Saturday, November 12, 2022

A Shakespearean Trump

In the aftermath of Tuesday’s less-than-satisfactory election outcome, Donald Trump went all Shakespearean. That is, he dialed up the drama, made it all about him, and attacked fellow Republicans Gov. Ron DeSantis and Gov. Glenn Youngkin. 

At the very least, it was strange behavior. Calling DeSantis, DeSanctimonious was simply off. Criticizing Youngkin because his name sounded Chinese suggested that Trump had spent so much time marinating in his grievances that he lost the thread. His much vaunted capacity for diminishing his opponents suddenly started looking stale and unengaging.


After all, these two men were being touted as the future of the Republican Party. Donald Trump was raging because he had just been relegated to the past. Yesterday’s news, as it were.


It was not unTrumpian. After all, Trump chose and excluded candidates based on whether they accepted or rejected his assertion that the election of 2020 had been stolen. He may or may not have been right. And yet, it still begs the question: what should we do if we could prove that the Biden people had stolen the election. Erase the past two years and go back to the future? You know and I know that this is not going to happen. Still, nursing  grievance, whether it defines woke culture, or a stolen election, bespeaks a failure to engage with the present. 


To be fair, it makes for great drama, even great Shakespearean drama. Old King Lear, dispossessed of his ruling authority, naked on the heath, railing against the storm-- the one that he is powerless to influence.


The more pundits and politicians declare Trump to be yesterday's news, the more noise he makes, the more he tries to make it all about him. The fact that his epithets about his prospective opponents fall flat tells us that he is beyond his time. That he has passed from leadership to its theatrical representation.


After all, if you want to lead you need to bring people together. You need to convince them that you are all working together to a common purpose, a purpose that rises beyond personal self-aggrandizement. If you succeed at the expense of your colleagues, if you make it all about you and not about them, the chances are good that they, weighed down by insult and invective, are less motivated to do their best work.


If your boss views you with contempt, will you make the extra effort to make him look good?


Donald Trump divided the world into winners and losers. He understood that America had been declining because it could not win wars. It was losing out in competition because it had become too squeamish to compete.


Then again, there is more to life, and even to executive work, than winning. There is-- governing. Ron DeSantis rose above the din and turned Florida bright red because he took charge. He knew how to govern, and possessed a quality that is so rare among leaders who aspire to be petty tyrants.


Recall Hurricane Ian, a massive challenge for any executive. And recall the DeSantis press briefings about the storm. Without going into too much detail, you must recall that the Florida governor had a full and complete command of the relevant information, including a predicted damage assessment and all of the resources that the state would marshal to protect the citizenry. It was an object lesson in good governance. The governor rattled off facts and figures as though he was in charge. Clearly, the people of Florida were grateful to be in such good hands. There was no drama. He was not out on the heath railing against Nature with requisite macho bravado. 


We saw a governor who was working for the people. It made perfectly good sense that the people of Florida rewarded him and his party last Tuesday.

Friday, November 11, 2022

The Lesson for Democrats

Joe Biden, who barely seems to know where he is or where he is going, thought that it was a triumph. He believed that the good showing Democrats had made in Tuesday’s election vindicated his presidency. Other Democratic politicians seem happy to jump on the bandwagon.

Joel Kotkin, however, sees things differently. Whatever the reasons for the relatively strong showings of Democrats on Tuesday, they were not a vote of confidence in today’s Democratic Party. If party leaders follow Biden’s cue and try to do more of the same they are consigning themselves to oblivion. Which, come to think of it, is not such a bad idea.


Kotkin notes that a motley band of progressives remains a dominant faction in the party. This despite the fact that their policy proposals are wildly unpopular.


So, rather than using the next two years to regroup and craft a political programme that could win the next election, the Democrats now appear stuck with a weak leader who appears unfit to deal with the global challenges that will define America in the coming decade. Internally, too, the Democrats look increasingly unstable. A stronger-than-expected Midterms performance doesn’t mask the fact that the progressives remain a dominant faction in the party — with an associated agenda that, outside of deep blue-college towns and core cities, commands remarkably low levels of support, as Barack Obama and others have warned.


