of information distribution—risks repressing certain ideas from the public consciousness just as surely as if access were restricted by the government.


To be sure, there are a few notable exceptions to Democratic Party ideological control: Fox News, The New York Post, and The Wall Street Journal’s editorial page. It should be sobering for those concerned about news bias that these institutions are controlled by a single man and his son. Will a lone holdout remain in what is otherwise a frighteningly orthodox media culture? After all, there are serious efforts to muzzle Fox News. And although upstart (mainly online) conservative networks have emerged in recent years, their visibility has been decidedly curtailed by Social Media, either by direct bans or content-based censorship.


Judge Silberman concludes:


The First Amendment guarantees a free press to foster a vibrant trade in ideas. But a biased press can distort the marketplace. And when the media has proven its willingness—if not eagerness—to so distort, it is a profound mistake to stand by unjustified legal rules that serve only to enhance the press’ power.


Democracy dies in darkness, the Washington Post tells us, but why then is it actively working to turn out the lights on the free marketplace of ideas.