Take the anti-work, anti-energy green agenda being promoted by the Squad. We can always ask about Europe's green energy present-- do we want it as your future. It is anti-economic growth:


Over time, the economic implications of Biden’s green agenda may be obvious, but for now they are hidden amid massive deficits and increased transfer payments. However, as Democratic strategist Ruy Teixeira has noted, in the longer run, the party’s emphasis on “de-growth” and austerity is unlikely to attract middle and particularly working-class voters. Already, the political implications of climate policy have ruined the Democrats’ best chance to take the GOP seat in Ohio. Their candidate Tim Ryan may have claimed to support fracking, but his backing of the Pelosi Congressional agenda proved disastrous in a state whose economy is fuelled by natural gas production and hopes to attract new investment, including a possible $20 billion new Intel chip plant in the Columbus suburbs. In Florida, meanwhile, Ron DeSantis won heavily in Latino, historically Democratic regions.


And let’s not ignore the radical leftists who seem to be holding sway in our school system. What are people going to think when they discover that the armies of anti-racist social justice warriors are fundamentally useless in the world economy, and that American jobs will be fleeing the nation, in search of friendlier climes, and in search of competent workers. Until the new order arrives, you cannot vote yourself a living.





Thursday, November 10, 2022

Had Enough Trump?

Five weeks ago I pointed out, on the basis of a New York Post article, that President Trump had lost Rupert Murdoch. Some commenters took vigorous exception to the notion, and I should have been clearer that I was describing, not prescribing the state of things in the media world.

By now, however, the fact that Murdoch media has moved beyond Trump is self-evident. Everyone is writing about it.


Most salient is the fact that, yesterday, in the aftermath of the less than satisfactory Midterm election results, the Murdoch flagship, the Wall Street Journal declared Trump “the biggest loser” last Tuesday. 


The Journal is editorializing that it is time for the Republican Party to move on from Trump.


It begins in New Hampshire:


Trumpy Republican candidates failed at the ballot box in states that were clearly winnable. 


Looking at the Senate map, the message could not be clearer. In New Hampshire, the Trump-endorsed Republican Don Bolduc lost to Sen. Maggie Hassan, 53% to 45%, as of the latest data. At the same time voters re-elected Republican Gov. Chris Sununu by 16 points.


And then it moves on to Arizona:


In Arizona the Trump-endorsed Republican Blake Masters trails Sen. Mark Kelly, 51% to 47%. This is a state successful Gov. Doug Ducey won by 14 points in 2018. Mr. Ducey could have won the Senate seat, but Mr. Trump pledged to go to war with him because Mr. Ducey refused to entertain 2020 fraud theories.


Pennsylvania:


In Pennsylvania, the Trump-endorsed Republican Mehmet Oz lost to John Fetterman, 51% to 47%. This is a tough state for the GOP. But Mr. Fetterman was a weak candidate: He’s a lefty with a record of wanting Medicare for All and a ban on fracking, and he’s recovering from a stroke. David McCormick would have been a better Republican nominee, but he wouldn’t say the 2020 election was stolen, so Mr. Trump endorsed Mr. Oz.


And then, Herschel Walker in Georgia:


Mr. Walker’s flaws as a candidate were obvious, but Mr. Trump helped clear the primary field and other candidates opted out.


Ohio:


In Ohio the Trump-endorsed Republican J.D. Vance won a solid victory over Rep. Tim Ryan, 53% to 47%, while Republican Gov. Mike DeWine won by 26 points. Mr. Vance was a poor fundraiser. As of Oct. 19 he’d pulled in $12 million to Mr. Ryan’s $47 million. What saved him was $32 million from the Senate Leadership Fund (SLF), a Super Pac aligned with Mitch McConnell. Mr. Vance trailed in the polls until mid-October.


And various other calamities:


Doug Mastriano, Pennsylvania’s Trump-endorsed gubernatorial choice, lost by 14 points. Tim Michels in Wisconsin and Tudor Dixon in Michigan fumbled winnable gubernatorial races. Also in Michigan, Mr. Trump helped John Gibbs beat GOP Rep. Peter Meijer in the primary in the Grand Rapids seat because Mr. Meijer voted to impeach him. Mr. Gibbs lost by 13 points. Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler also voted to impeach Mr. Trump, who helped Joe Kent beat her in a primary. Mr. Kent is trailing in that Washington state district.


Mr. Trump could have stayed quiet in the final weeks of the campaign except to spend money to help his candidates. But he did little of the latter and instead staged rallies that played into Democratic hands. His rally in Latrobe last week might have hurt Mr. Oz with suburban voters who cost Mr. Trump the state in 2020.


It is not news. Since he won in 2016 Trump has a poor track record of advancing Republican candidates:


Since his unlikely victory in 2016 against the widely disliked Hillary Clinton, Mr. Trump has a perfect record of electoral defeat. The GOP was pounded in the 2018 midterms owing to his low approval rating. Mr. Trump himself lost in 2020. He then sabotaged Georgia’s 2021 runoffs by blaming party leaders for not somehow overturning his defeat. That gave Democrats control of the Senate, letting President Biden pump up inflation with a $1.9 trillion Covid bill, appoint a liberal Supreme Court Justice, and pass a $700 billion climate spending hash.


Now Mr. Trump has botched the 2022 elections, and it could hand Democrats the Senate for two more years. Mr. Trump had policy successes as President, including tax cuts and deregulation, but he has led Republicans into one political fiasco after another.


“We’re going to win so much,” Mr. Trump once said, “that you’re going to get sick and tired of winning.” Maybe by now Republicans are sick and tired of losing.


End of story.


Wednesday, November 9, 2022

What Now for Trump?

Jack Newman’s article for the Daily Mail feels rather typical. Yesterday was not a great day for the Republican Party. It was not a great day for its putative leader, Donald Trump. And, of course, it was a great day for Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. 

Whereas many of Trump’s chosen candidates showed themselves to be lesser vote-getters, DeSantis and his fellow Florida Republicans swept into power.


Clearly, Trump has been showing that he believes DeSantis to be the most significant obstacle to his restoration. Just as clearly, as most commentators have argued, Trump chose candidates and held numerous rallies in order to make it all about him. 


When Trump kept teasing an announcement next week, everyone was distracted from the elections. Did the distraction cause Democrats to vote, not for Republican candidates, but against Donald Trump.


Or, are the Republicans just looking for a convenient scapegoat:


Donald Trump is under fire from Republicans who blame their poorer than expected showing in the midterm elections on the controversial former president.


The GOP kingmaker endorsed around 300 candidates, held 30 rallies and raised millions of dollars, hoping to demonstrate his continued MAGA influence that could spark another bid for the White House.


But it appears his Midas touch is waning with many of his preferred candidates failing to win seats, although others such as JD Vance secured victory, with more results incoming.


Some have criticized Trump for foisting sub-standard candidates on the Party. Since Trump himself was a rank amateur who showed no respect for politicians, perhaps he was trying to prove a point-- he proposed a band of amateurs in order to vindicate his own presidency. If people who were  modeled on Trump could triumph, then perhaps it would prove him right and prove the politicians wrong.


Erick Erickson, a longtime GOP commentator, told the Washington Post: 'Candidate quality matters. 


'They weren't good candidates. They had more allegiance to him than anything else. The GOP might still win both [chambers] but this is not the night they expected.' 


Through these candidates, Trump drew attention to himself:


Bill Palatucci, a member of the Republican National Committee from New Jersey, said: 'Trump candidates were a drag on the party and the messaging of all our candidates.


'We were constantly having to distance ourselves from their support of the former president.' 


Trump's picks lost high-stakes contests in Pennsylvania, Michigan and New Hampshire. 


So, last night Trump threw a party for journalists and supporters. Doubtless he planned to emerge triumphant and to top off the evening by teasing his next candidacy:


After summoning reporters and his most loyal supporters to a watch party at his Mar-a-Lago club, he ended the night without a triumphant speech. 


Nonetheless, he took to his social media platform to insist he'd had 'A GREAT EVENING.' 


As they say, you win some and you lose some. Among Trump’s winning candidates were JD Vance and Ted Budd:


It wasn't all gloom for Trump, as he helped lift Republican Senate candidates to victory in Ohio and North Carolina. 

JD Vance, the bestselling author of 'Hillbilly Elegy,' defeated 10-term congressman Tim Ryan, while Rep. Ted Budd beat Cheri Beasley, the former chief justice of the state Supreme Court. 


While campaigning for Vance on Monday, Trump teased an announcement for his presidential run.


'We want nothing to detract from the importance of tomorrow. You understand that,' Trump said at a rally. 


'I'm going to be making a very big announcement on Tuesday, November 15,' he added, saying the announcement would come at his Mar-a-Lago property in Florida. 


Now, we will see what happens on November 15. Don’t be surprised if Trump postpones his announcement. 


Longtime GOP strategist Douglas Heye told DailyMail.com Trump was a distraction for many voters.


He said: 'When someone says they don't want to detract, get ready for some detracting.


'Trump is all about Trump and after months of being on the sidelines - good months for Republicans - Trump had to make it all about him. Again.' 


Whereas Ronald Reagan had declared that Republicans should never speak ill of another Republican, Donald Trump is happy to violate this commandment. Before last night he was getting ready to go on the attack against Ron DeSantis:


For his part, Trump sees the danger and has been firing shots across the governor's bows.


At a rally in Pennsylvania on Saturday, Trump unveiled a new nickname for him: 'Ron DeSanctimonious.' 


And on Monday he issued a veiled threat.


'I don't know that he's running. I think if he runs he could hurt himself very badly, I really believe he could hurt himself badly,' said Trump.


He went on hint he was ready to go on the attack with personal details. 


'But if he did run I could tell you things bout him that won't be very flattering. I know more about him other than perhaps his wife - who's really running about his campaign. 


Ready to get down into the gutter with DeSantis, Trump now has the chance to change his mind. I will not try to offer any further interpretation, but I am curious to read what some of you think of it all.


Tuesday, November 8, 2022

When the Gender Continuum Replaced the Gender Binary

Luana Maroja is a distinguished scientist, a professor of biology at Williams College. As you must know, Williams is a distinguished small college located in Williamstown, MA.

We care about it all because yesterday Maroya wrote a fascinating essay of how biology is taught at Williams, and not just at Williams. It appeared on Bari Weiss’s Substack, Common Sense.

If you had been dismayed to discover that medical schools have been admitting candidate physicians in order to achieve diversity and that scientific journals have been selecting and rejecting submitted articles on the basis of the author’s skin color, now you have one more sign that American medical science is circling the drain.

In the past, diversity programs were largely limited to the Humanities and Social Sciences. Having wrecked those two noble disciplines, it has now trained its sights on science.

It has discovered that science is racist and sexist. It proposes as a solution-- gas lighting. Since reality does not fulfill their ideologically driven predicates, scientists create an alternative reality, and insist that everyone act as though it were the real thing.

To be more precise, gender, the division of the sexes into a binary, has now been rejected. In its place we have the concept of a “continuum” between different versions of maleness and different versions of femaleness. In principle, this concept of a continuum allows children greater latitude in choosing their sex.

Presumably, the goal of scientific research involves therapy. It is also very useful if you want to groom young children in the ways of polymorphous perversity.

Maroja explains the reality of biological sex difference. Nothing about this changes if you change your mind:

One of the most fundamental rules of biology from plants to humans is that the sexes are defined by the size of their gametes—that is, their reproductive cells. Large gametes occur in females; small gametes in males. In humans, an egg is 10 million times bigger than a sperm. There is zero overlap. It is a full binary. 

But in some biology 101 classes, teachers are telling students that sexes—not gender, sex—are on a continuum. At least one college I know teaches with the “gender unicorn” and informs students that it is bigoted to think that humans come in two distinct and discrete sexes. 

Apparently, continuum theory is all the rage. You must believe it. If believing it compromises your research, too bad:

Even medical schools and the Society for the Study of Evolution have issued statements suggesting that sexes are on a “continuum.” If this were true, the entire field of sexual selection would be baseless, as its bedrock insight lies in the much larger female investment in reproduction, explaining the demonstrated choosiness in females (who have more to lose) and competitiveness in males (the “abundant” sex in most species, one male can fertilize multiple females). Published papers (see here, for example) ask us to be “inclusive” by limiting the sex discussion to the few species of algae and protists (such as amoebas) that have equal size gametes—even when that has no relevance to any animal or vascular plant. 

It does not stop there. Enforcing the new reality, ensuring that everyone accepts the alternate reality, becomes a consuming project:

I had a colleague who, during a conference, was criticized for studying female sexual selection in insects because he was a male. Another was discouraged from teaching the important concept of “sexual conflict”—the idea that male and female interests differ and mates will often act selfishly; think of a female praying mantis decapitating the head of the male after mating—because it might “traumatize students.” I was criticized for teaching “kin selection”—the the idea that animals tend to help their relatives. Apparently this was somehow an endorsement of Donald Trump hiring his daughter Ivanka.

So, people live in a world where their speech is policed all the time, and when they often do not know what will or will not trigger a traumatic reaction.

The language purity that this ideology requires is also distressing. It gets in the way of spontaneity and good teaching. At Williams, for example, our teaching assistants were told at a DEI training session that the word “guys” is a microaggression. So students learn that inoffensive words are harmful. This leads to a snowball effect, where ever more insignificant words or gestures can be taken as proof of bigotry. Many professors I know will freeze in class when realizing they were praising the work of a “colonialist” such as Darwin or Newton. Others will avoid mentioning historical figures if they are white and male. 

Thus does education in the sciences die at Williams College.

The prestigious journal Nature Human Behavior just announced in a recent editorial: “Although academic freedom is fundamental, it is not unbounded.” They are not referring to the importance of protecting individuals participating in research. They are saying that the study of human variation is itself suspect. So they advocate avoiding research that could “stigmatize individuals or human groups” or “promotes privileged, exclusionary perspectives.”

The censors and gatekeepers simply assume—without evidence—that human population research is malign and must be shut down. The costs of this kind of censorship, both self-imposed and ideologically based, are profound. Student learning is impaired and important research is never done. The dangers of closing off so many avenues of inquiry is that science itself becomes an extension of ideology and is no longer an endeavor predicated on pursuing knowledge and truth.

Students who are force-fed the ideology never really learn to think. They do not learn how to test ideas against experience or experiment. They are apparently not smart enough to evaluate different hypotheses and to test them before choosing to believe one and not the other. They learn how to memorize an ideologically driven script and to apply it indiscriminately to all things, great and small, living and dead.

 


Monday, November 7, 2022

The War against Coal

 An amusing thought, and some hard facts, regarding coal power plants, from a Canadian, Patrick Moore’s twitter:


What Did They Know, and When Did They Know it?

What did they know and when did they know it?

You recall my recent post about an article written by Brown University professor Emily Oster. In it she suggests that we offer blanket amnesty to the civil authorities who botched the covid response so badly. They were using the best science, so we need forgive them their failings. No one knew any better.

It was a dumb idea, and I commented on it three days ago. Now, for our general edification the Brownstone Institute (via Maggie’s Farm) has compiled a series of links that expose what we knew about the virus. That these opinions do not correlate with the actions of our bureaucrats draws our attention. In truth, they knew better and they ignored what they knew. 

I offer them for your interest, without commentary:

2019: WHO Global Influenza Programme recommends against lockdowns and masks

 

Sept 2019: Johns Hopkins pandemic preparedness study recommends against lockdowns

 

Jan 20: Obama health adviser says stop panicking

 

Jan 24: Doctor warns that mass quarantine won’t work and will devastate society

 

Feb 5: Fauci says there’s no asymptomatic spread

 

Feb 28: Fauci says this is more akin to flu than something more deadly

 

Mar: 81% of Chinese Covid cases are mild

 

Mar 1: Sweden: No effective measure to let healthy school children stay at home

 

Mar 2: Discussion on how Covid IFR was likely much lower than predicted

 

Mar 2: 800 public health scientists warn against lockdowns, quartantines, restrictions

 

Mar 3: Article on why masks are impractical

 

Mar 3: Berkeley doctor indicates masks are not helpful in preventing Covid

 

Mar 4: Doctor says Covid not nearly as deadly as feared

 

Mar 4: Your doctor is not panicking and neither should you

 

Mar 9: Article on how Covid is only really dangerous to the elderly

 

Mar 9: Doctor talking about unnecessary panic over Covid

 

Mar 12: Review found severe mental health problems from prolonged quarantine

 

Mar 12: Chief medical officer saying people shouldn’t wear masks

 

Mar 15: Medical org. says stopping elective surgeries is unnecessary and dangerous

 

Mar 17: Covid response is focused on the wrong things

 

Mar 17: Warning of financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric

 

Mar 19: Article about Covid overaction and its issues

 

Mar 25: Data about the health impacts of crushing the economy

 

Mar 26: Early evidence of hospitals inaccurately listing Covid as cause of death

 

Mar 26: Early data shows we’re overreacting to Covid

 

Mar 28: Predictions about the harms of lockdowns: Drugs, Suicide, and Crime

 

Mar 28: Guardian outlines rise in domestic abuse throughout the world

 

Mar 30: Study showing children are not the primary spreader of Covid

 

Apr 1: Article saying masks offer little to no advantage outside of hospital settings

 

Apr 3: An overview on the dangers of Lockdowns

 

Apr 4: Warning of the harm in delaying non-Covid medical procedures

 

Apr 4: Study from China finds of 7,324 COVID-19 cases only 2 transmissions occurred outdoors

 

Apr 6: U.N. warns about domestic violence surge

 

Apr 6: Piece on domestic abuse during lockdown

 

Apr 7: Piece on the mental health cost of the lockdown on kids

 

Apr 8: Research showing the seasonality of Coronaviruses

 

Apr 13: More confirmation about domestic abuse rising due to lockdowns

 

Apr 14: Children are very unlikely to contract Covid

 

Apr 15: Barely any transmission from outdoor activities

 

Apr 15: Different approaches by countries have little impact on Covid deaths

 

Apr 15: Molecular Biologist suggests the cure is worse than the disease

 

Apr 16: Research showing school lockdowns aren’t helpful and cause great harm

 

Apr 16: UN overview about the poverty/death that will come from lockdowns

 

Apr 16: CDC mask study concludes that masks don’t work

 

Apr 17: Info on how damaging canceled procedures are

 

Apr 20: Oxford professor says cases in UK peaked before lockdown

 

Apr 22: Potential for 60,000 cancer deaths due to lack of screening/treatment

 

Apr 23: The harm lockdowns are having on people with heart conditions

 

Apr 24: Data on the mental health toll of lockdowns

 

Apr 24: Indications from Europe that lockdowns are ineffective

 

Apr 24: Study showing school closings are the least cost-effective pandemic policy

 

Apr 26: The rise of domestic abuse during lockdowns

 

Apr 26: Data that the infection rate from kids is extremely low

 

Apr 28: Increasing child abuse is a side effect of Covid lockdowns

 

Apr 29: Cancer deaths could increase by 20% due to lockdown

 

Nov 20: No evidence of asymptomatic spread in study of 10M Wuhan residents